Should we run a referral program, and what reward works?
Our answer
Run a referral program once customers are glad they bought. Reward both sides, make the friend's reward guaranteed and clear, and size rewards to order value and margin. Pay after the return window and test against a holdout.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 controlled tests
- 2 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 10 statements
TLHPEWBB
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA sure reward for the friend gets more referrals than a chance at one. In a randomized test with more than 160,000 app users, a chance-based reward for the sender raised referrals 20.9%, while one for the friend cut them 12.3% (Ting Li and co-authors).
Overpaying the referrer is the common mistake, Eightx (fractional CFO firm) argues. It reads $10 each side, or 10% each, as suited to orders of $50 to $100, and expects 12 to 18 months before a program proves itself.
Local services need their own reward sizes. Housecall Pro (field service software maker) advises $25 to $50 in cash or service credit for most home service businesses, asked right after a job and paid only when the work is real.
Our judgment
- Making the friend's reward guaranteed and plainly stated is our reading of one test. We combined the finding that uncertainty helps on the sender's side and hurts on the friend's with the view that friends convert because they trust the friend, so don't overpay the referrer.
- The referral reward sizes are our bands from several sources. We drew on Eightx's bands by order value, up to $25 plus $25 or more at $150 or more, Housecall Pro's range for local services, and a check against what a new customer costs through ads.
- A referral program can start before a loyalty program. It pays only on results, and Top Growth Marketing puts it first for smaller stores, though Eightx would build loyalty first. Either way, expect the long proving period Eightx gives.
- When to ask customers for a referral is ours. Ask after a good experience, in the first post-purchase emails or right after a job.
- The rules for paying the referrer and the size of the holdout are ours. Pay the referrer only after the friend's order is paid and past its return window, block self-referrals and compare against a random holdout of 10 to 20% of customers.
Our judgment, built from Rotterdam School of Management, Eightx, Housecall Pro, WiserReview, Top Growth Marketing, BLKDG, Brandmovers and ShieldLabs: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 10 sourcesBLKDG, a Klaviyo agency, splits post-purchase emails by first-time and repeat buyers and times reorder reminders to how long the product lasts. Per Klaviyo, post-purchase flows average $1.80 revenue per recipient.
“Judge your post-purchase emails on what they're for: how many first-time buyers place a second order.”
A Rotterdam School of Management article on a field experiment paying loyalty points to 160,000+ telecom app users: an uncertain sender reward raised referrals 20.9%, an uncertain recipient reward cut them 12.3%.
“The most effective referral design combines an uncertain reward for the sender with a guaranteed reward for the recipient”
Brandmovers, a loyalty agency, says a Shopify app suits simple programs under about $10 million in revenue, and to measure a program against a comparison group, since members may already be your best customers.
“Measure the program against a comparison group, because members who spend more may have been your best customers already.”
ShieldLabs, which sells fraud detection, says the most common promo abuse is one shopper making new accounts to keep claiming a first-order discount, which code rules and IP blocks miss.
“No single row is proof. A real customer can shop over a VPN, and two people in one household can share a network and a delivery address.”
WiserReview, which sells review software, advises comparing a referral reward with your customer acquisition cost. It says a $10 to $20 reward can pay off if ads cost $30 per customer. It gives no data.
“If you normally spend $30 to acquire a customer through ads, a $10-$20 referral reward may still be profitable.”
Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, says mature DTC refer-a-friend programs drive 5-10% of revenue at the median and up to 30% at the top quartile. It says to build loyalty first and referral second.
“Mature DTC refer-a-friend programs drive 5-10% of revenue at the median and up to 30% at the top quartile”
Extole, which sells referral software, says from its own clients that 20% of advocates drive 80% of referrals, double-sided rewards are most common, and rewards should scale with order value. No method shown.
“A $10 reward might work well for a $50 purchase, but feel insignificant for a $500 one.”
Housecall Pro, which sells field service software, suggests home service businesses offer $25 to $50 cash or credit per referral, rewards for both sides, and asking right after a job. No data of its own.
“Bring it up right after a job, when the customer is happiest and likely to pass your name along.”
In a mobile game experiment with 66,427 inviters, high rewards paid only on conversion cut referrals 77.4% but raised acceptance over 11 times; those invitees spent 76.6% less.
“while the CRI scheme is effective for immediate conversions, the URI scheme fosters greater long-term value by cultivating higher-quality invitees.”
Top Growth Marketing, an agency, says loyalty ROI is clearer above $500K revenue, launch when repeat rate tops 25%, and set the first reward within 1 to 2 purchases. No data.
“Launch loyalty when your repeat purchase rate exceeds 25% and you need a system to accelerate it further.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer