What subject lines and preview text work now?
Our answer
Keep subject lines to about 5 to 7 words and under 40 characters, use one emoji at most and let preview text add a detail. Judge tests on clicks or orders, not raw opens.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 3 datasets, 1 practitioner, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 13 statements
- KL
OSAGK
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShort subject lines get seen and opened. Omnisend's own analysis of Black Friday and Cyber Monday sends favors 5 to 7 words, and it notes an iPhone in portrait shows only the first 41 characters. Klaviyo's own research finds wordier subject lines get fewer opens.
Emojis go with fewer clicks, and first names barely move opens. Across 602.2 million emails, Selzy, an email marketing platform, found emoji subject lines drew a 0.75% click rate against 1.68% without, and a first name barely moved opens.
Apple changed what opens and previews show. Apple's privacy feature can inflate open rates, so Klaviyo suggests click rate when opens blur a test. With Apple Intelligence on, Apple Mail shows an AI summary in place of preview text, unlike Gmail and Outlook (Apple, Knak).
Our judgment
Treat Litmus's nine words and around 60 characters as the outer limit. Don't count on a first name alone, since Klaviyo says it won't do much, and Visionary Marketing's larger open lifts rest on opens it adjusts with its own factor.
Our judgment, built from Omnisend, Klaviyo, Litmus, Selzy and Visionary Marketing: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 10 sourcesApple says that with Apple Intelligence on, Mail shows a short AI summary under each unread email by default. Users can turn off Summarize Message Previews to see the first lines instead.
“A short summary automatically appears under each unread email in your inbox”
Omnisend, which sells email software, says five to seven words is the sweet spot for BFCM subject lines based on its analysis of 5,000 subscribers, and advises under 40 characters and one or two emojis.
“Five to seven words is the sweet spot based on our Black Friday and Cyber Monday analysis”
Klaviyo says test one variable at a time in flows, judge subject lines on opens and content on clicks, and notes Apple Mail Privacy Protection may inflate open rates.
“Note that you should only test one variable at a time. If you test more than one, the results may be skewed.”
Klaviyo says its research on customers' sends shows wordier subject lines are opened less, with the average about 7 words and a roughly 30% open rate, and first name alone does little. No sample or method is given.
“as subject lines get wordier, subscribers on your email list are less likely to open your emails.”
Litmus advises holiday subject lines of no more than nine words and about 60 characters, front-loaded, with one or two emojis at most and only genuine urgency or scarcity.
“Front-load your subject line with the most important information”
Selzy, which sells email sending, analyzed 388,431 campaigns: emoji subject lines had 0.75% CTR against 1.68% without, and question subjects did best at 12.4% opens. Averages across its senders, not a test.
“Several common subject-line tactics were linked to weaker results.”
Attentive's data on over 91 billion subject lines found subjects under 25 characters did best on opens and clicks, and 25 to 35 characters with 30 to 50 character preheaders on conversions. Observational.
“Short subject lines (under 25 characters) and preheaders (under 30 characters) perform best”
Knak says Apple Intelligence summaries replace preview text under the subject line by default and can differ per reader, while Gmail, Outlook and Apple devices without it still show it as written.
“Gmail, Outlook, and Apple devices without Apple Intelligence all display it verbatim”
Litmus, which sells email tools, says inbox AI now sorts and summarizes mail in Gmail, Apple and Yahoo, so put the offer up front, use clean formatting, and set Gmail annotations yourself.
“Use clean, structured formatting so AI summarizes your email accurately.”
Dyspatch says Apple Intelligence replaces the preheader in the inbox list with an AI summary that uses it only as input, while Gmail does not, so subject and preheader pairs that build on each other break.
“automatically replaces your preheader text in the inbox list view”
Visionary Marketing, a UK agency, reports from 32 million sends and 4,200 A/B tests that 35-45 character subject lines work best, with first names lifting real opens 11.4%. It discounts Apple opens by a fixed 76%.
“The optimal email subject line length in 2026 is 42 characters.”
Google says Gmail's AI Overviews summarize a long email thread when you open it, free in the US in English. The post does not say summaries replace preview text in the inbox list.
“Gmail synthesizes the entire conversation into a concise summary of key points”
Klaviyo calls a campaign A/B result significant when each email variant has 50+ deliveries and win probability tops 90%. Open rate tests count MPP opens, so click rate may read cleaner.
“Consider click rate if MPP makes open-rate results difficult to interpret.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer