All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

Are customers we win during Black Friday and Cyber Monday worth less than customers we win at full price, and should our sale ceiling on new-customer cost be lower because of it?

The PrevailingPublished Nov 15, 2026

Our answer

Usually worth less, but check your own cohorts first. Compare past Black Friday new customers with normal-month ones on full-price repeat orders and gross profit. Lower the sale cap on new-customer cost only as far as they fall short.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
2 datasets
2 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
Sources
7 sources
9 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Black Friday buyers come back less often. Only 4% of Black Friday 2024 new customers at Ometria's retail clients bought again within 12 months. That makes them six times less likely to return than a typical new customer.

Sale clicks also earned back less by year end. Meta clicks bought over BFCM 2025 reached 1.18 ROAS by December 31, against 1.40 for October clicks, which had longer to settle (Wicked Reports).

How far to cut the cap depends on your own cohorts. Foxwell Digital tightens payback for November and December buyers to 30, 60 or 90 days. Echelonn would pay less for sale buyers who bought once, and more for ones who came back.

Our judgment

Treat a lower sale cap as something your own cohorts have to justify, not a default, and size any cut by the gap in gross profit per customer over the same number of months. The datasets show sale buyers repeat less on average, but Echelonn says some brands' sale buyers are as valuable as regular customers, so the average gap may not be yours.

Our judgment, built from Taylor Sicard, Echelonn, Fudge and Foxwell Digital: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

9 statements from 7 sources
  • EchelonnNov 13, 2026Supports

    Jackson Blackledge of Echelonn says BFCM buyers can be worth less than normal buyers, so cheaper BFCM acquisition can still mean less profit. Compare past BFCM buyers' repeat rates before setting how much CAC to pay.

    “You need to know the value of your BFCM customers before deciding how much to spend acquiring them.”

    Read it on echelonn.beehiiv.com

  • Andrew FoxwellOct 30, 2026Supports

    Alex Greifeld says November and December customers are almost always the lowest lifetime value, so tighten their payback targets to 30, 60 or 90 days. No data shown.

    “customers acquired in November and December are almost always the lowest lifetime value segment”

    Read it on foxwelldigital.com

  • Andrew FoxwellOct 26, 2026Supports

    Ben Radack, reported by Andrew Foxwell, says to audit the previous Black Friday's new-customer CAC and LTV and ask whether you can still afford that CAC after changes in margins and costs. He gives no figures.

    “Can you afford that same CAC this year, considering any changes to your margins or costs (tariffs, supply chain, etc.)?”

    Read it on foxwelldigital.com

  • Taylor Sicard ConsultingOct 21, 2026Supports

    Taylor Sicard, a DTC consultant, suggests checking a past sale by comparing customers first acquired in it, split by discount use, with a normal month's cohort on gross profit per customer over your repeat cycle.

    “Compare gross profit per customer, not revenue, for each cohort over the same number of months.”

    Read it on taylorsicard.com

  • Taylor Sicard ConsultingOct 21, 2026Supports

    Taylor Sicard, a growth consultant, says a deep Black Friday discount buys orders, not customers: at 60% margin, 25% off needs 71% more orders to break even, and few Black Friday buyers return.

    “at 60% gross margin, 25% off needs 71% more orders just to stand still.”

    Read it on taylorsicard.com

  • Wicked ReportsOct 7, 2026Supports

    In Wicked Reports' Q4 2025 Meta cohorts, October clicks rose from 0.82 to 1.40 ROAS by December 31, while early December and holiday clicks never broke even (0.96 and 0.88). Later cohorts had less time to settle.

    “Shift acquisition budget earlier into October, where the settle multiplier is highest.”

    Read it on wickedreports.com

  • AppLovinOct 5, 2026Caveat

    AppLovin says in BFCM 2025 new-customer checkouts hit 3.3x the normal baseline versus 2.9x for returning customers, and suggests separate new-customer campaigns started a week or two early. Its own data.

    “Avoid cutting or reallocating their budget based on the first few days”

    Read it on applovin.com

  • FudgeAug 22, 2026Supports

    Fudge, a Shopify tool vendor, says after BFCM measure new-customer share, contribution per order by discount tier, the cohort's 30, 60 and 90 day repeat rate against earlier cohorts, and final returns.

    “If your deepest discount tier contributed close to nothing per order, you bought revenue, not profit.”

    Read it on fudge.ai

  • Ometria2025-12Supports

    Ometria's retail clients got 55% of 2025 Black Friday revenue from existing customers, and only 4% of Black Friday 2024 new buyers bought again within 12 months. Sample size not given.

    “Opting out of Black Friday is a legitimate strategy too”

    Read it on ometria.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Budget, channel mix and seasonality