Should we send handwritten notes, gifts or surprises to customers?
Our answer
Test handwritten notes and surprise gifts on a group of your best customers, without discount codes. Keep them only if the margin on that group's extra spending over a random holdout covers their cost after 4 to 6 weeks.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 3 official rules, 2 datasets, 2 practitioners, 7 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 15 statements
- KMSP
EM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentThe reported wins come from sellers. PostPilot, which sells the cards at $1.99, credits thank-you notes with over $200,000 for one brand. Measured found targeted direct mail in general scores 1.6 times its panel average.
Measuring against an unmailed holdout group can halve a mailing's result. In a worked catalog example by Kevin Hillstrom (MineThatData), $4.00 a book by matchback falls to $2.00 against a holdout. Klaviyo's direct mail course advises waiting 4 to 6 weeks.
Surprises work best on customers who already buy. Skio argues unannounced surprises do not stop cancellations and keeps them for subscribers at 10 or more orders. Intelligems advises that a gift means more to a repeat buyer than a first-time one.
Our judgment
Send notes and gifts without a discount code, because a code turns thanks into an offer and lets redemptions stand in for results. PostPilot itself says only 10 to 30% of customers use codes, Skio says a surprise code feels transactional, and a note that says why you are thanking them fits the Journal of Consumer Behaviour finding that explaining a surprise strengthens its link to loyalty. Start with customers who already buy often, since Kevin Hillstrom expects loyal buyers to be kept with premium experiences rather than discounts. Judge the program against a holdout, not attributed revenue, and weigh the margin on the extra revenue against the cost. Kevin Hillstrom's example loses money at its 40% profit factor and $0.90 catalog cost once the holdout is counted.
Our judgment, built from PostPilot, Skio, Intelligems, Kevin Hillstrom, Klaviyo and Journal of Consumer Behaviour: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 11 sourcesKlaviyo's direct mail lesson, built around PostPilot, says wait 4 to 6 weeks before judging, count from the delivery date, and measure lift against an unmailed holdout from the same segment.
“Start your window from the delivery date, not the send date.”
Klaviyo suggests defining VIPs as customers a little above your average yearly spend or order count, starting with one VIP segment, and offering early access, exclusive discounts or referral asks.
“To start, we recommend creating a single VIP segment to make it easier to manage your loyalty program.”
Kevin Hillstrom says brands should identify loyal buyers, those with a 60% or better chance of buying again within a year, and win them with premium experiences, not points or discounts. He offers this scoring.
“I define a loyal buyer as somebody who has a 60% or greater chance of buying again in the next year.”
Intelligems, which sells offer testing, says a free gift can mean little to first-time buyers and a lot to repeat ones, and a group's own offer pays only if it earns more profit per visitor than your standard sale.
“A group’s own offer pays only when it earns more profit per visitor from that group than your standard sale.”
Contractor+, which sells postcard mailing, says contractor postcards need a unique phone number or QR link, should be judged in a controlled test on won jobs against full cost, and its examples are not results.
“Run an affordable test, track qualified leads and won jobs, and compare contribution with the full campaign cost.”
Lob, which sells direct mail, surveyed 2,000 US adults and found 87% read mail the day it arrives. PPC Land notes this measures recall and intent, with no mailed versus unmailed comparison.
“What Lob has measured is recall and intention, not response rates.”
Measured's panel of enterprise brands found CRM-targeted programmatic direct mail at 1.6x the expansion-channel benchmark, while cold lookalike mail and a large catalog program did worse.
“Target warm, and measure with holdouts.”
PostPilot, which sells robot-written cards, says handwritten thank-you notes to &Collar's top customers brought over $200,000 in extra revenue and 15x+ ROI. It gives no holdout, sample or method.
“Automated thank-you cards are a genuinely high-impact tactic for driving repurchases...for half the price of a latte ($1.99).”
PostPilot, which sells handwritten postcards, claims a tea brand's birthday cards earned 9.6x ROAS and 28.5% conversion, with no comparison group, and says only 10 to 30% of customers use discount codes.
“Make the coupon code short + easy to remember (though keep in mind: only 10-30% of customers use discount codes).”
Skio, which sells subscription software, says to announce rewards at milestones where retention drops over 10%, save surprises for loyal subscribers, and budget 2 to 5% of subscription revenue. No data.
“a reward nobody knows about can't convince anybody to stay.”
Lob, which sells direct mail, suggests thank-you cards after first purchases and other milestones, tracked with QR codes or promo codes. Its measures are response tracking, not a comparison with no card.
“Change one major variable at a time, keep the versions that perform well, and continue refining the program as customer behavior changes.”
Skio's July 2026 update lets subscription milestone rewards count orders across all of a customer's subscriptions, so a customer earns a gift once rather than once per subscription.
“Customer-Level Surprise & Delight lets you reward a subscriber once across all their subscriptions instead of once per subscription.”
Evolve Media, an agency, measures direct mail with a holdout: it keeps 5 to 15% of the target audience unmailed and compares conversions between the mailed and unmailed groups.
“Hold-out testing is the gold standard but requires sufficient audience size to maintain statistical significance (typically 5,000+ in each group).”
Three online experiments found surprise rewards build loyalty only when customers see them as the firm serving them. Explaining why the gift was sent strengthens this, most among cynical customers.
“Providing explanatory information strengthens customer-serving attributions, which in turn enhance customer loyalty”
Kevin Hillstrom's worked example: a catalog showing $0.70 profit per book on matchback lost $0.10 per book once a holdout showed half the sales would have happened anyway.
“Profit per Catalog = $2.00 * 0.40 - $0.90 = ($0.10) per book ... the catalog lost money.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer