Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Customs and practice

The EU started charging a fee on every item in a parcel shipped in from outside the bloc, and if you sell to Europe from the US, your cheapest orders just got pricier to fill. Also: how to grade an advertorial, Google's new-customer push for Shopping, a Black Friday budget formula, and a new call on welcome discounts.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Comic panels: a courier asks for coins at the door, then the same parcel handed over smoothly with its price tag showing

Since November 1, the EU adds a €2 handling fee per declared item on goods sold to EU consumers from outside the EU, at any order value, and customs keeps it (Estonian Tax and Customs Board). It stacks on the €3 duty per item on parcels up to €150 that's applied since July, and the European Commission counts items by tariff classification, so 3 T-shirts and a watch pay €6 in duty (European Commission). Passport, which sells cross-border shipping, works out €10 of fixed charges on a €20 order with two line items (Passport). Pilothouse flagged it on Monday with the warning that "it could be a lot more" depending on what's in the box (Pilothouse).

I held this one a day so the answer could catch up, and it's worth the wait. Our answer on EU parcel fees is new: treat both charges as landed cost, build them into EU prices and ship duty paid, look at low-value and multi-item orders first, count both as gone on returns, and set EU acquisition cost targets from what an order earns after the fees at your EU order value, not your home numbers. Confidence is high on the charges and medium on the pricing advice, which leans on shipping vendors. Dame's CEO said a visible $5 tariff line at checkout "really killed" its conversion rate (Modern Retail), which is why the answer hides it in the price.

Timely counterpoint: Nick Theriot says he copied a winning US Meta campaign, changed only the country to the UK, and had it spending $3,700 a day 12 days later (Theriot). That's spend, with no cost per purchase, margin or shipping costs, and the post ends with a pitch for his agency. Our answer on adjusting by country still wants each country's own cost and return targets before you scale, and the EU just showed why.

Read all about it

Marin Istvanic, who sells account audits, says advertorial click-through to the product page deserves "a permanent spot on your dashboard", because at 30% you're sending only 30% of your paid traffic to the product page, which then has to convert at about 3 times your usual rate to match the same ad sent straight there (Istvanic). He also warns a page that hides the price can make click-through look "artificially great".

Our answer on judging an advertorial, also new, builds on that: judge the advertorial and its product page as one pair against the same ad going straight to the product page in the live campaign, on cost per product page visit, orders per ad click and new-customer cost per purchase. Expect about 25% to 30% click-through on a typical advertorial and 35% to 50% or more on a good listicle, per Istvanic and Nik Sharma (Sharma), and keep separate targets for pages that hide the price. Medium confidence on the method, low on the targets, which are rules of thumb.

Turkey math

  • Segwise says to fund each Black Friday offer ad set at about 7 times your target CPA a day, its own arithmetic from Meta's 50-results-a-week learning rule, so about $286 a day at a $40 CPA. Have offer ads delivering by November 20, submit them by November 18 since review can take a day, and freeze structure from Thanksgiving through Cyber Monday (Segwise). If that math prices you out, our answer on a fallback event says merge ad sets before you drop to add to cart.
  • Menachem Ani, an agency owner, says set the Black Friday budget backward from the revenue goal, orders needed at your real order value times what an order costs you today, instead of from last year's spend (Ani). Simple enough that I'm annoyed I didn't write it down first.
  • Pilothouse reminds you that "a manually uploaded customer list won't know who bought on Black Friday unless you refresh it", so update purchaser exclusions and retargeting lists during the sale (Pilothouse).
  • Our answer on feeding Meta your customer data goes one better: sync the lists automatically and continuously.
  • Istvanic again, on bidshe uses caps "only for scaling, not for testing", and describes a cost cap as averaging out at the cap (Istvanic).
  • Istvanic again, on bidsOur answer on cost caps says a cost per result goal tends to land about 40% above target, so set it about a third below what you can afford. His dollar figures are illustrations, so I'd trust ours.
  • Savannah Sanchez, who runs a UGC agency, says don't show the product until at least 3 seconds into a video, because an instant product shot reads as an ad and people swipe (Sanchez). No test behind it.
  • Our answer on Reels and Feed hooks says open on the buyer's problem and doesn't set a product clock, while our TikTok creative answer now wants the offer clear inside the first 3 seconds (more below). Pick your platform, pick your stopwatch.
  • Common Thread Collective says Meta's revised ad terms are "indefinitely delayed" with no new date, and the March 2024 terms stay in force (CTC). It says Meta confirmed this but quotes nothing from Meta; Meta's own line was that the consultation "could extend beyond November 20" (Reuters via WSAU). Same advice as Monday: no date anybody's holding to.

Google

Google says High Value New Customer Mode "is rolling out this week to Shopping campaigns", suggests valuing a new customer at 2 times your average order value, and wants new-customer budgets kept separate with a 20% buffer. It backs that with Measured experiments where Google and YouTube drove 25% more new-customer conversions than paid social (Google Ads). That's Google grading itself with a vendor's numbers. Our answer on Google's new customer goal says run the reporting-only setting first and start the premium much smaller, around 1.15x to 1.25x, raising it only while a new customer still pays back.

Smaller one: Google Ads asset scheduling now takes day groups such as weekdays or weekends, and several schedules per asset, spotted by one practitioner and not announced by Google (Search Engine Roundtable).

And a changed Google call: our answer on changing bid targets still moves targets 10% to 20% at a time, but a budget-limited campaign now resets in one move to the return you want, which Google's Ads Liaison says may be the return it already gets (Search Engine Roundtable).

New in the book

One new answer beyond the two above. Whether to offer a welcome discount: keep one by default, as a unique, single-use, expiring code for first orders only; premium brands should test early access or a gift instead, and you judge either on profit per customer against a group that never got the code. Taylor Sicard, who sells consulting, works out that at a 60% gross margin a 15% discount needs 33% more first orders just to earn the same gross profit (Sicard). Low confidence on when to drop it.

Three more calls changed. TikTok creative now wants what the ad offers clear within the first 3 seconds. TikTok account structure raises budgets only once an ad group is ready to scale. And raising order value now says never raise a US list price just to make a discount look bigger.

Meta's on-device counting starts November 12, in 8 days. Black Friday is 23 days out.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue