How should we pay creators for ads: a flat fee per video, a retainer, or a share of ad spend or sales?
Our answer
Pay most creators a share of their ads' sales or spend. Give your best few a monthly minimum tied to a video quota. Use flat fees only to start new creators or for one-off shoots.
- Confidence
- Low to medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 Meta rules
- 3 datasets, 11 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 19 sources
- 24 statements
RM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentFew videos win, so a flat fee pays for many losers. About 5% of Meta creatives become winners (Motion, a creative analytics software maker). From Motion's rates by account size, Riffkit works out that a flat fee buys about 11 to 25 videos per winner.
Creator content paid on a share of sales should be one of your 3 or 4 production sources. Common Thread Collective tells brands to make creator content paid on a percentage of sales one of their 3 or 4 production sources.
A minimum keeps good creators producing while they learn. zeroto1, a creator program agency, paid $1,000 to $2,000 retainers for months to creators who later won.
Our judgment
Paying a share of results is cheaper per winner than flat fees. We base this on Motion's 5% hit rate (a flat fee pays for every video, a share pays mostly for winners) and Riffkit's cost-per-winner method. We pick it over IAB's finding that most brands pay flat fees, because IAB measures what brands use, not what works. The under-$10K line comes from Motion's smallest spend tier, which Riffkit uses, and Wispr Flow's 7% of ad spend: 7% of $10K is $700 a month across all creators.
Our judgment, built from Motion, Riffkit, IAB (Interactive Advertising Bureau) and Hector Serrano, Wispr Flow: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
24 statements from 19 sourcesCommon Thread Collective, an agency, says Instagram creators can now earn Amazon commissions in feed, so test base fee plus commission deals with 3 to 5 creators. Those sales won't show in Meta.
“Organic affiliate purchases through Amazon will attribute to Amazon, not to your Meta ad account.”
Instagram says partnership ads need the partner's permission, which they can revoke at any time. Content-level permission covers single posts; account-level permission suits ongoing partnerships.
“Account-level permissions offer broader access and are more suitable for ongoing partnerships”
Instagram lets creators revoke an advertiser's partnership ad permission at any time, which pauses any of that advertiser's running partnership ads from their handle.
“Note: Any ads that are currently running will be paused.”
The FTC's endorsement guides make advertisers liable for misleading endorsements and undisclosed ties, require them to guide and monitor endorsers, and count free products as a connection to disclose clearly.
“Provide guidance to their endorsers on the need to ensure that their statements are not misleading and to disclose unexpected material connections”
PPC Land says partnership ad deals set a fee, scope and term, and Meta permissions can expire, but a platform permission does not prove the music, people or footage were cleared for ads.
“does not confirm that the music, the people on screen or the footage were cleared for advertising”
Wispr pays creators 7% of the ad spend on their ads, plus a minimum such as $1,000 a month for 25 videos, topped up only when commissions fall short. Ecommerce brands pay a share of sales instead.
“And a smart retainer is basically the minimum amount of money a creator will make as long as they hit their quota of videos.”
Cody Plofker says Winks gets 60 videos a month from five retained creators, and an AI agent writes copy, picks landing pages and uploads ads to Meta paused for his review. Its first drafts usually need tweaks.
“Tbh, V1 of ads usually need tweaking.”
zeroto1, an agency, starts creators on a percentage of attributed sales and adds flat fees only to activate new ones. It says the fastest-scaling brands on Trybe pay 5 to 10% commission, not 30%.
“the fastest-scaling brands on Trybe pay 5 to 10% commission, not 30%”
In one zeroto1 client's 90-day test, content challenges made 1,694 videos at $15.90 each and paid creator campaigns 1,074 at $104.52 each. Some top creators got $1,000 to $2,000 monthly retainers for months first.
“Challenges find creators, paid campaigns scale them, retainers keep them.”
Spark UGC, a UGC studio, says mid-tier creators charge about $150 to $300 per base video; 12 months of paid-ad rights add 50 to 100%, and the all-in cost is about 1.5 to 2.5 times the base.
IAB's survey of 453 creator ad buyers, relayed by Analysis Atlas: three in four brands pay creators flat fees, 49% use performance-based pay, 48% retainers, and only 28% use affiliate networks.
“Three in four brands pay creators flat fees, according to IAB, with performance-based pay (49%) and retainers (48%) used alongside.”
Ridge's CMO says partnership and affiliate ads grew from about 3% to nearly 40% of Meta spend during its 2026 sweepstakes and beat the baseline account's ROAS.
“more creators making more useful content, not volume for its own sake.”
Launchpoint, which sells creator programs, says base pay plus commission is the most common creator deal in 2026, since only about 20% of influencer purchases can be tied to a link. Agree usage rights in the brief.
“Commission-only deals stay rare because only around 20% of influencer purchases are directly link-attributable.”
CTC's Luke Austin says brands need three or four creative sources, one being creators paid on sales through marketplaces, and growing brands now make 1,000 to 2,000 new ads a month.
An AI video vendor says to budget creators by cost per winning ad: divide all-in cost per video by hit rate. At Motion's 2026 rates that is about 25 videos per winner under $10K a month and about 11 over $1M.
Connor MacDonald says creator partnerships can't be justified by the creator's own reach. The content has to resonate enough that you can pay to promote it further.
“you can't justify it via the distribution of the creator themselves.”
A BK Beauty co-founder says flat-fee influencer sponsorships rarely return the 3 times in sales she expects, because creator rates are so inflated.
“if I'm going to pay that flat fee, I'm expecting three times that in sales. And that's just not really happening because the rates are so inflated.”
Nik Sharma says gifting product for stories or paying for a single influencer post does not drive direct sales, compared with performance-focused models.
“sending an influencer product and hoping them to post on stories, not working”
Ridge's Sean Frank, after $10M on influencers, says deals are priced on reach (CPM), Ridge gets about $10 base CPM, and creators outside your category often work better.
“Non-endemic is often BETTER”
Eightx says creator commission must clear about $5 a sale (11% at a $45 order), with most brands setting 15 to 20% plus behaviour bonuses and paying about 5% of ad spend, capped, to license content.
“A blanket move from 20% to 30% pays the extra ten points on every sale, including the sales you were already going to get.”
Jeremy Horowitz says brands can scale with micro-influencers of about 1,000 followers or fewer, paid only on commission, which he finds more capital efficient than ad spend.
“It's like people with like a thousand followers or even less.”
Katie Hunt says her brand pays creators a flat fee of about $200 for several videos to run on Meta, YouTube and TikTok, which she prefers to traditional influencer deals.
“we only pay like $200 truly and they'll send us multiple videos, which then we can put on meta and YouTube and TikTok”
Motion counts a winner as an ad spending at least 10x the account's median ad and at least $500, which about 5% of ads reach. Losers are ads turned off within 28 days.
Collabstr's marketplace data on more than 21,000 collaborations: 80% of creator collaborations cost under $300, and the average UGC campaign cost fell 5.7% to $197. No data on usage fees or performance.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer