How should we give each new lead a predicted value and send it to Meta and Google, so they bid for valuable leads instead of cheap ones?
Our answer
Give each lead a value when it arrives: its chance of closing times the sale. Send it to Google once you have 2 or more distinct values, and to Meta through value rules or its predicted value option.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 10 official rules
- 9 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 22 statements
- G
M
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle lets you bid on lead scores and lead form answers. It asks for 2 or more distinct non-zero values, uploaded for at least 4 weeks or 3 conversion cycles, and 15 conversions a month across the account before switching.
Meta bids on a CRM stage unless you clear a high bar. Its qualified-lead goal optimizes on a CRM stage. Its predicted value option requires at least 5 distinct values, the highest at least 3 times the lowest, and 100 Meta-attributed conversions a week.
Practitioners value a lead as its close rate times what a customer is worth (Elevarus, AdAdvisor, Jon Loomer). Elevarus, which sells lead gen media, sends that value at qualification and corrects it when the sale closes.
Our judgment
- Build a few clearly different lead values from groups you can see when a lead arrives. Use each group's close rate times its average sale, or margin if you compute it, by service asked for, form answers, location and source. Elevarus warns that garbage values produce garbage optimization, and in Admoon's account one region's leads closed almost twice as often.
- Send the value on the CRM step that Early signs a lead will close picks and correct it as sales close. That means the lead itself while it is the bid goal, or the qualified stage once it has the volume. Google allows conversion adjustments up to 55 days but bidding reads them only within 7 days (Offline and return-adjusted conversions).
- Leave out a lead you would reject rather than sending it at zero, and keep the lowest real value above zero. Google advises removing zero-value conversions and Meta's predicted value option needs positive values, though Kalungi gives junk leads zero.
- On Meta, keep the qualified-lead goal on the step from Early signs a lead will close and put value differences into value rules. Use rules for groups your sales show close less, since Jon Loomer uses value rules only when you have information Meta lacks. Try predicted value only once you clear Meta's weekly conversion bar for 4 weeks, as a test against your current campaign.
- Check the values on past leads, then switch on value bidding on Google in a campaign experiment. Confirm higher-valued groups did close more often or for more (Building predicted lifetime value for Meta), since Elevarus warns an unchecked proxy drifts. Allow at least 2 weeks or 3 conversion cycles, judge on cost per closed sale. Expect cost per lead to rise, as Elevarus says it may while cost per booked job falls.
Our judgment, built from Elevarus, AdAdvisor, Jon Loomer, Google, Admoon, Meta, Kalungi and PPC Land: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
22 statements from 10 sourcesGoogle says to feed lead values such as revenue, lead scores or proxies back daily, avoid zero-value conversions, and before switching, track 2+ distinct values for 4 weeks or 3 conversion cycles.
“If exact values are challenging to determine, utilize proxy values that align with your business priorities.”
Google says that if you can give leads different values, use value-based bidding with conversion value rules; if quality matters but values don't vary, bid to target CPA on qualified or converted leads.
“If lead quality is important to you, but you aren’t able to assign distinct values per conversion, we recommend using target cost-per-acquisition bidding for qualified or converted leads.”
Google suggests enhanced conversions for leads, optimized to qualified or converted leads, with uploads at least daily for 1 to 2 conversion cycles before bidding on them. A spreadsheet can stand in for a CRM.
“Upload conversions at least daily.”
Google Ads won't import offline conversions uploaded more than 90 days after the last click, or 63 days for enhanced conversions for leads. The longer clicks take to convert, the longer full numbers take.
“To validate whether your conversion imports are working, use the "All conv. (by conv. time)" column.”
Google lets you retract or restate conversions by order ID or click ID within 54 days, but automated bidding reads changes only within 7 days; upload at least 24 hours after the conversion.
“Retracting removes a conversion completely from your reports.”
Google says conversion value rules adjust value by location, device or audience at auction time for Smart Bidding, but Smart Bidding already uses those signals when the difference shows in reporting.
“If a user in one of those segments converts better, and this is reflected in your reporting, Smart Bidding already accounts for that.”
PPC Land explains that value-based bidding predicts both conversion odds and value; lead gen advertisers can use lead scores or form-answer values, but long sales cycles starve the model.
“Attributed value is not caused value”
Search Engine Roundtable reports Google Ads lead form assets now let you mark which answers qualify a lead, up to 12 answers per question, for lead scoring.
“You can add up to 12 answers per question and check off whether they qualify under the lead scoring section.”
To optimize lead ads to a CRM stage, Meta requires at least 200 leads a month, a stage that 1% to 40% of leads reach within 28 days, and CRM uploads at least daily. It gives no performance figures.
“Generate at least 200 leads per month”
Google's Lead Intent Scores label each lead form submission high, medium or low intent from Google's signals, to help sales prioritize outreach. The page does not say the scores feed bidding.
“We have introduced a new scoring system that categorizes every submission as high, medium or low intent.”
AdAdvisor says to judge Meta costs against your own break-even, not industry medians. For lead gen, max CPL is close rate times profit per customer, so 10% of $1,000 allows $100.
“Compare to your break-even, not the average.”
Admoon, a Google Ads agency, says to start value rules with conservative multipliers backed by CRM data, review them at least quarterly, and not treat higher reported ROAS as proof of more revenue.
“A higher reported ROAS does not necessarily prove that revenue increased.”
Kalungi, a B2B agency, says to pass a CRM-based value with each lead and give junk leads zero; sending every lead the same value defeats value optimization. Google advises against zero values.
“Teams turn on value-based optimization but keep sending every lead through with the same non-zero value, defeating the entire purpose.”
Jon Loomer asks two questions before a value rule: do you know something Meta doesn't, and is the problem proven in data? He cuts bids on 65+ leads only when Meta spends a large share there.
“unless Meta is actually spending a large percentage of my budget there, there is no problem to be solved”
Jon Loomer relays two unconfirmed Meta tests: marking preferred Instant Form answers so Meta learns from them, and crediting an ad only when two events happen in order. Meta has no documentation on either.
“Your ad is credited only if both events occur in the order you define.”
Jon Loomer says to start lead forms with the fewest questions and add controls like SMS verification only once data shows a quality problem, aiming for 50 optimized events per ad set per week.
“Your goal should always be to get 50 optimized events per ad set per week.”
Jon Loomer says not to chase a generic cost per lead: work out average lead value from the share of leads that convert, and set a target cost per lead from that.
“even a cost per lead under $1 is pointless if none of those leads does anything of value”
Meta's pLTV guide lets advertisers optimize to their own predicted lifetime values. It needs a web Conversions API setup, at least 5 distinct positive values, and 100+ Meta-attributed conversions a week for 4 weeks.
“a minimum of 100 conversion events per week attributed to Meta for each of the last 4 weeks.”
Meta's predicted lifetime value guide needs 100 Meta-attributed conversions a week for 4 weeks and at least 5 distinct values, and says to allow about 2 weeks of training and compare against a baseline.
“Comparing ROAS across different optimization settings is not accurate”
Elevarus, which sells lead gen services, says to value each lead stage at average sale times close rate (a booking that closes 40% of the time is worth 40% of the sale) and true it up to real revenue later.
“A proxy that is never trued up against real outcomes drifts, and the algorithm chases a number that stopped meaning anything.”
TRKKN, an agency, says GoCompare fed predicted lead value into Google target ROAS bidding instead of bidding for volume and saw 38% more revenue and 11% higher ROI in a pilot. Test design is not stated.
“+38% Revenue Increase, scaling high-value volume”
Google claims advertisers who import offline and app data through Data Manager see a 26% average increase in incremental ROAS, from its own Search data, April 2025 to April 2026, with no method given.
“Importing post-lead events, like when a prospect becomes sales qualified or finally converts, is key to driving high-value outcomes for your campaigns.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer