All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

How should we build community around the brand, and does it pay?

The PrevailingPublished Oct 29, 2026

Our answer

Build community around what customers already do with your product. Start with your most engaged buyers and give them access rather than discounts. Treat member gains over matched non-members at 90 and 180 days as an upper bound.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
1 official rule
1 dataset, 5 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
Sources
10 sources
12 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Communities that lift repeat buying are structured programs launched with your most engaged customers (TYB, community and rewards software maker). Viral Nation (influencer marketing agency) advises contributing to an activity people already value.

The payoff from community looks bigger than it is. TYB reports 24% higher lifetime value for members across its brands, but loyal customers self-select (Yourmunity). One loyalty client's 34% member gap fell to about 12% once cohorts were matched (Open Loyalty).

Access works better than discounts. Darkroom, ATTN Agency and the founders on Shopify's blog reward members with access, a say in products and events rather than discounts.

Our judgment

Our plan for building community joins several sources. Building around an existing activity, with a say and access rather than discounts, draws on TYB's structured participation, Viral Nation's advice, the founder accounts reported by Shopify and Darkroom's and ATTN Agency's access over discounts. Starting with engaged customers and introducing the community in welcome emails joins TYB's launch advice to Klaviyo's engaged and VIP segments and welcome series. Reading member gains at 90 and 180 days as an upper bound draws on Yourmunity's matched cohort at those points, Open Loyalty's audit where matching shrank the gap and Gladly's holdout example.

Our judgment, built from TYB, Viral Nation, Shopify, Darkroom, ATTN Agency, Klaviyo, Yourmunity, Open Loyalty and Gladly: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

12 statements from 10 sources
  • KlaviyoUndatedSupports

    Klaviyo suggests starting a brand community with engaged and VIP customer segments, hosting it online or in person, deciding who moderates any forum, and introducing it in the welcome series.

    “The welcome series flow is the perfect place to introduce new subscribers to your brand community.”

    Read it on academy.klaviyo.com

  • Open LoyaltyOct 23, 2026Caveat

    Open Loyalty, which sells a loyalty platform, says measure loyalty ROI on revenue lift against a control group, with points liability counted as cost. In one client audit a 34% gap shrank to 12%.

    “Once we matched cohorts on prior spend and tenure, the true incremental lift was closer to 12 percent.”

    Read it on openloyalty.io

  • GladlySep 30, 2026Caveat

    Gladly says to measure loyalty program return against a random holdout of eligible customers, since rewards also pay for spending that would happen anyway. In its made-up example, the holdout cut apparent lift 40%.

    “Hold out customers at the point they’d be invited or eligible, not after they’ve signed up.”

    Read it on gladly.ai

  • DarkroomAug 3, 2026Supports

    Darkroom, an agency, says to give top RFM segments early access and loyalty perks and keep them out of blanket discounts, since they buy anyway. Guidance from client work, no data.

    “excluding champions from blanket promotions is often the fastest margin win in the whole system.”

    Read it on darkroomagency.com

  • AttentiveJul 30, 2026Supports

    Attentive, which sells SMS, relays client results: loyalty members drove 41% of The INKEY List's revenue in one event week, and SMS early access lifted one brand's clicks 26%. No comparison group.

    “A competitor can always offer a bigger discount, but it's much harder to recreate a sense of belonging.”

    Read it on attentive.com

  • ShopifyJul 27, 2026Supports

    Shopify relays founder accounts of community building: Actively Black grew 10,000 Instagram followers and 10,000 email subscribers before a launch that made $55,000 on day one. No comparison group.

    “Instead of sending content creators on a brand trip, they invited their everyday customers.”

    Read it on shopify.com

  • YourmunityJul 8, 2026Caveat

    Yourmunity, which sells community software, says to compare members' 90 and 180 day repurchase with matched non-members, since loyal buyers self-select in, and targets 15 to 25% monthly active members.

    “your most loyal customers will self-select into the community, so a naive comparison overstates the lift.”

    Read it on yourmunity.com

  • ShopifyApr 9, 2026Supports

    Pistakio's founders, on Shopify's blog, say they answer every DM, built a product from community requests, and surveyed fans before switching jars: one of 200 said they wouldn't buy plastic.

    “Our crunchy spread came directly from our community.”

    Read it on shopify.com

  • TYBMar 27, 2026Supports

    TYB, which sells community software, says community members across its 200+ brands show 24% higher lifetime value. It doesn't control for customers who join because they already buy more.

    “Community-engaged customers show 24% higher LTV and 43% higher purchase frequency compared to non-members across TYB's 200+ brand network.”

    Read it on tyb.xyz

  • ATTN AgencyMar 12, 2026Supports

    ATTN Agency says VIP programs should rest on exclusive access and experiences, about 70% of benefits, not bigger discounts.

    “The most successful VIP programs focus on access, personalization, and community over price reductions.”

    Read it on attnagency.com

  • Viral NationJan 20, 2026Caveat

    Viral Nation, an experiential agency, says to judge run club partnerships on participation, feedback and business results separately, since attendance and views are not proof of acquisition or loyalty.

    “Attendance, posts, and views describe different kinds of activity and should not substitute for evidence of customer acquisition or loyalty.”

    Read it on viralnation.com

  • ShopifyDec 23, 2025Supports

    Shopify's blog tells how a comic shop made its 27 pinball machines free on Black Friday, with no sales or discounts, and had its highest-grossing day of the year. One shop's account.

    “No sales. No discounts. Just free pinball.”

    Read it on shopify.com

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Retention and loyalty