Measurement
Judge Google on total store sales and prove its effect with geo holdouts. Use Google's own reports to compare and fix campaigns, not to prove they work.
14 answers · 8 new or changed since Nov 16 · Data as of Nov 22, 2026

The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 14 answers below.
Judge Google on total store sales with a factor from your own holdout, and test branded search, non-brand and Performance Max separately.
From Which Google numbers to trust, Testing whether Google spend is incremental
Make only the sale or qualified lead primary, keep other actions secondary and keep data-driven attribution on every primary action.
From Google conversion action settings, Attribution model in Google Ads
Turn on enhanced conversions and Google tag gateway first, and add a server-side container only when your spend justifies it.
Test a change in Google's own experiment, split 50/50 with nothing else changed, and run it at least 4 to 6 weeks.
The 14 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Prove what Google adds
Which numbers to trust and how to test whether Google spend adds sales.
Should we judge Google results by Google Ads reporting, GA4 or a third-party tool?
Judge Google on total store sales with a factor from your own holdout. Use Google Ads reporting to compare campaigns inside Google, GA4 for cross-channel trends and a paid attribution tool only from about $50K a month across channels.
Medium confidence · 17 sources
How do we test whether our Google spend is incremental?
Test Google with a geo holdout read on total store sales, not Google-reported conversions. Test branded search, non-brand and Performance Max separately. Use Google's Conversion Lift once you have 1,000 observed conversions and a $5,000 study budget.
Updated Nov 22 Medium confidence · 10 sources
How do we measure the effect of YouTube on search and direct sales?
Measure YouTube's effect with a geo holdout read on total sales and branded search. Add Google's Search Lift study if you qualify. Treat Branded Searches counts as a signal, not lift.
Medium confidence · 10 sources
How should we read Performance Max reporting, given what it hides?
Use Performance Max reports to find where spend goes and what to fix, not to prove the campaign works. Read the channel, search term, asset and placement reports within their limits, and test whether it adds sales with a holdout.
Medium confidence · 8 sources
Set up conversion tracking
How to install, repair and extend tracking, including phone and chat sales.
Which conversion tracking setup does Google need now?
Turn on enhanced conversions with the Google tag on every page, serve tags through Google tag gateway and pass at least 3 identifier signals per conversion. Add a server-side container only when your spend justifies it.
Medium confidence · 6 sources
How should we set up Google Ads conversion tracking: Google tag, Tag Manager, GA4 import or our store's app?
Make a Google tag conversion your primary purchase action, installed through your store's Google app or plugin, or Tag Manager elsewhere. Keep any GA4 import of the same sale secondary so bidding counts it once.
Updated Nov 18 Medium confidence · 7 sources
Google Ads says our conversion tracking is not working or incomplete: how do we find and fix the cause?
Start with the conversion action's status. Misconfigured means a broken setup, while Awaiting conversions often just means no recent sales. Find what changed, test with Tag Assistant from a real ad click and exclude the broken dates from bidding.
New Nov 17 Medium confidence · 8 sources
How should we track phone orders and chat sales that start from Google ads?
Tie calls to clicks with forwarding numbers or call tracking. Count calls above a 30 to 90 second minimum. Once volume allows, make calls and chats that became sales, imported with value, the primary action.
Medium confidence · 12 sources
Choose conversion settings
Which actions count, which attribution model to use and how long a window to set.
Which windows and settings should our Google conversion actions use?
Make only the sale or qualified lead primary and keep other actions secondary. Count every purchase but one lead per click, start with a 30-day click and 1-day view-through window, and keep data-driven attribution.
Updated Nov 18 Medium confidence · 15 sources
Which attribution model should we use in Google Ads?
Keep data-driven attribution on every primary conversion action. Use last click only in a Search-only or very low-volume account. Reset targets after any switch, and prove Google's sales impact with a holdout, not either model.
Medium confidence · 7 sources
How long a conversion window should our Google conversions use?
Set each primary action's click window to your buyers' decision time. Use 30 days for a quick-deciding store and 45 to 90 for leads or high-ticket sales. Upload imported sales within Google's 90-day limit (63 for hashed data).
Updated Nov 17 Medium confidence · 6 sources
Run tests and benchmarks
How to run a Google experiment and read conversion and click-through rates.
How do we set up and read a Google Ads experiment?
Test the change in Google's own experiment for it, split 50/50 with nothing else changed. Leave out one to two weeks of ramp-up, run at least 4 to 6 weeks and judge it on a metric you chose, not auto-apply.
Changed Nov 20 Medium confidence · 7 sources
What conversion rate and cost per conversion should our Google Search and Shopping ads get?
Judge conversion rate by campaign type, not one average. European stores convert about 4.5% of Search clicks and 3.75% of Shopping clicks (smec). Set your cost per purchase from order value and target ROAS.
New Nov 17 Medium confidence · 5 sources
What click-through rate should our Google Search, Shopping and Performance Max ads get?
Judge click-through rate by campaign type, not one average. The median Search campaign gets 8.88% (Optmyzr), while European stores see about 2.2% on Shopping and 1.6% on Performance Max (smec). Read it beside clicks and sales.
New Nov 17 Medium confidence · 5 sources
More in Google Ads
128 answers in 7 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to start advertising on Google · How to market a lead-gen business on Meta and Google · How to market a local service business