Discounts and promotions
Plan the year around a few sale moments and keep the weeks between at full price. Judge each offer on profit, and lock codes so they can't leak or stack in ways you didn't plan.
10 answers · 1 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026
The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 10 answers below.
Plan the year around a few sale moments customers expect, plus one or two of your own, and keep the weeks between at full price.
From Planning a promotion calendar, Memorial Day, July 4 and Labor Day sales
Test the same offer value as percent off, dollars off and a free gift, and keep whichever earns the most profit per visitor.
Make a Black Friday sale a clear step above your everyday offer and below your break-even discount.
Use single-use codes with limits and expiry, and allow discounts to stack only in combinations you planned and costed.
From Stacking discounts and abuse, Creator discount codes without margin leaks
The 10 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Plan the sale calendar
How many sales to run, when to run them and how deep to go.
How should we plan a promotion calendar for the year?
Plan the year around a few sale moments customers expect, plus one or two of your own. Keep the weeks between at full price with other offers. Check every 6 months that repeat buyers still pay full price.
Medium confidence · 11 sources
Should Black Friday offers be bigger than the rest of the year, and by how much?
Make a Black Friday sale a clear step above your everyday offer, typically 20 to 30% off sitewide and below your break-even discount. Test your previous Black Friday depth against one step lower and higher on an earlier sale.
Medium confidence · 18 sources
Should a consumer brand run Memorial Day, July 4 and Labor Day sales, and how deep should the discount go?
Run a holiday-weekend sale only where your buyers are already shopping that weekend, and count it among your few sale moments. Go about 20 to 25% off, below break-even. Judge it on profit after the sale, not weekend revenue.
New Nov 19 Medium confidence · 8 sources
How should we run flash sales without training buyers to wait?
Run flash sales rarely, about 4 to 6 a year at most. Give each a real reason, a kept deadline and codes that expire within 24 to 72 hours. Watch repeat buyers' full-price buying.
Medium confidence · 10 sources
Shape the offer
Which discount format to use, whether to keep a welcome offer and who gets early access.
How should we choose between percent off, dollars off and free gifts?
Run the same offer value as percent off, dollars off and a free gift, and keep whichever earns the most profit per visitor. Give dollar offers a minimum spend and set gift thresholds above your usual basket.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
Should we offer a first-order discount, and how do we measure what it costs?
Keep a welcome offer by default, as a unique single-use code that expires and works only on first orders. Premium brands should test a perk instead. Judge either on profit against a no-offer holdout.
Low confidence · 16 sources
Should we run early access sales for subscribers and customers?
Yes. Give subscribers and past customers a head start of about 24 to 48 hours on your bigger sales. Keep the group smaller than your whole list, and give it its own perk rather than a deeper discount.
Medium confidence · 13 sources
Guard your margin
How to stop codes stacking or leaking and how to end a sale cleanly.
Should we offer stacking discounts, and how should we prevent abuse?
Don't let discounts stack by default. Allow only combinations you planned and costed, and keep codes off sale items. Use single-use codes with limits and expiry so leaked or farmed codes can't run up discounts.
Medium confidence · 12 sources
How should we use discount codes for creators and partners without margin leaks?
Give each creator a unique code that works once per customer, ends on a set date and won't stack with other offers. Reverse commission on refunds and replace any code that leaks.
Medium confidence · 11 sources
How should we end a sale period cleanly?
End each sale at the announced time, in every system at once, with end dates set before launch. Don't extend it or rerun a similar deal soon after, and go back to full price.
Medium confidence · 15 sources
More in Pricing
43 answers in 6 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to plan for Black Friday and peak season · How to market a local service business · How to set prices and run discounts