Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Cheap CPMs, empty carts

Thursday was a strange day to read a Meta dashboard. Some advertisers watched CPMs fall through the floor and their sales go with them, on the same day Meta started counting some purchases on shoppers' own phones, so this issue opens with how to tell which lever moved. Also: a pileup of scaling rules, Triple Whale's app gone from the Shopify App Store, Black Friday discount math from a vendor with the data, Google grading itself in three new places and a new answer on Google click costs.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Four hand-drawn gauges on one pipe, one needle dropped low and circled in red

Several posters on r/FacebookAds reported Meta sales collapsing on November 11 and 12 with no changes to their accounts. One saw CPM fall from about $20 to $4 to $5 over two days while conversion rate dropped and the placement mix held steady, and others reported a single sale on $300 a day of spend (r/FacebookAds). That's a handful of accounts and Meta has said nothing. When impressions get that cheap and sales fall anyway, I'd suspect Meta is selling you inventory nobody else wanted. That's my read, and nobody has confirmed it.

It was also day one of Meta's on-device counting, which Wednesday's issue warned could lift reported purchases with no change in real sales. Two things pushing the same numbers on the same day is the moment to slow down. Our answer on diagnosing a Meta cost per purchase drop starts in the right place: confirm the move shows in store revenue and orders and that the attribution setting didn't change, then compare CPM, click-through rate, conversion rate and order value with the prior week and the same week a year earlier. In the Reddit case CPM and conversion rate fell together. The answer reads a conversion rate drop with steady click-through as a site, price or stock problem, so check click-through before you blame the auction. Then blame the auction.

The Norwegian publisher Schibsted, pitching its own native ads, picked the same week to tell AdExchanger that some advertisers have seen Meta returns flatten or slip, and to ask for about 10% of their Meta spend (AdExchanger). It gives no figures. A seller pitching against Meta goes in the mood file next to Thursday's Google defectors, and our answer on when to shift budget to other channels is the place to start if you're tempted.

Meta notes

  • Scaling rules arrived in bulk. Charley Tichenor raises a budget 5% on Monday, Wednesday and Friday, and only when the campaign is at least 10% under its target cost per purchase (Tichenor), and says to automate whatever rule you pick instead of deciding by feel (Tichenor). Reddit commenters advising an advertiser who wants to go from $1,000 to $10,000 a day suggest about 20% every three days, then reading how cost per purchase breaks when it does (r/FacebookAds).
  • Our answer on how fast to scale a winning campaign sits with the Reddit crowd at steps of 20 to 30%, two to three days apart, which makes Tichenor the cautious end of the range.
  • Olly Hudson says that since what he calls Meta's Andromeda V2 rollout on October 28, the floor is 5 ads per ad set and the target is 20, and he won't kill a new concept inside 3 days (Hudson).
  • Our answer on how many ads per ad set scales it to budget instead, from about 3 to 6 ads at small budgets to about 10 to 20 at large ones. Lorenzo Pravata, following up on his point from Wednesday's issue, says hook swaps on the same video count as one ad (Pravata), which matches our answer on what counts as a new creative down to the opening line.
  • Marin Istvanic says to skip separate funnel and retargeting campaigns, since one Advantage+ sales campaign already matches each ad to warm or cold people (Istvanic).
  • Our answer on a dedicated retargeting campaign agrees by default and adds a small one, under 10% of budget, only past about $1,000 a day.
  • Two trades advertisers say Advantage+ placements sent about 90 to 99% of a lead campaign's budget to Reels with no leads, and they moved to Facebook Feed only (r/FacebookAds). A home-services commenter adds that one qualifying question on the lead form costs a bit more per lead and books more jobs.
  • Our answer on setting up Meta for a local service business judges every route on cost per booked job, which is the number that catches a Reels leak.
  • Statics are still earning their keep. Cody Wittick says a static image was the top-spending ad over 7 days for two brands in his agency's accounts and third for another (Wittick).
  • Our answer on the mix of static, video and carousel says don't go video-only.
  • More than 10 million people in the US and Canada set up a Meta Muse agent between its September 8 launch and October 21, and about 25% use it daily, by Mark Zuckerberg's count (AdExchanger). That's Meta grading itself, and Amazon has blocked Muse since shortly after launch.
  • Our answer on getting recommended by Muse still says do the cheap groundwork, a clean catalog and readable product pages, and hold off on a dedicated budget.

Black Friday math

Lebesgue, an ecommerce analytics vendor, published Black Friday and Cyber Monday 2025 data from nearly 1,000 online stores (Lebesgue). The median store's BFCM-week sales grew 1.95 times over a normal November day at about 15% off and 1.88 times at about 20% off, and stores at 40% off and deeper grew about 2 times. Among more than 500 stores with cost data, gross profit grew 2.05 times at 15% off against 1.75 times at 40% off. Deeper discounts bought about the same sales and less profit. Our answer on Black Friday offer size lands at about 20 to 30% off sitewide for most consumer brands and says going deeper adds little, so count Lebesgue as a vote for the shallow end.

Measurement shop

  • Triple Whale's Shopify app is gone from the Shopify App Store. Storeleads records it removed on November 11 after counting 37,643 installed stores, and the listing says the app isn't available, with no reason given (Storeleads). If you're shopping for a dashboard, confirm install and billing with Triple Whale directly. Our answer on choosing a dashboard tool lists Triple Whale as one option and says to start with the free tools before paying for any of them.
  • Northbeam rewrote its pricing page: Starter at $1,500 a month for brands under $1.5M a year of ad spend, Professional at $3,500 a month for up to $500K a month of spend on annual or semi-annual terms, and a quote-only Growth plan (Northbeam). Our answer on measurement vendors and what they cost is where to compare.

Google

Google spent Thursday building new places to grade itself.

  • A new Invalid Traffic Overview card on the Overview page shows what Google's filters saved before billing and what it credited after, by day and campaign, rolling out globally (Google). Google says the credits equal the invalid spend and land on the next invoice automatically. Our answer on invalid clicks and click fraud says check Google's own reports before paying anyone else to look, and to judge them against sales.
  • Google Ads Editor 2.14 switches on AI Max, text asset automation and Final URL expansion by default for new Search campaigns built in Editor (Google). Our answer on turning on AI Max for Search tests AI Max through Google's experiment and leaves text customization and Final URL expansion for later, one at a time, so switch those two off when you build in Editor.
  • A Data Strength uplift metric shows Google's estimate of extra conversions over 14 days from its first-party data features, for accounts with 100 or more website conversions or 20 or more offline conversions in 14 days (Search Engine Roundtable). Google is estimating the value of its own features. Our answer on customer lists for Google covers the data worth feeding it.
  • Nils Rooijmans won't switch Google's promotion mode beta on across accounts for Black Friday. He gives it even odds of working, says Black Friday week is the most expensive time to find a bug, and will test it on one campaign for clients who can take the risk. It covers Search and Performance Max only and doesn't support portfolio bid strategies (Rooijmans). Our answer on Google budgets around sales peaks gives campaigns room before Black Friday rather than steering them on the day, and a beta switch on the day is steering.
  • YouTube target frequency campaigns can mix non-skippable ads up to 20 seconds, up from 15, with Shorts and in-feed ads, at one frequency range of 2 to 7 views a week (PPC Land). Our answer on YouTube Shorts ads covers the Shorts side.
  • PPC Land spotted a local-retailer sponsored product pack below AI Mode answers (PPC Land). It's a sighting, not an announcement. Our answer on ads in AI Mode and AI Overviews says your Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns already take part, with nothing to opt into.

Elsewhere

  • One advertiser targeting ChatGPT ads at Europe only saw 16 of 60 campaign visits geolocate to Iran, against 2 of 950 visits from Iran in normal traffic (r/PPC). Commenters say to ask OpenAI for a credit and keep that traffic out of conversion reporting. A Search Engine Land column by Tyler Jordan finds early ChatGPT ad tests at Google-like cost per click with fewer conversions (Search Engine Land).
  • Our answer on ads inside AI assistants treats ChatGPT as research money, and Iranian traffic for a European store is pricey research.
  • Google put Gemini 4 Hydrogen into Search globally, saying its answers run more searches across subtopics and link to a wider range of sites (Google).
  • Our answer on Google's AI Mode covers the organic side.
  • The European Commission adopted a Digital Fairness Act proposal on November 11. PPC Land reads it as extending the Digital Services Act's bans on profiling-based ads aimed at minors and on targeting with sensitive data to all traders, making AI shopping agents disclose paid suggestions and making brands and agencies liable for their influencers' compliance (PPC Land). It's a proposal, so nothing changes yet.
  • Our answer on EU and US privacy rules has the rules in force.

New in the book

One new answer and one changed call on Thursday. The new one: our answer on Google click cost moves says judge your click costs against your own category and campaign type and against the market's move on a year earlier, not an all-industry average. Search cost per click on Google rose 4% in Q3 2026 against a year earlier in Tinuiti's data and 7% across Skai's paid search clients, so a rise well above that points at your own account first: lost impression share, Auction Insights, match types and the brand and non-brand mix.

  • Our answer on who owns measurement changed its call. It puts reporting with one analyst-minded generalist at about $10M a year in revenue, earlier than the $15M to $20M it gave before, on Eightx's headcount data and advice from Taylor Sicard. Eightx sells finance services and Sicard sells consulting.

Google's core update could run until about November 24. Black Friday is in 14 days.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue