Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

The terms get ghosted

Last Saturday's lead was Meta pushing its new terms back to November 20. This Saturday they're off the calendar altogether. This is the week-in-review: Friday's news, the three calls that changed in the Answer Book, and the week's stories worth keeping.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Isometric street of four shops, three lit and plugged in, the pharmacy dark with its owner holding the unplugged cord

Meta told Reuters on Wednesday that it does "not plan to make policy changes without a full consultation with industry groups and leaders", that the consultation "could extend beyond November 20, in which case we'd delay implementation of the updated terms", and "Until then our existing terms remain in place." Reuters called it an indefinite delay (Reuters via WSAU). On Friday the UK's Competition and Markets Authority opened an investigation, saying the terms could amount to "an unlawful imposition of unfair trading conditions" (Reuters via Yahoo). Press Gazette adds that Norwegian media companies won a court order barring the terms in Norway until a court reviews them (Press Gazette). Meta has posted nothing about the hold on its own pages.

So the crawling clause and the AI liability clause we've been covering for weeks are still written down, with no date attached. Our answer on letting Meta's crawlers read your pages now reflects the hold, and its call stands: let Meta's ads and link-preview crawlers in, and decide the AI training crawler with its own robots.txt rule. I'm also retiring the terms countdown at the bottom of this briefing. Two dates in two weeks was a good run.

Also Friday

  • ChatGPT ads now run in 89 countries, OpenAI says more than 100,000 advertisers have signed up, and OpenAI now rewrites ads by default unless you opt out (PPC Land). The advertiser count is OpenAI grading itself. If you're testing, find that opt-out.
  • Our answer on ads inside AI assistants still says spend only money you can treat as research.
  • Reddit's CEO told investors that "AI Mode does not drive traffic, not for us and not for anybody, as far as I know," as Reddit's search referrals fell by more than 1 million a week in October (PPC Land). It's one company with a grudge, and it fits our answer on Google's AI Mode: work on it as part of your SEO, with no budget of its own.
  • France's privacy regulator fined two Fnac companies 7 million euros because the Fnac app kept sending a user ID and viewed products to a third party after people tapped "Continue without accepting". It ruled that product recommendations count as targeting that needs consent (PPC Land).
  • Our answer on consent banners already says no advertising tag fires before the shopper accepts, and in France that now covers recommendation trackers too.

Google

Google's crawler documentation now says Google "intends to support the AIPREF shared machine-readable training preference signal" in robots.txt "in early 2027" (Google). That's a shared line for opting out of AI training that any company can choose to honor. The catch, per Google's John Mueller: if you opt out that way without naming Google-Extended, Google will treat it as blocking Google-Extended, which also covers grounding in Gemini Apps (Search Engine Roundtable). Bing set out its own controls the same day and will honor the new preferences when crawling from February 1, 2027 (Search Engine Roundtable). Nothing to change before then. Our answer on llms.txt and other AI files already calls robots.txt the AI file that matters: allow the search crawlers and decide on training crawlers separately.

What changed in the book this week

Three calls changed.

  • Friday, budget share for catalog ads: keep catalog ads above about a third of Meta spend and raise the share in steps, except from October to December, when you hold it. Haus found catalog ads returned 0.64x the brand's other Meta ads in geo tests starting in those months, against 1.07x the rest of the year (Kory). Haus sells incrementality testing. Monday's issue filed Olivia Kory's first hint at this under "one to watch", and four days later it's a call.
  • Friday, benchmarking your CPMs: a US rise well above about 25% on last year is still the point to look at your own account, but compare with your category too, since the agency Pennock's beauty and skincare brands saw Meta CPMs up 35.1% in July and August (Pennock).
  • Tuesday, Meta's share of paid budget for lead gen, which Wednesday's issue covered: business-to-business lead gen keeps Meta a small share, near the 8% Dreamdata's B2B customers spend.

And 679 new answers went up, most of them in Wednesday's and Thursday's waves:

One for the next four weeks: our answer on Black Friday email says run the peak as a season, open early access in early November to a group smaller than your whole list, and leave buyers from the last 30 days out of discount blasts.

The week in three

Monday's issue led with Meta's claim that ad sets under about 50 conversions a week "ran about 28% more expensive per purchase", from Meta's own analysis with no method attached (PPC Land). The advice under the number held up better than the number: our answer on how many campaigns and ad sets says run the fewest ad sets that each reach about 50 a week.

Wednesday's issue covered Meta's "Measure conversions on customer devices" setting, which starts counting some purchases on the shopper's device on November 12, on by default (PPC Land). Thursday's issue had our call: our answer on keeping the setting says keep it on where your consent setup is documented and you've saved a baseline of Meta purchases against store orders before November 12. Save that baseline this week.

Product browsing switched on by default for existing ads on October 28 (CTC), and Friday's issue had Segwise's switch-off steps (Segwise). Our answer on Meta's creative enhancements says decide feature by feature, and fence anything that sends people somewhere other than the page you chose.

Meta's on-device counting starts November 12, in 12 days. Black Friday is 27 days out.

There is no Sunday issue, so see you Monday.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue