Current answers to the marketing questions consumer businesses ask. Sign in free to read them all.1,898 sources, at least 3 behind every answer.

Recount

Meta's on-device counting switches on November 12, and Meta is now emailing advertisers that their reported results may improve. That makes it a good day for our new answer on what to check when Meta's numbers move week over week. Also: Ads Manager reportedly has a minimum budget now, Google's core update runs into Black Friday week, and there are two new answers.

By Scott Stroud, Editor

Four hand-drawn gauges on one pipe, one needle dropped low and circled in red

Jon Loomer says Meta has emailed advertisers and put an alert in Events Manager about "Measure conversions on customer devices", and that advertisers may see an improvement in reported conversion results (Loomer). The setting is on by default for eligible datasets, needs no integration work and can be switched off per dataset in Events Manager, per Meta's help page. Phil Kiel puts the catch plainly: reported conversions can rise with no change in real sales (Kiel). When Meta grades its own homework with a new red pen, check the grade against the store.

Pilothouse, an agency that sells Meta ads management, offers a yardstick for that check: before Black Friday, deduplicated Meta purchases should capture at least 90% of eligible Shopify online-store purchases, compared over 7, 14 and 28 days in the same time zone (Pilothouse via Direct to Consumer). More than Shopify points to duplicates, fewer to tracking gaps. Our answer on auditing your tracking setup covers the plumbing, and our answer on keeping the on-device setting still says save a baseline before November 12 and switch it off on any pixel where a Black Friday test depends on Meta-reported numbers.

The new piece is our answer on a week-over-week drop in Meta cost per purchase or ROAS, which went live today. Its first step is to confirm the move shows in store revenue and orders and that the attribution setting didn't change. Then split it four ways: CPM up with steady click-through is auction pressure or season, click-through down points to the ad or offer, conversion rate down with steady click-through points to the site, price or stock, and steady cost per purchase with lower ROAS points to order value. It works in reverse too. If Meta's numbers look better on Friday and your store's don't, you know which lever moved.

Meta notes

  • Kiel also reports that Ads Manager now refuses to publish new or duplicated campaigns below a minimum budget that varies by objective and country, while live campaigns are unaffected (Kiel). Meta hasn't confirmed it.
  • Our answer on the minimum budget worth running sets a floor of its own based on the learning phase, which is likely higher than whatever Meta's form enforces.
  • Loomer counts 47 creative enhancements and found a new "Format Display Options" section in Ads Manager, which he calls "very easy to miss"; the catalog tiles that sat under Product Tags moved there (Loomer). He keeps Optimize Website Destination off and calls it "incredibly risky".
  • Our answer on Meta's creative enhancements decides feature by feature too, and Monday's detected-offers story is still the one to fix before your Black Friday copy goes out.
  • Olivia Kory of Haus, which sells incrementality testing, says Meta CPMs this fall are up about 10% year over year across all US markets, with conversion rates not rising to offset it (Kory).
  • Our answer on benchmarking your CPMs puts that inside the normal range for this year.
  • Kiel's take for accounts launching hundreds of new videos a monthcampaign budgets starve most of them, so test one concept per ad set at about 30% of target CPA a day, with no cost caps on tests (Kiel).
  • Kiel's take for accounts launching hundreds of new videos a monthOur answer on where to test new creative says much the same for large accounts, with a separate testing campaign beside the main one.
  • Lorenzo Pravata says Meta groups near-identical creator videos as one entity, so 20 lookalike UGC videos buy you one test (Pravata).
  • Our answer on iterating versus new concepts puts at least half of new production into genuinely new concepts, which is the polite version of his point.
  • Shopify's Campaign Autopilot buys ads on Meta, Microsoft and Snapchat for merchants who set what they'll pay per sale, and Shopify says it "takes that media risk" (AdExchanger), with no results to show so far.
  • Our answer on letting AI agents manage campaigns keeps a person approving anything that goes live, and this is a case where Shopify is the agent.
  • HousekeepingMeta's Marketing API v24.0 stopped working on November 10, so any tool still calling it must move to v25.0 or later (Meta changelog). If a reporting tool went quiet Tuesday, start there.

Google

Google's November core update began rolling out on November 10 and may take up to two weeks, which could run it to about November 24, three days before Black Friday (PPC Land). That's organic search, not ads, but a traffic dip there tends to send people to the ad budget. Our answer on recovering from a core update says change nothing until the update finishes and a full week has passed.

  • A study of more than 400 Google Ads accounts found no shift toward longer queries in search terms reports, including US campaigns on broad match and AI Max, despite Google saying AI Mode queries run three times longer (Search Engine Land). Google doesn't separate AI search in reports. Our answer on ads in AI Mode already says don't move to broad match or AI Max just to reach AI placements.
  • Google product results across Search, Shopping and AI Mode now offer a "Non-incentivized only" review filter (Search Engine Roundtable). If your star rating leans on reviews you paid for in discounts, our answer on Google's review summaries is worth a reread.
  • Google Ads is rolling out an opt-in setting called "Ads with pay-per-lead goals terms" that advertisers must accept first; there's no Google statement or date yet (Search Engine Roundtable). For lead businesses, our answer on Google's lead intent signals covers what Google already offers.
  • Kory's same post puts Google CPCs up about 4% this fall across Haus brands and YouTube CPMs up about 6% (Kory), a gentler climb than Meta's.

Elsewhere

OpenAI launched Businesses in ChatGPT in beta: a business can claim its listing, manage its information, see how people engage with it and, if eligible, build an agent that answers customer questions (OpenAI). No eligibility or country list. Our answer on how AI assistants pick brands to recommend says the wider web's opinion of you counts most, and a claimed listing is one more page the web can read.

New in the book

Two new answers went up today. The featured one: Google video placement exclusions says set exclusions once at the account level, exclude the Content Suitable for Families theme plus YouTube channels and apps that waste spend, and check where ads ran every month. When a soft goal such as add-to-carts suddenly jumps, check placements before calling it a win. Confidence is medium, and the outside sources sell Google Ads management. It's the follow-up to Tuesday's story on Demand Gen's Display opt-out moving to ad groups. The other one is the week-over-week drop answer above.

Meta's on-device counting starts November 12, in 1 day. Black Friday is 16 days out.

Every fact links to its source. Opinions are the writer’s, built from the sources linked beside them.

Every issue