All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

Should we exclude existing customers from our prospecting campaigns?

The PrevailingUpdated Nov 5, 2026

Our answer

Don't blanket-exclude customers. Hard-exclude only active subscribers and recent buyers. If you are judged on new-customer cost, test Acquire new customers on a duplicate ad set with its window cut from 730 days to 180 or fewer.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
1 controlled test
3 Meta rules, 2 datasets, 16 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
Sources
13 sources
29 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Meta over-credits existing-customer spend, yet that spend still paid. Common Thread Collective's factors keep 0.60 of its reported ROAS against 1.13 for acquisition, but the 2.65% slice still returned 3.53 times incremental ROAS (299 brands, Q1 2026, mostly before Meta's March 2026 click change).

The default window of Meta's Acquire new customers setting decides how much you exclude. Since October 2026, Acquire new customers excludes 730 days of purchasers by default, and that can't be switched off (Jon Loomer, Meta ads educator).

Most exclusions are made for the wrong reason. Jon Loomer argues most advertisers who exclude existing customers usually do so because Ads Manager doesn't match their third-party reporting.

Our judgment

  • Cut the Acquire new customers window to 180 days or shorter. No source sets one window for recent buyers in everyday prospecting. The nearest are the buyers of about the last 90 days that Faris excludes from retention campaigns, the 60 days Kiel excluded for a product bought about monthly (longer for longer cycles), the 30 days of buyers Ben Radack keeps out of Black Friday ads, the 180-day window Common Thread Collective and Marin Istvanic exclude and the four windows of six months or less Meta offers besides 730 days.
  • Hard-exclude only active subscribers and recent buyers, a narrower cut than others make. Common Thread Collective and Marin Istvanic exclude at least everyone who bought in the last 180 days, and Phil Kiel excludes customers from prospecting by default. We stay narrow because Faris combines new and existing customers for low-retention brands and frequent launchers, at most trying a short exclusion such as 30 days. His subscriber and 90-day exclusions apply to retention campaigns, not prospecting.
  • Spend a small, tested slice on existing customers rather than none. Common Thread Collective's non-acquisition slice beat the 2.07 times it found for acquisition, on factors measured mostly before Meta's March 2026 click change, so it shows direction only. Faris advises lift-testing existing-customer spend, and Kiel's lapsed-customer campaign cleared its bar.
  • Use being judged on new-customer cost as the trigger for turning on Acquire new customers. It stands in for Ben Heath's test, spend going disproportionately to existing customers, and Common Thread Collective's point that converting existing customers does not grow the brand. Test it on a duplicate ad set before prospecting switches over (Meta's new-customer setting), since Heath advises against turning it on by default.
  • For durable goods bought once every two to three years, keep the 730-day window rather than cut it. Flighted says to exclude those buyers from prospecting, Kiel sets the lapsed window by purchase cycle and 730 days is the longest window Meta offers.

Our judgment, built from Andrew Faris, Phil Kiel, Ben Radack, Common Thread Collective, Marin Istvanic, Jon Loomer, Ben Heath and Flighted: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

29 statements from 13 sources
  • Phil KielNov 10, 2026Caveat

    Phil Kiel, an agency owner, says Meta now recommends keeping existing customers out of new-customer campaigns; on one account, spend on engaged non-buyers rose from 22% to 41% in two months.

    “There are new recommendations to keep existing customers out of campaigns meant to find new ones.”

    Read it on x.com

  • Phil KielOct 28, 2026Caveat

    Phil Kiel's agency says Meta spend on engaged audiences has climbed since August, with purchases 7% to 34% cheaper on Meta attribution. He advises ring-fencing one prospecting campaign that excludes them.

    “Ring-fence one prospecting campaign that excludes engaged and existing users, with a fixed slice of budget, so cold reach doesn't get starved going into Black Friday.”

    Read it on x.com

  • Andrew FoxwellOct 26, 2026Supports

    Ben Radack's Black Friday playbook, written up by Andrew Foxwell, runs one Meta CBO campaign on highest volume bidding and excludes purchasers from the last 30 days. No data given.

    “One CBO campaign optimized for highest volume, not cost or bid caps.”

    Read it on foxwelldigital.com

  • Marin IstvanicOct 23, 2026Disagrees

    Marin Istvanic says for lifetime value goals, exclude all existing buyers from prospecting using both the 730-day purchase pixel audience and the Klaviyo-synced list. No data.

    “we should exclude all existing buyers”

    Read it on x.com

  • DTC Newsletter / DTC PodcastOct 20, 2026Disagrees

    An agency case study of one brand: existing-customer share of Meta spend fell from over 30% to below 5% after stacked exclusions, and sales rose 28% year over year. No spend, CAC or new-customer counts given.

    Read it on directtoconsumer.co

  • MetaOct 17, 2026Caveat

    Meta has removed the existing customer budget cap from Advantage+ sales campaigns, but says you can do the same by hand with an audience exclusion or two ad sets with a spend limit.

    “Existing customer budget cap, which allowed Advantage+ sales campaign advertisers to choose whether or not to spend on existing customers, is no longer available.”

    Read it on facebook.com

  • Phil KielOct 15, 2026Supports

    In one UK brand's Haus geo test, a Meta campaign to lapsed customers returned 1.93 incremental ROAS on returning-customer sales against Meta's reported 6.2x; Haus counted 40% of the orders Meta claimed.

    “a retention campaign showing 6x in Ads Manager is not a 6x campaign.”

    Read it on x.com

  • MetaOct 15, 2026Caveat

    Meta says Reels Trending Ads, which place an ad right after popular Reels, are open to all advertisers with 15 standing topics plus seasonal lineups. Custom audience exclusions come later this year.

    “We are expanding our targeting capabilities, including custom audience exclusions later this year.”

    Read it on facebook.com

  • Marin IstvanicOct 13, 2026Disagrees

    Marin Istvanic's broad testing ad sets exclude pixel buyers from the past 180 days and the synced Klaviyo customer list.

    Read it on x.com

  • Jon LoomerOct 13, 2026Supports

    Jon Loomer says Meta's "Acquire new customers" setting now automatically excludes purchasers in your conversion data from the last 730 days, and this can't be turned off. Offline buyers still need a custom audience.

    “Customers from your conversion data (730 days)”

    Read it on jonloomer.com

  • Marin IstvanicOct 13, 2026Caveat

    A buyer managing $7M a month tests creative in ABO ad sets, one concept per ad set with 3 to 5 variations, starting at $100 a day on broad audiences.

    “One concept per ad set. 3-5 variations.”

    Read it on x.com

  • DTC Newsletter / DTC PodcastOct 13, 2026Supports

    Pilothouse, an agency, shows one prospecting campaign set to acquire new customers putting about 92% of spend ($15,542 of $16,855) on new audiences, at $72.63 per purchase versus $38.44 for engaged audiences.

    “Pilothouse recommends running this check weekly during sale periods, when the audience mix can shift quickly.”

    Read it on directtoconsumer.co

  • Jon LoomerOct 13, 2026Supports

    Pushes back on excluding existing customers from Meta campaigns: Jon Loomer says most advertisers do it for the wrong reasons. He suggests defining customer segments and using breakdowns to see their share of results.

    “most advertisers who exclude existing customers do so for the wrong reasons”

    Read it on jonloomer.com

  • Common Thread CollectiveOct 11, 2026Supports

    CTC says Meta's Customer Lifecycle Strategy toggle is live in manual Sales campaigns and can limit delivery to new customers (no purchase in 180 days); Advantage+ campaigns used a separate budget setting.

    Read it on commonthreadco.com

  • Common Thread CollectiveOct 11, 2026Disagrees

    CTC says for Black Friday 2026 to turn on new customers only in every prospecting ad set, after checking pixel and Conversions API coverage and uploading about two years of buyers, with a separate retention campaign.

    “Without lifecycle controls, Meta's optimization engine defaults to finding the easiest conversions.”

    Read it on commonthreadco.com

  • Ben HeathOct 7, 2026Supports

    Ben Heath says not to use Meta's 'Acquire new customers' setting by default, only when spend is going disproportionately to existing customers.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • Ben HeathOct 7, 2026Supports

    Ben Heath says adding legal and operational audience exclusions to a running ad set often makes ROAS drop sharply and cost per conversion rise. Anecdotal, with no data.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MetaOct 6, 2026Supports

    Meta says Customer Lifecycle Strategy is open to all advertisers: mark a campaign as acquisition and Meta suggests which existing customers to exclude. It is testing one tag that excludes them all.

    “already available to all advertisers”

    Read it on about.fb.com

  • Connor MacDonaldSep 1, 2026Caveat

    Ridge's Connor MacDonald says splitting new from returning customer revenue in incrementality tests is blurrier than people assume, since buyers use different emails; 8-9% of surveyed customers identified as existing.

    “is new customer actually returning. And it's all much blurrier.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Andrew FarisAug 24, 2026Supports

    Andrew Faris says not to blanket-exclude existing customers, since many brands should spend on them and lift-test it. Stronger exclusions, like active subscribers and 90-day buyers, belong on retention campaigns.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • Andrew FarisAug 24, 2026Supports

    Andrew Faris says brands with frequent product releases or sales usually shouldn't split new and existing customers into separate campaigns.

    “you actually shouldn't even separate out new and existing customers into separate campaigns.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Andrew FarisAug 24, 2026Supports

    Andrew Faris says single-product supplement brands with high repeat rates should not spend on existing customers at the same level as on new ones.

    “you shouldn't be targeting existing customers with your ad spend at the same level that you're doing new customers.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Common Thread CollectiveAug 12, 2026Disagrees

    A practitioner advises suppressing existing customers and 180-day purchasers from all Advantage+ campaigns, refreshed monthly.

    “Export existing customers, recent purchasers within 180 days, and opted-out contacts.”

    Read it on commonthreadco.com

  • DTC Newsletter / DTC PodcastJul 31, 2026Disagrees

    Nate Schulte says most of his testing runs to open audiences at the very top of the funnel.

    “The vast, vast majority of the testing that we're going to be doing is at the very top of the funnel.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Marketing Operators podcastJul 21, 2026Disagrees

    Hosts from Ridge, Jones Road and HexClad say loosening exclusions improved performance: one runs about 40% of the account with fewer exclusions, and another mainly excludes only purchasers. No data.

    “we pulled them back significantly better performance, like much better.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Andrew FarisJul 15, 2026Supports

    Andrew Faris feels less need for tight existing-customer exclusions under Meta's Incremental Attribution, and has merged new and existing customers for some wide-catalog clients.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • FlightedJul 2, 2026Disagrees

    Flighted, an agency, says brands under $50K a month on Meta and durable goods sellers should exclude existing customers from prospecting, and that over 25-30% of budget on existing buyers is too much.

    “If more than 25-30% of your Meta budget goes to existing buyers and engaged audiences, you are likely over-indexed.”

    Read it on flighted.co

  • MeasuredJun 2, 2026Caveat

    Measured's study found 64% of Meta's incremental conversions came from new or reactivated customers, so the figure includes lapsed buyers. On new-customer goals Meta's iROAS was 2.3 times search's.

    “64% of Meta technologies' incremental conversions were attributed to new or reactivated customers”

    Read it on measured.com

  • Common Thread CollectiveApr 24, 2026Supports

    In CTC's Q1 2026 data on 299 DTC brands and $231M, Meta retargeting and retention took 2.65% of spend at an estimated 3.53x incremental ROAS, versus 2.07x for acquisition, using pooled factors.

    “The gap between these numbers is where misallocation lives.”

    Read it on commonthreadco.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Audience and customers