All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

What share of our Meta budget should go to catalog (dynamic product) ads?

The PrevailingUpdated Oct 30, 2026

Our answer

Run catalog ads as their own always-on line to broad audiences, above about a third of Meta spend. Raise the share in steps while new-customer cost holds. From October to December, hold the share, since Haus found catalog weakest then.

Confidence
Low
Strongest proof
3 datasets
3 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
Sources
9 sources
10 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Catalog ads were weakest late in the year in incrementality tests. In Haus geo tests starting October to December, they returned 0.64 times the incremental return of the same brand's other Meta ads, against 1.07 times the rest of the year (Olivia Kory).

A small catalog share goes with lower returns. Confect, a catalog ad tool maker, found advertisers under a third of spend on catalog returned 9% less ROAS in Black Month 2025, with little extra gain above two thirds. It does not show cause.

Practitioners give catalog ads their own campaign. Common Thread Collective (CTC) runs them to broad and Advantage+ audiences as a separate budget line. Flighted, above $250K a month, and Pilothouse's newsletter do the same, though Flighted uses it mainly for retargeting.

Our judgment

  • Keep catalog above about a third of Meta spend and run it to broad audiences. We side with Confect's Black Month data, the only data on a share, and CTC's broad-audience practice over the retargeting view of Flighted and Jetfuel Agency, which show no data. Flighted's view comes from accounts at $250K to $1M or more a month, while Confect's advertisers average far less.
  • Outside October to December, raise the share in budget steps checked against new-customer cost. Use the steps How fast to scale a winning campaign sets, since no source gives a pace and Confect's penalty sits below a third.
  • Hold the catalog share from October to December, and judge it then on a holdout or new-customer cost, not Meta's ROAS. We side with Haus's geo tests, which measure incremental return, over Confect's Black Month checklist, which compares advertisers on platform-reported ROAS. Haus measured return per dollar, not a share.
  • Hold the catalog share down when a holdout shows catalog ads mostly reach past visitors who would have bought anyway. Catalog ROAS can be flattered by people who already know you, as Flighted and the retargeting answer (Budget for prospecting, retargeting and existing customers) say.
  • Ads Manager can understate how much of your spend serves as catalog ads. Once product browsing is on, the catalog campaign's share leaves out catalog-style delivery of your other ads (David Herrmann).

Our judgment, built from Confect, Common Thread Collective, Flighted, Jetfuel Agency, Haus (Olivia Kory) and David Herrmann: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

10 statements from 9 sources
  • Olivia KoryOct 28, 2026Supports

    Haus tests found catalog ads returned about 0.96x the return per dollar of a brand's other Meta ads over the year, but 0.64x in October to December tests versus 1.07x the rest of the year. Results vary a lot by brand.

    “Results vary a lot by brand here.”

    Read it on x.com

  • DTC Newsletter / DTC PodcastOct 19, 2026Supports

    A DTC podcast guest says to run catalog ads in their own campaign with their own budget and product set, because Ads Manager does not cleanly separate creative performance from catalog effects. No data.

    “deliberately in their own campaign, with their own budget and product set”

    Read it on directtoconsumer.co

  • David HerrmannOct 14, 2026Caveat

    David Herrmann says Meta is turning on product browsing for all existing ads from Oct 28, 2026, and on several brands an ad he thought was winning was mostly serving as a collection ad on Reels.

    “This has now happened multiple times on multiple brands.”

    Read it on x.com

  • ConfectSep 25, 2026Supports

    Confect's study of 1,362 advertisers found those spending under a third of their Meta budget on catalog ads returned 9% less ROAS than the average catalog ad, and those above two-thirds returned 4% more.

    “The honest reading is that the penalty sits at the bottom, not a reward at the top.”

    Read it on confect.io

  • ConfectSep 25, 2026Supports

    Confect's Black Month study found catalog ROAS lift of +32% for small advertisers, +30% mid and +21% big. Catalogs under 500 products returned 21% less, and over 2,000 products 20% more. Seasonal and correlational.

    “Catalogs with more than 2,000 products return 20% more than the average Black Month Catalog Ad.”

    Read it on confect.io

  • Dara DenneyAug 13, 2026Supports

    Dara Denney ranks founder content top and catalog ads strong; generic problem-solution UGC, AI avatars and AI animation sit in the middle, with carousels and podcast-style ads near the bottom.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • Common Thread CollectiveJul 30, 2026Supports

    CTC says catalog ads are usually an account's highest-ROAS item, but instead of using them only for retargeting, launch them broad with Advantage+ across the whole catalog and budget them as a separate line.

    “to a broad audience and Advantage+ with a catalog for your entire portfolio”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • Jetfuel AgencyJul 3, 2026Disagrees

    Jetfuel rates catalog and product grid ads 5 out of 10, useful for retargeting and weak for cold prospecting. Its 2026 structure puts 60 to 70% of budget in Advantage+ Shopping. No data.

    “Useful for retargeting; weak for cold prospecting.”

    Read it on jetfuel.agency

  • FlightedJul 1, 2026Disagrees

    For brands above about $250K a month, Flighted suggests five campaigns (testing, scaling, promotions, advertorial, catalog), each sustaining 100+ conversions, and launching 100 to 300+ new ads a month.

    “At $250k+/month, each campaign can sustain 100+ conversions independently, making multi-campaign structures viable without fragmenting data.”

    Read it on flighted.co

  • MarpipeJun 10, 2026Caveat

    Marpipe's Dan Pantelo, no data, says brands under 50 purchases a week should stay on manual DPA with warm audiences, then move 20 to 30% of DPA budget to broad catalog prospecting, expecting cold ROAS of 1.5 to 2.5x.

    “Under 50 purchases a week: stay on manual DPA against warm audiences for now”

    Read it on marpipe.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Budget, channel mix and seasonality