Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Vote early, panic never

The midterms are Tuesday, and the Answer Book now has a call on what to do with Meta budgets while candidates crowd the auction. Plus a Buy now button on regular Google results, Gemini quietly dropping its tracking tags, and a weekend of operator takes, including one for the franchise crowd.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Woodcut of a shopper getting a mug handed through a chat bubble, and being sent through a shop door for a big bundle

Northbeam, which sells measurement, says average Meta CPMs across the more than 1,000 accounts it tracks are up 25%, and blames candidate spend plus Amazon's October sale pulling money forward, without splitting the two or naming the comparison period (Northbeam). Its Bryan Bumgardner says midterm money is going out ZIP code by ZIP code, mostly to Michigan, Texas and Ohio, and that outside those states "you won't see much relief in your CPMs" (Bumgardner via Colin Dougherty). AdImpact projects $11.6 billion in political spend this cycle, $1.6 billion of it digital (PPC Land).

So I wouldn't touch the dials. Our answer on election week and Meta budgets is new, and it says hold budgets and targets through Tuesday rather than cutting by reflex, judge CPM, CPC and CPA against your own recent weeks, and plan for CPMs that don't fall after election day, with a separate plan in the drawer if they ease. If most of your customers live in Michigan, Texas or Ohio, expect the most pressure and tune the message for buyers there. Confidence is low: the advice rests on an agency's and a vendor's opinion, and nobody has published a clean read on how much an election moves Meta costs outside the battleground states. A roofer in Lansing has more to worry about than a candle shop in Oregon.

Terms of endearment

One coda to Saturday's lead. PPC Land's read of the UK competition case says it covers Meta's existing terms as well as the revised ones, and names advertisers alongside publishers. Evidence gathering runs to January 2027, and the regulator's board is due to look at Meta's market status in spring 2027 (PPC Land). Meanwhile Meta's own preview page still says the updates "will go into effect on November 20, 2026" (Meta), days after its spokesperson said the consultation could run past that date. I'd treat November 20 as a date nobody is holding to.

What operators said

  • Phil Kiel ran a holdout on a campaign aimed only at lapsed customers and read 2.45x incremental ROAS, above target, with new customers from the same households along for the ride (Kiel). One campaign, no spend given. It backs our answer on excluding existing customers: don't blanket-exclude them, and hard-exclude only active subscribers and recent buyers.
  • Drew Sanocki, who sells direct mail through PostPilot, says if you get one Black Friday mailing, send it to buyers with two or more orders who lapsed 2 to 24 months ago, and leave out anyone who clicked an email in the last 60 days (Sanocki). A seller telling you to mail, sure, but it lines up with our answer on direct mail for retention, which mails quiet past customers and holds back a matched slice to see whether it worked.
  • Marin Istvanic, who sells account audits, says a frequency of 3 means most of the reachable audience has been worked through at $10K a week and almost nothing at $200K a week (Istvanic). That pokes at the fixed watch level of about 2.5 in our answer on ad frequency, though we agree on the bigger point: frequency alone is no reason to change anything.
  • Cody Schneider, who sells the analytics tool Graphed, says a franchise with more than 200 locations cut Meta cost per lead from $70 to $16 in four weeks by giving every location its own campaign and shipping five ads every three days, and Google cost per lead fell from $82 to $35 over the same stretch (Schneider). Cost per lead is the easy number to move.
  • Our answer on Meta for local service businesses judges on booked jobs, so I'd want those before copying the campaign sprawl.

Google

Product panels in regular US Google results now show Add to cart and Buy now buttons under Visit site, paid through Google Pay, with a cart that carries over to the Gemini app. The rollout began October 15. If you're on Shopify and matched to Merchant Center, Shopify's native checkout on Google has been on by default since September 18; the off switch is in Shopify admin under Sales channels (PPC Land). Our answer on selling through AI shopping assistants says stay listed and put the effort into complete product data, and turn direct checkout off, channel by channel, where subscriptions, bundles, custom products or checkout add-ons carry your revenue.

Speaking of Gemini, it stopped tagging its links. Cited links carried utm_source=gemini from about September 9, peaked at 83 tagged visits on one practitioner's sites on September 28 and fell to 3 the next day. The iPhone app sends no referrer at all, and Android visits almost always land in Direct (PPC Land). Google hasn't said a word. ChatGPT had its own tagging bug in mid-October that pushed visits into Direct until it was fixed (Search Engine Roundtable). Adobe, which sells analytics, forecasts AI-referred traffic to US retail sites up 130% this holiday season (Common Thread Collective), so it's worth counting properly. Our answer on measuring AI assistant visits, also new, says read GA4's AI Assistant channel as a floor, add a custom channel group for chatgpt.com, gemini, copilot, claude and perplexity, and read AI Assistant and Direct together.

The third new answer is a Google one too. Google's Ads API release on October 28 added household income exclusions to Performance Max (Google). Our answer on excluding lower income ranges says don't by default: exclude a tier only for a clearly premium offer, after your own conversions show it lags, and keep the Unknown tier in. Confidence is low, and the three agencies behind it all sell paid search management.

Also from Google's Ads Liaison, Ginny Marvin: ads in AI Mode and AI Overviews are matched to "both the query and the content of the AI response" (PPC Land). Nothing to switch on.

Meta's on-device counting starts November 12, in 10 days. Black Friday is 25 days out.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue