What counts as a genuinely new creative rather than a variant?
Our answer
Count an ad as new only when it looks different in the first seconds (format, person or setting) and ideally says something new. New copy, headlines or crops are variants.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 Meta rules
- 1 dataset, 13 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 21 sources
- 26 statements
- LPM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAds that look alike can reach the same people. When creative is too similar, Meta's system may not recognize it as different and could deliver it to the same audiences, which limits reach (Meta).
Meta judges sameness by what it sees. Its help pages score Creative diversity by comparing images and video thumbnails, and count fatigue by repeat exposure of the same image or video.
Surface edits such as new copy, headlines or crops collapse into one ad. Jetfuel Agency, a consumer marketing agency, counts 30 hook variations of one video, color swaps, text-only edits and aspect-ratio exports as one.
Our judgment
- We require a different look, not only a different message. Common Thread Collective counts message theme as a diversity dimension, while Billo says the rating scores visual sameness. We side with the visual test. Meta's diversity score compares images and video thumbnails, and its fatigue status counts exposures of the same image or video. Marketing Brew's agency source says Meta treats the same video with different on-screen text as the same creative. Fraser Cottrell says to make versions look different, not just read different. The two-of-four rules from Common Thread Collective and Jetfuel Agency both include visual dimensions.
- Aaron O'Connell on the Operators podcast says visual and format differences matter far less than the message. We keep a new message as the ideal and still require a new look, because Meta's diversity score and fatigue status read images and videos.
Our judgment, built from Meta, Common Thread Collective, Billo, Marketing Brew, Fraser Cottrell, Jetfuel Agency and Aaron O'Connell: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
26 statements from 21 sourcesAkvile DeFazio says more ads will not revive declining paid social results. Test distinct concepts, hooks and messages rather than small variations of one winner, isolating one variable at a time.
“Test distinct concepts rather than launching minor visual variations of a single winning asset”
Aaron O'Connell says that for creative diversity, messaging matters far more than visual or format differences.
“it's not like, yes, visual differences or format differences matter, but they matter way less than the messaging.”
An operator says to launch 10 concepts differing in format, persona or awareness level, with one CBO per product and one ad set per concept. One ad went from $500 to $12K+ in spend in 3 days. No account figures.
“A winner is the ad that becomes a top spender, so judge it by spend before anything else.”
Sukesh Meriyala says more, and more diverse, creative helps Meta's system match the right ad to the right user at the right time.
“having more creative, more diverse creative, is generally a a more effective way for us to be able to deliver.”
Nest Commerce, a UK agency, reports in a Meta-published case study that seven brands put 68% of spend on video against 38% across the benchmark. It is the agency's own accounts, and both Nest and Meta have an interest.
“against 38% across the benchmark”
Meta's creative diversity score compares the images and video thumbnails in an ad set for similarity and labels it High, Medium or Low. It names no copy input and is still in development.
“is calculated by comparing the images and video thumbnails in your ad set to each other to determine similarity.”
Meta flags 'Creative limited' when an ad's cost per result tops your past ads but is under twice as much, and 'Creative fatigue' at twice or more. It suggests a materially different new ad.
“Keeping your original ad active instead of pausing or turning it off may maximize results”
Meta says ads that are too similar may be treated as the same and shown to the same people, limiting reach and causing Creative limited or fatigue status. It suggests different angles such as price or ease of use.
“When creative is too similar, our system may not recognize it as different and could deliver it to the same sets of audiences.”
Lorenzo Pravata says don't kill a still-spending ad over one bad CPA day or crown a winner at 4 ROAS on $50 of spend. One account grew from $29K to $150K a month on one CBO with about 95% of creative changed.
“Calling an ad a winner at a 4 ROAS on $50 of spend... Did it hold at $500?”
Lorenzo Pravata says that under Andromeda similar ads get the same entity ID and compete for the same people, so every concept has to be completely different.
“similar ads get the same entity ID and fight over the same people”
Marin Istvanic says adding a meme-style text banner, or speeding a video up 10%, used to make Facebook treat it as a new entity, but this is less effective since Andromeda.
“Less effective since Andromeda.”
Fraser Cottrell, from 10,000+ ads, scales static ads by mining reviews for one message, making versions look different rather than just read different, and expanding winners.
“Make it look different, not just read different”
Lorenzo Pravata says Meta groups ads with the same setup and shot into one entity, so 20 videos of different creators holding the same product the same way pays 20 times for one test.
“Meta groups ads with the same setup and the same shot into one entity, so you paid 20 times for a single test”
Eugene Healey says even Meta wants genuine creative diversity, not the same ad repeated in different fonts.
“It can't just be repeats of the same thing in different fonts.”
Agency executives in Marketing Brew relay that Meta treats ads with the same look or opening hook as one ad even when the text differs; Meta declined to give specifics.
“don’t get into the specifics of how our ranking models represent individual creative assets.”
Paul Chinedu Nnamani says you can fight creative fatigue by keeping a winning video and only swapping its first five seconds for new hooks.
“You can take the same video and you're going to just change the first five seconds with different different openings, different numbers, different wordings.”
Billo says Meta's Creative diversity column rates ad sets Low, Medium or High on visual similarity, and five openers on the same shot still read as one ad. Its 60% similarity threshold is not sourced to Meta.
“a new headline on the same footage reads as the same asset”
Common Thread Collective says Meta's delivery treats ads with the same visual or opening hook as effectively one ad, so changes to text, headline, color or crop add no creative diversity.
“Meta groups ads that share the same visual style, opening frame, spokesperson, product framing, or messaging theme as a single creative entity.”
Spicy Web, an Australian agency, launches one to three genuinely different ads at a time in one ad set at $50 a day or more, since Meta treats look-alike variations as the same ad. No data.
“Three genuinely different ads is plenty for the system to choose from.”
New Engen, an agency, separates executional variety (new hook, edit, creator) from conceptual change (new motivation, problem, proof). It relays a Meta staffer's view and shows no outcome data.
“When assets share key visual or thematic attributes, Meta may group their learnings at the creative level, limiting the range of signals available to its delivery system”
Ready Set's Nacho Manchi says diversification means a new persona, angle or visual world, while iteration changes a hook, copy or CTA on a winner. Only diversification gives Meta new signal. No data.
“Only diversification gives Meta new signal.”
At a Motion summit panel, a speaker said a net new ad is usually a different person and a completely different format. A native static versus a designed static is not net new. Stated practice, no data.
“Net new = brand new concept, different person, different format.”
The Ecommerce Alley podcast says changing only the text on the same static image gave Meta too little variety: of 10 such ads, 9 got no spend.
“meta put out of the 10 ads, I hear 10 ads, I think, nine of them got not even one penny of spend.”
Jetfuel, an agency, says Meta groups ads that look or say the same into one unit, so a new one must change two of format, persona, setting or benefit. It aims for 10 to 15 distinct units. No data.
Motion's Sophia Beauvoir says running many versions of one image with small text tweaks no longer tests much, because Meta's system now treats them as one ad.
“running 10 versions of the same image with minor text tweaks isn't the efficient test that it used to be”
Rich From Anywhere says recording three scripts in the same setting no longer works because Meta treats those videos as the same. Record variations with different settings, locations or props.
“That's not the way to do it anymore because Meta's basically looking at those videos as the same video.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer
Read next
More in Creative volume and testing- How quickly do our creatives fatigue, and what signals say it is time to refresh?
- What share of production should iterate on winners versus invent new concepts?
- How should we judge a creative test: what volume, what time window and which metric?
- Do we have to label AI-generated ads, and does labeling or AI voiceover hurt results?