Should we sell on Amazon
Sell on Amazon once your site shows real demand and your products clear the margin floor, start with your best sellers, and judge Amazon and site sales together.
7 answers · Data as of Nov 22, 2026
The short version
Our judgment, drawn from the 7 answers below.
Sell on Amazon once your site shows real demand, price in its fees and ads first, and keep Amazon well below 70% of revenue.
List a product only if price minus landed cost is at least 40% of the price, and treat that as a floor, since fees and ads can take most or all of it.
From The margin a product needs on Amazon, Which products to sell on Amazon
Start with your proven best sellers, keep custom items, add-ons and unique variants on your own site, and sell through Seller Central unless a Vendor Central invite still earns your margin.
From Which products to sell on Amazon, Vendor Central or Seller Central
Expect some of the demand your ads create to be bought on Amazon, so judge site and Amazon sales together and keep prices aligned.
The 7 answers
Grouped by the decision you are making. Jump to a group:
Decide whether to sell
Whether Amazon fits your business and the margin a product needs to work there.
Should a consumer brand sell on Amazon at all?
Sell on Amazon once your site shows real demand, since shoppers your ads reach search there. Price in its fees and ads first, and keep Amazon well below 70% of revenue.
Medium confidence · 10 sources
What margin do we need on a product to make Amazon work after all fees?
Sell a product on Amazon only if price minus landed cost is at least 40% of the price. Treat that as a floor, not a target. Amazon's fees and ads can take most or all of it.
Medium confidence · 7 sources
Pick products and account
Which products to list and whether to sell through Seller Central or Vendor Central.
Which products should we sell on Amazon and which only on our site?
Start Amazon with your proven best sellers, not the full catalog. Keep custom items, add-ons and unique variants on your own site. Keep off Amazon any product whose fees leave little or no margin.
Medium confidence · 8 sources
Should we sell to Amazon wholesale (Vendor) or sell directly (Seller Central)?
Sell through Seller Central unless Amazon invites you to Vendor Central and the products still earn your margin after its wholesale discount, co-op and chargebacks. Keep a Seller Central account ready either way.
Medium confidence · 7 sources
Protect your own channels
How Amazon affects site sales, how to handle resellers, and whether to test Buy with Prime.
How does selling on Amazon affect our own site's sales?
Expect part of the demand your ads create to be bought on Amazon rather than your site. Judge site and Amazon sales together, keep prices aligned and give shoppers reasons to buy on your site.
Medium confidence · 10 sources
How should we handle unauthorized resellers of our products on Amazon?
Treat sellers of your genuine product as a leak in your own distribution. Trace it with test buys and lot codes and cut off the source. Report to Amazon only counterfeits, listing abuse or materially different goods.
Medium confidence · 7 sources
Should we use Buy with Prime on our own site?
Test Buy with Prime on a few high-margin products already in Amazon's warehouses, beside your own checkout. Keep it only if contribution per visitor rises after its 3% service fee and fulfillment costs.
Medium confidence · 5 sources
More in Amazon
80 answers in 10 subjects
Guides that use these answers: How to start selling on Amazon