Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.
Meta's favorite child
Meta now shows how each image, video and line of text in a multi-asset ad performed, and the obvious move, cutting whatever got no spend, is the one I'd hold off on. Also: a $1M-a-month brand that ran a site-wide sale with zero sale ads, Google handing its ad tags full IP addresses in 2027, and a shelf of new answers for anyone who sells by the lead.
By Scott Stroud, Editor

Ads Manager's Breakdown menu has new Media and Text options for ads with several assets. Meta says Media shows "how your images and videos delivered as single media", and Text does the same for each text variation; carousel and collection ads aren't covered (Meta via Social Media Today). Common Thread Collective, an agency, says you get spend, impressions, clicks, CTR, purchases, CPA and ROAS per image or video. It also hands out quick pre-Black Friday rules: pull an asset past $500 spent at twice the campaign's CPA, and anything under 5% impression share in a Flexible ad with five or more images. On the same page it warns that low spend may only mean Meta deprioritized the asset and asks for 50 purchases before judging on CPA (CTC). CTC arguing with itself is my favorite genre.
I side with the second CTC. Meta decides which version each person sees, so a version with a sliver of spend lost a popularity contest Meta ran, which tells you little about whether it sells. Our answer on cutting versions inside a multi-asset ad is new: don't remove a version for low spend alone, judge it on cost per purchase once it has about 50 purchases, and when Meta piles impressions onto one or two versions, swap the idle ones for stronger, distinct ones in a single edit, since Meta treats any creative change as a significant edit. CTC's spend-based cut rule is the dissent. Confidence is low, and agencies sell this work.
Black Friday, minus the Black Friday ads
- Barry Hott says he ran a full site-wide sale for a brand spending over $1 million a month "without a single ad mentioning it", and it lifted ROAS, cut CPA and let spend scale to 4x the usual (Hott). One account, no figures, and the same post plugs his page-monitoring tool.
- Our answer on Black Friday ads says build a separate, bigger batch of sale ads on top of evergreen, so file this as a fun counterexample until someone tests both side by side.
- Phil Kiel, whose agency sells Meta management, says some of his biggest accounts scaled 21% from September to October with CPA down 3% and purchases up 23%, by starting in October, checking cost caps every morning and running a retention holdout first (Kiel). That's the schedule in our answer on seasonal budgets: live by mid-October, hold or raise spend into November.
- Bryan Bumgardner of Northbeam, which sells measurement, says to judge ads over at least your conversion lag, so a 7-day read on a 14-day buying cycle sees half the picture (Bumgardner).
- Our answer on judging a creative test sets 7 days as the floor, and his point is a decent reason to stretch it if your buyers dawdle.
- CTC's checklist for Meta's on-device counting adds an Event Match Quality of 6.0 or better on purchases, matching event IDs between the pixel and the Conversions API, and no structural changes from November 12 to 18 (CTC). Its "up to 15% more attributed purchase conversions" credits unnamed Meta testing and describes reporting, which is different from sales.
- Our answer on keeping the setting still wants that baseline of Meta purchases against store orders saved first.
Google emailed server-side Tag Manager users that from January 11, 2027, Google Ads, Display & Video 360, Search Ads 360 and Campaign Manager 360 tags will receive the full visitor IP address by default unless you opt out, while Google Analytics tags keep redacting it. Consent and notices are on you (PPC Land). That comes from an email a freelancer posted, and I can't find a Google help page saying it yet, so treat it as reported. Our answer on Google conversion tracking covers when server-side tagging is worth adding and doesn't get into IP handling; if your consent setup doesn't cover sending IPs to ad tags, put the opt-out on your January list.
Google's help page on Performance Max now says it may filter out "navigational or brand-specific search queries" so dedicated Search campaigns handle them, and tells you to fund those campaigns (Google). That's Google grading its own setup, and it matches our answer on running Performance Max alongside Search: keep a brand Search campaign next to it.
Media buyers told Digiday that 10% to 30% of client search budgets are being questioned as AI Overviews and AI Mode answer more queries, and Tinuiti says its clients' Facebook spend rose 16% in the third quarter, though nobody said the search money is heading to Meta (PPC Land). It's talk with no results attached. Our answer on Google's share of budget stands at about 30% to 40% of paid media.
Menachem Ani, who runs an agency, has a tidy Black Friday trap: a Merchant Center sale price with no time zone starts on UTC, so a November 27 sale goes live at 7 PM Eastern on Thanksgiving (Ani). Our answer on sale prices already says to send sale dates with a time and UTC offset at both ends.
And a new Google answer: our answer on message buttons in Search ads says add an SMS or WhatsApp button only where buyers ask questions before they buy, and count a Leads from Messages conversion as a chat started until your CRM shows it became a booking or sale. Confidence is low, partly because Google's own pages don't say what that conversion counts (Google).
New in the book
Fourteen new answers since the last issue, most of them for businesses that sell by the lead, which is good news for the plumbers in the audience. The featured one: AI agents in your conversion data. Microsoft Clarity, which sells analytics, found checkout events in 25.21% of sessions involving AI agents against 14.65% of human ones, while warning that it can't split agent and human actions in a session and an event isn't an order (Microsoft Clarity). Our call: check whether agents reach your checkout and form pages, filter the ones that identify themselves before events reach Meta and Google, and bid on backend-confirmed purchases and qualified leads.
- How should we give each new lead a predicted value?
- Which early lead actions predict a sale?
- Should we send conversions only from our server?
- How should we judge ads when the cheapest leads are the worst?
- How should ads for a high-price or high-trust offer differ?
- How do we cut junk and fake leads without losing volume?
- Should appointment ads optimize for booked or attended visits?
- How should Meta's location fees change country budgets?
- How do we give an AI agent safe access to our ad accounts?
- How do we set up a Meta campaign to win back lapsed customers?
- How do we measure what our referral program really adds?
Meta's on-device counting starts November 12, in 9 days. Black Friday is 24 days out.
Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.