Which metrics belong in a weekly marketing review?
Our answer
Review the same short set every week in a fixed order. Go from revenue, spend and MER to new and returning customers, channel mix, creative, tracking health and written decisions. Leave cohort value and payback to the monthly review.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 practitioners
- 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 14 statements
- A
KT
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA fixed, top-down order catches what reviews miss. Kickbite runs its Monday review in that order, starting with total sales divided by total ad spend (MER). It says new and returning customers and data health are the two steps most reviews skip.
A short weekly page leaves detail for later. Balistro's weekly report holds MER, profit on ad spend (POAS), blended CAC, the new and repeat split, the top 3 creatives and a one-line note. Cohort and attribution detail wait for a less frequent review.
Slow numbers belong in the monthly look. Eightx reviews MER and new-customer share of orders weekly, and blended CAC and contribution margin monthly. Trackbee leaves cohorts and lifetime value, and Redefine Web retention rates, to the monthly review.
Our judgment
- Order the review top down. Go from total efficiency through new customers, channels, creative and tracking health to decisions, following Kickbite's six steps.
- Keep MER, the new and returning split and channel results weekly, and cohort value, payback and retention monthly. Eightx, Trackbee and Redefine Web put margin, cohort or retention numbers in a monthly look, Balistro leaves cohort retention to a less frequent review and Exactius tracks payback monthly by cohort and channel. Only RetentionX and Futureproof put lifetime value or payback weekly.
- Add contribution margin or profit on ad spend to the weekly page when cost data allows. This goes by Admetrics' weekly MER, acquisition MER and contribution margin against plan, and Balistro's weekly POAS.
- Make scaling calls on the week's blended numbers rather than daily swings. This follows Flighted's rule of daily pacing and weekly scaling, and Eightx's threshold of an MER trend lasting 3 or more weeks.
Our judgment, built from Kickbite, Eightx, Trackbee, Balistro, Redefine Web, Exactius, RetentionX, Futureproof, Admetrics and Flighted: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 13 sourcesFor Black Week, Admetrics says to check MER, rolling three-day MER and acquisition MER several times a day, and shift budget from the least profitable campaigns when MER drops below the floor.
“Compare each week against its own break-even.”
Kickbite proposes a 20-minute weekly review in six steps: total business, new versus returning, channel mix, creative, data health, then decisions with an owner and a date.
“The two steps most reviews omit are new versus returning and data health”
Balistro, an agency, says a weekly report needs six metrics shown the same way every week: MER, POAS, blended CAC, new versus repeat revenue, top 3 creatives and a one-line narrative.
“Weekly reports answer "are we on track," monthly reviews answer "why, and what's the plan."”
Web Tonic, an agency for HVAC contractors, suggests a 30-minute weekly review that ends in one action with one owner and a date, with decisions made on 30-day trends.
“A cadence without an agenda drifts into number-admiring.”
Trackbee suggests watching revenue, orders, MER, spend and CAC daily, the new versus returning split and channel results weekly, and cohorts, LTV and margin monthly.
“If a number would not change what you do next, it belongs in a monthly report, not on your daily screen.”
Admetrics, an analytics vendor, suggests a one-screen executive view of MER, net revenue, contribution margin, blended CAC, payback and LTV, an operator view below it, and one system of record for orders.
“Create an executive view that fits on one screen. Then add an operator view that explains the drivers.”
PipelineOn, which sells software to contractors, recommends a free Looker Studio dashboard of 7 KPIs, from cost per lead to booked jobs, reviewed 30 minutes every Monday. Paid connectors typically add $50 to $80 a month.
“The job-level source tag is the key - if your CSR is not capturing “how did you hear about us?” with a controlled vocabulary, the attribution chain breaks here.”
CTC's profit engineer manager says a combined growth, Meta and creative role splits about 50% account execution and 50% strategy, with a weekly client meeting and daily plan checks.
Exactius, a growth agency, calls DTC payback under 6 months strong and 6 to 12 acceptable, and tracks payback monthly by acquisition cohort and channel before raising spend.
“CAC payback period is the number of months it takes a new customer to generate enough contribution margin to recover the cost of acquiring them.”
RetentionX, which sells retention analytics, says put time-bound LTV on the weekly scorecard (at least 30, 90 and 180 days), and set a CAC ceiling from a cash payback limit such as day 90 or 180.
“A customer worth $200 over 12 months is not the same as a customer worth $200 over 3 years.”
Redefine Web suggests a weekly channel scorecard, a monthly dashboard of MER, blended CAC, margin and retention, and a quarterly cohort review, since retention moves slowly.
“Retention numbers move slowly, so founders that check them monthly, not weekly, avoid over-reacting to noise.”
Eightx suggests reviewing channel ROAS daily, MER and new customer share weekly, blended CAC and margin monthly, and LTV to CAC quarterly, each with an action threshold.
“build a simple Google Sheet with these six rows updating weekly.”
Flighted, an agency, says to check pacing daily but make scaling calls weekly on blended numbers, give every audience a full week before pausing, and prune account structure monthly.
“Check pacing daily, but make scaling calls weekly on blended numbers.”
Futureproof, which sells ecommerce bookkeeping, says a financial dashboard should show whether you acquire profitably, retain value and make cash. Drop metrics that change no decision, and review weekly.
“If a metric does not change a decision, it does not belong on the primary view.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer
Read next
More in What to measure- How should we set marketing targets when margins change, for example from tariffs?
- How should we account for discounts and returns in marketing metrics?
- How should we measure the cost of acquiring a subscriber versus a one-time buyer?
- Should we report marketing results on a cash basis or on contribution margin?