What to measure
Govern spend by contribution margin dollars, and set every efficiency and acquisition target from it. Judge customers by margin and payback over months, not by first-order cost.
12 answers · 3 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026
The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 12 answers below.
Govern total spend by contribution margin dollars, adding spend only while total contribution margin rises against a monthly target.
Set your blended efficiency target from your own margin, and recompute every target as soon as a cost change such as a tariff lands.
From Setting a blended efficiency target, Targets when margins change
Aim to earn back a new customer's acquisition cost in contribution margin within 3 to 6 months, read from first-order cohorts.
From Payback period for new customers, Measuring customer lifetime value
Report new and returning revenue as separate lines, net of discounts and returns.
From New and repeat revenue in reporting, Discounts and returns in marketing metrics
The 12 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Set the governing target
The metric that governs spend and the targets you derive from it.
Which single business metric should govern total marketing spend?
Govern total spend by contribution margin in dollars. Add spend only while total contribution margin rises against a monthly target. Derive your ad efficiency and new-customer cost ceilings from it, and check you can fund the payback in cash.
Medium confidence · 14 sources
How should we set a target for blended marketing efficiency at our margin?
Set your target for total sales divided by total ad spend (MER) from your margin. Break-even is 1 divided by contribution margin before ads. The target is planned revenue over the ad budget left after fixed costs and profit.
Medium confidence · 14 sources
How should we set marketing targets when margins change, for example from tariffs?
Recompute your marketing targets from the new contribution margin as soon as a cost change such as a tariff lands. Reset break-even, CAC ceiling and platform targets, by product where margins differ, and judge spend on contribution dollars.
Updated Nov 18 Medium confidence · 13 sources
Track customer value
Lifetime value, payback and how subscribers compare with one-time buyers.
How should we measure customer lifetime value, and over how many months?
Measure lifetime value as contribution margin per first-order cohort, compared at the same age. Read it at 30, 90 and 180 days to steer spend, and plan on 12 months of realized data.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
How fast should a new customer pay back their acquisition cost?
Aim to earn back a new customer's acquisition cost in contribution margin within 3 to 6 months. Past 6 months, fix retention and margin before adding spend. Past 12 months, restructure before scaling.
Updated Nov 18 Medium confidence · 14 sources
How should we measure the cost of acquiring a subscriber versus a one-time buyer?
Measure one cost per new customer. Tag each by how they started (subscribed first, subscribed later, one-time only). Compare their contribution margin and payback at six and twelve months, not their first-order cost.
Medium confidence · 8 sources
Build the reports
What goes in reports and how to treat new customers, discounts, returns and cash.
How should we separate new-customer revenue from repeat revenue in reporting?
Report new and returning revenue as separate lines. Count a customer as new only on their first order in your store. Judge acquisition on new-customer CAC and acquisition MER, not total sales divided by total ad spend (MER).
Medium confidence · 17 sources
Which metrics belong in a weekly marketing review?
Review the same short set every week in a fixed order. Go from revenue, spend and MER to new and returning customers, channel mix, creative, tracking health and written decisions. Leave cohort value and payback to the monthly review.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
How should we account for discounts and returns in marketing metrics?
Judge marketing on store net revenue after discounts and returns. Count each discount once, in CAC or first-order margin, book expected returns when you report, and restate campaigns once their returns land.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
Should we report marketing results on a cash basis or on contribution margin?
Report marketing on contribution margin, with sales and their costs counted in the month of the sale, not on bank deposits or revenue. Keep a separate cash view of payback and runway to decide how much spend you can fund.
Medium confidence · 8 sources
Value leads for bidding
Which lead value and CRM step to send to Meta and Google.
How should we give each new lead a predicted value and send it to Meta and Google, so they bid for valuable leads instead of cheap ones?
Give each lead a value when it arrives: its chance of closing times the sale. Send it to Google once you have 2 or more distinct values, and to Meta through value rules or its predicted value option.
Medium confidence · 10 sources
When sales close weeks or months after the lead, which early actions best predict a lead will close, and how do we prove one before optimizing on it?
Optimize for the latest CRM step that arrives within 7 days on Google or 28 days on Meta and reaches about 50 a week per ad set. Check its timing and fit on past leads, then test it.
Updated Nov 18 Medium confidence · 12 sources
More in Measurement
69 answers in 10 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to tell if your ad spend is working · How to market a lead-gen business on Meta and Google · How to market a local service business