How should we treat VIP customers?
Our answer
Reward VIPs with access, not discounts. Pick your best customers from your own order data and give them early access, recognition and better service. Keep them out of sitewide discount blasts and reach them early when they go quiet.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 official rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 8 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 18 statements
- K
LSM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBlanket coupons to your best customers give away margin, because they would have paid full price (Lifetimely, Darkroom). Omnisend keeps its top 5 to 10% by lifetime value out of sitewide discounts so the exclusivity stays real.
Good VIP treatment covers the whole relationship. Klaviyo's VIP course pairs a welcome when customers qualify and a nudge to those close to the threshold with personal win-back when a VIP becomes a churn risk, using text or push as the main channel.
Comparing members with everyone else overstates what VIP treatment causes. Smile.io found loyalty members outspend non-members by 72%, but says engaged customers self-select.
Our judgment
Keep discounts out of active VIPs' messages and save bigger offers for VIPs who have lapsed. That reconciles the advice to keep champions out of discount campaigns with LTV.ai's larger win-back offer for top spenders and Darkroom's deepest offer at two purchase cycles overdue. Judge the program on retention and margin against a random holdout drawn from the VIP segment, not on member against non-member spending. That applies Instant's random holdout for loyalty programs to VIP treatment, with Smile.io's note that engaged customers self-select and Sequenzy's advice not to judge VIP sends on revenue alone. Start with one VIP segment narrow enough that early access stays exclusive, such as Omnisend's top 5 to 10% by lifetime value. That follows Klaviyo's advice to start with a single VIP segment and Zettler Digital's point that early access must go to a group smaller than the whole list.
Our judgment, built from Lifetimely, Darkroom, Omnisend, LTV.ai, Instant, Smile.io, Sequenzy, Klaviyo and Zettler Digital: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
18 statements from 13 sourcesKlaviyo suggests defining VIPs as customers a little above your average yearly spend or order count, starting with one VIP segment, and offering early access, exclusive discounts or referral asks.
“To start, we recommend creating a single VIP segment to make it easier to manage your loyalty program.”
Klaviyo, which sells email and SMS, suggests texts or push for exclusive loyalty messages, flows when customers near a VIP threshold, a VIP welcome flow, and winback messages when VIPs drift.
“Build a VIP-specific welcome flow to welcome new VIPs, introduce your program, deliver any sign-up incentives, and encourage them to take their next action.”
Klaviyo advises giving VIP customers white-glove service, skipping brand introductions, adding VIP branches to cart, browse and post-purchase flows, and considering SMS or push as the main VIP channel.
“Loyal customers already know and love your brand, so skip the brand introduction and focus on building personal connections with your campaigns.”
Klaviyo suggests splitting the post-purchase flow at the thank-you email by first-time or repeat buyer, inviting first-timers to the list or loyalty program and keeping order confirmations in separate flows.
“The wants of a first-time buyer or a repeat purchaser are different, and your messaging should reflect that.”
Klaviyo tells senders to mail its engaged segments (opened or clicked in the last 30, 60 or 90 days, or recently joined) and exclude unengaged ones from broad sends to protect deliverability.
“Your engaged segments are the primary groups of people that you should send to.”
Kevin Hillstrom says brands should identify loyal buyers, those with a 60% or better chance of buying again within a year, and win them with premium experiences, not points or discounts. He offers this scoring.
“I define a loyal buyer as somebody who has a 60% or greater chance of buying again in the next year.”
Portland Leather Goods' CMO plans a 55-day holiday season from November 1, reaching existing customers by SMS and email rather than Meta, and turns ads on for the Nov 22 to 28 sitewide sale.
“We now plan a 55-day selling season. November 1st all the way through Christmas.”
Ben Zettler, whose agency sells Klaviyo work, says most Black Friday early access is just a sale sent early to a big list; real early access needs real value, a genuinely small group and a short window.
“Most "early access" during BFCM is just a regular sale sent a few hours early to a bigger list, and customers can tell.”
Klaviyo's recap of Tatcha and Far Niente marketers: give subscribers or VIPs early Black Friday access with a perk like a gift or free shipping instead of a bigger discount. No figures given.
“Tatcha's early-access-only merch item gave shoppers a reason to buy right away, and the brand didn't need to add a discount.”
Omnisend, which sells email and SMS, advises keeping buyers from the last 30 days and VIPs (top 5-10% by lifetime value) out of Black Friday discount blasts. No data behind the rules.
“Exclude recent buyers from your discount blasts to avoid messaging fatigue and buyer's remorse”
Darkroom, an agency, says to give top RFM segments early access and loyalty perks and keep them out of blanket discounts, since they buy anyway. Guidance from client work, no data.
“excluding champions from blanket promotions is often the fastest margin win in the whole system.”
Sequenzy, an email software seller, says a VIP sequence is a relationship program, not a discount stream: define the tier by a written rule, spell out real benefits, and judge it on more than revenue.
“VIP email is a relationship program, not a permanent discount stream.”
Lifetimely, which sells profit analytics, says give top RFM customers early access and referral asks, not discounts, and win back lapsed top customers personally. One apparel store had 15,108 of them.
“should get early access and referral asks, not discounts. They would have paid full price anyway”
Smile.io, which sells loyalty software, says loyalty members outspend non-members by 72% across 10,766 programs, but notes best customers self-select, so measure incremental repeat revenue.
“engaged customers self-select. Joining a program and redeeming rewards are marks of your best customers, not only causes of them.”
Instant, which sells abandonment email software, says loyalty programs only amplify retention that already works, and to test one against a 10 to 20% holdout group. Its thresholds are rules of thumb.
“A loyalty program cannot fix weak retention mechanics. It can only amplify retention that already works.”
ATTN Agency says VIP programs should rest on exclusive access and experiences, about 70% of benefits, not bigger discounts.
“The most successful VIP programs focus on access, personalization, and community over price reductions.”
LTV.ai, which sells email software, says open winbacks with no discount, then tier offers: 20 to 25% off for top spenders, free shipping or a gift for others. Suppress after 4 emails with no engagement.
“No discount. Acknowledge the gap, reference what they purchased, share what's new.”
Yotpo, which sells loyalty software, suggests a Black Friday early access sale for top loyalty tiers, announced a week ahead, with a set share of stock so the main event is not sold out.
“If your VIPs buy all your top products, you'll have nothing left for the main event. Consider allocating a specific percentage of your stock to the early sale.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer