Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Display, unticked

Saturday means the week in review, and the most useful thing in it is another date. In the week of December 1, Google takes away the campaign-level switch that kept Demand Gen off the Display Network, so this issue opens with the one check to run before then. After that: Friday's news, including a Haus test that says where Black Friday money stops working, the week's three big stories with their endings, and everything that changed in the Answer Book.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Layered paper funnel with a sieve catching toy blocks and app tiles, only screens passing through

Callback to the 10th. Two Tuesdays ago I told you Google was moving the Demand Gen opt-out from the Display Network down to the ad group. Google's Ads Developer Blog says that from the week of December 1, 2026, Display targeting can no longer be switched off at campaign level. Campaigns that used the old switch get rewritten, and ad groups that targeted only Display under it get paused (Google Ads Developer Blog). Google says default serving won't change. Google's help page already puts every Demand Gen channel, Google Display Network included, in the ad group's channel controls (Google Ads Help).

What changed today is who has to check. Google's post was written for API users, so our answer on Google video placement exclusions used to aim this check only at campaigns built through the API or other tools. PPC Land, relaying PPC News Feed, now reports the switch applies in the Google Ads interface and Editor too (PPC Land). Google hasn't said that in its own words, but Google is rewriting every campaign that used the opt-out, whichever tool built it. So the call changed. If any Demand Gen campaign of yours keeps Display off, open each of its ad groups from the week of December 1 and confirm Google Display Network is unticked. The rest holds: set placement and content exclusions once at the account level, exclude the Content Suitable for Families theme and check where your ads ran every month.

The timing is rude. The rewrite lands the day after Cyber Monday, when nobody wants to open ad groups one by one. Put it on the calendar now and you'll thank yourself on December 1.

The week's big three

Black Friday money. Thursday's issue asked whether your rising costs were the season or you, and Friday's laid out the pacing plans. On Friday Olivia Kory of the incrementality testing seller Haus posted a three-cell Google Shopping test from Black Friday 2025 for one unnamed brand (Olivia Kory). The cell running 40% above normal spend through the lead-up and the peak returned 2 times its break-even incremental return. The cell that added another 55% on top during Black Friday and Cyber Monday got little extra, with that last slice of spend about 80% below break-even. Haus sells these tests and calls it "just one example." Our answer on Google budgets around sales peaks sets Black Friday and Cyber Week budgets at about 3 times expected spend, which is headroom for the campaign, not an order to spend all of it. One brand doesn't move the call. It does say the lead-up is where the extra dollars earn their keep, and the last ones on the big day can be the most expensive you buy all year.

Plumbers. Three issues in a row went to the service businesses, and the reason was a changed call. Our answer on Local Services Ads cost and value changed on Wednesday: with manual lead disputes gone once your account moves into Google Ads, turn off services you don't offer and review leads on the Leads page in place of counting on credits. Friday's issue added the money, $47 to $75 a lead in the middle of the pack.

Meta's terms. On Thursday Meta said its revised Commercial Terms, the ones that let its crawlers read your site, stay on hold. On Friday the agency Common Thread Collective said the new terms took effect that day, and I told you to go with Meta on Meta's terms. Now Common Thread Collective has caught up: it says Meta paused the revised Commercial, Product Catalog, Self-Serve Ad and Ad Creative Generative AI terms, so the existing Self-Serve Ad Terms stay in force (Common Thread Collective). It also notes those existing terms already let Meta crawl your domains when you place an ad order. Our answer on letting Meta's crawlers read your pages holds: let the ads crawler in and set the AI-training crawler by its own robots.txt rule. Case closed until early 2027.

Friday's other notes

  • Google started rolling out Connected Apps in US Search and the Gemini app, which let shoppers build a grocery order and check out with Albertsons, Safeway, Shaw's and Target without leaving Google (Google). Google gave no way for other stores to join.
  • Our answer on selling through AI shopping assistants holds: put the work into complete product data and stay listed where Shopify turns channels on by default.
  • Search Engine Roundtable reports Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, ChatGPT and Claude now give coupon codes straight in their answers a week before Black Friday, with at least one code that appeared to come from community or affiliate pages (Search Engine Roundtable). These are sightings, not an announced feature.
  • Our answer on searches for discounts and coupons already points coupon searches at an official offers page, and now that page may be what the AI reads, so keep the codes on it current.
  • How much shopping happens in AI chat? SparkToro's Rand Fishkin looked at 118,163 prompts from 12,321 US panel users from January to October and found 6.9% of ChatGPT conversations show intent to buy, and he estimates Google's rate of purchase-related queries at more than 16 times ChatGPT's (PPC Land). PPC Land flagged some inconsistencies between the study's text and charts. A DoubleVerify survey of 22,000 consumers in 21 countries in the same piece put AI chat at 17% for product research, against 39% for search engines. Both fit our answer on Google's AI Mode, which sizes AI search as small and treats it as part of SEO.
  • The ad tech company Verve, in a US holiday report covering September 1 to November 16, says Amazon draws 24% of retailer searches but shows up in only 11% of AI shopping answers, while Target goes the other way, at 5% against 8% (PPC Land). Verve names no AI platforms and warns that "a mention is not a recommendation." Our answer on how AI assistants pick brands to recommend says they name brands the wider web already discusses, and search share clearly doesn't carry over one for one.
  • Bending Spoons agreed to buy Mailchimp from Intuit for $3.68 billion in cash, about 31% of what Intuit paid in 2021 (about $12 billion), with closing expected in early 2027 (PPC Land). Bending Spoons describes its own playbook as reorganizing teams, overhauling technology and pushing monetization.
  • Our answer on choosing an email platform doesn't recommend Mailchimp, so the call stands, but if you're on it, budget for a price change in 2027.
  • Cody Plofker writes that for his new brand Winks he shipped nine landing pages in the first week with Claude writing 90% of the copy, and "it is not working very well." Three copywriters then told him copy is "95% research" (Operators).
  • Our answer on where new creative ideas come from starts with customer research in customers' own words, and Plofker's plan now matches it: find the words through research, then let AI scale them.
  • Common Thread Collective says test a base fee plus commission with 3 to 5 creators in Q1 2027, now that Instagram creators can earn Amazon commissions from links in reels and posts, and warns those Amazon sales won't show in Meta reporting (Common Thread Collective).
  • Our answer on how to pay creators for ads already pays most creators a share of sales with a monthly minimum for your best few.
  • A model is suing the clothing brand RomperJack, alleging its new owner used AI to turn 2021 still photos of him, shot with no signed release, into new images and a video for Instagram ads (PPC Land). These are allegations, with no ruling.
  • Our answer on usage rights in creator contracts names every platform and ad type in the license, and after this I'd add a line on AI edits too.
  • Snap's head of performance marketing and the CMO of the hair accessories brand Kitsch say last click misses Snapchat demand that spreads through DMs and group chats, and Kitsch used a geo holdout to show Snap's value beyond the click (AdExchanger). That's Snap grading itself, with a customer along for the ride.
  • Our answer on measuring Snapchat results treats Snap's reported results as a ceiling and agrees on the holdout.
  • The Google Ads agency Echelonn says one client scaled Google to over $800K a month after splitting branded from non-branded traffic, launching over 100 prospecting campaigns, rebuilding product feeds and pushing Demand Gen past $769K a month (Echelonn). It's an agency's own case study.
  • Our answer on how fast to scale Google spend adds budget in 15 to 20% steps only where campaigns are limited by budget and meeting target, which is slower and much less exciting to write a newsletter about.

The week in the book

Sixty-seven new answers this week, 55 of them on Tuesday, which Wednesday's issue walked through topic by topic (Wednesday's Daily Call). The featured one is Thursday's: our answer on ads for Valentine's, Mother's and Father's Day says start gift messaging 3 to 4 weeks out, push hardest in the last 2 weeks, sell gift cards after your shipping cutoff and lead with gift-ready offers rather than sitewide discounts. File it under January homework.

Eleven calls changed, two of them above. One is new to this issue, from Friday.

  • Setting up and reading a Google Ads experiment now holds a bid strategy switch, a move into Performance Max or a wider rollout to 95% confidence, because Google's product leads say 80% is enough only for a directional tweak. Test setup and length are the same.

The other eight, all covered earlier in the week.

Thanksgiving is in 5 days. Black Friday is in 6 days. Google's Demand Gen rewrite lands in 10 days.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue