Should we sell on Target Plus or other marketplaces?
Our answer
Add other marketplaces one at a time after Amazon, and usually Walmart, run profitably. Apply to Target Plus only if your assortment fits Target and you can ship every order yourself.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 2 Amazon rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 10 statements
- T
CCSSMPCDC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA third marketplace comes after Amazon and Walmart are stable. Cart.com (fulfillment and marketplace services) puts it after Amazon and Walmart, and SalesDuo (Amazon agency) warns against launching two at once.
Target Plus is selective, and you do the fulfillment work. It is invite-only with one seller per SKU. Target replies within 30 days and runs a 75-day onboarding, and sellers pay their own shipping, returns and fulfillment.
Other marketplaces rarely rival Amazon. Marketplace Pulse (marketplace research firm) finds 71% of Amazon-primary sellers on another marketplace still earn three-quarters or more of marketplace revenue from Amazon.
Our judgment
Add one marketplace at a time after Amazon and usually Walmart run profitably. Sellers that run several marketplaces for brands put the third channel after the first two are stable and warn against launching two at once. Treat Target's own seller site as the route in. Target takes applications with a proposed assortment, while Spreetail says there is no application form, and Target's site governs. Build a profit and loss for each SKU on each new marketplace, and push only the products whose contribution margin adds to what you earn elsewhere. You pay your own fulfillment, and Target keeps the customer data (Eightx).
Our judgment, built from Cart.com, SalesDuo, Spreetail, Target and Eightx: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 8 sourcesTarget says Target Plus is an invite-only marketplace with one seller per SKU and no monthly fee, open only to US-registered businesses. It answers applicants within 30 days and doesn't publish referral rates.
“There is no minimum or maximum SKU count required for sellers to launch on Target Plus.”
Target says Target Plus is a curated marketplace with fewer sellers per category and a 75-day onboarding, and claims 30%+ GMV growth in 2025 and $5B expected revenue by 2030.
“A structured 75-day onboarding process ensures you have all the support to launch seamlessly on the marketplace.”
Amazon's new tools pull Shopify and Walmart orders into Seller Central. Marketplace Pulse's 2026 survey finds 71% of Amazon-first sellers on other marketplaces still earn three quarters or more of that revenue on Amazon.
“selling on several channels rarely means being diversified”
Spreetail, which runs Target Plus channels for brands, puts its all-in cost at 15 to 22% versus 30 to 40% on Amazon, with one seller per UPC, and says approval can take six to twelve months.
“Only one approved seller can list a given UPC.”
SalesDuo, a marketplace agency, suggests Amazon brands look at Walmart first at $500K to $1M in sales and Target Plus at $3M to $10M; these are its own planning guidelines, not eligibility rules.
“Revenue tells you when to evaluate. Operational readiness makes the decision.”
Digital Commerce 360 reports that in Q2 2026, Target+ marketplace sales grew more than 40% year over year, and non-merchandise sales, including its Roundel ad network, grew 20%.
“Gross merchandise volume (GMV) on the Target+ marketplace grew more than 40% year over year.”
ChannelEngine, which sells marketplace integrations, says Target Plus has no monthly fee and referral rates of 5 to 15%, a figure Target doesn't publish, and requires shipping within 24 hours.
“Every seller is invited, every product is vetted.”
Eightx, a fractional CFO firm, says a Target Plus invite brings discovery without CAC but costs margin, fulfillment and customer data, so model contribution margin per SKU before joining.
“Treat a marketplace invite as a channel-mix decision, not a growth reflex.”
Cart.com, which sells marketplace management, says pick two or three marketplaces: Amazon first, Walmart second, then a third such as TikTok Shop once operations are stable.
“Amazon first, Walmart second, is the right order for most brands.”
Target's CFO said Target Plus, its third-party marketplace, grew first-quarter 2026 GMV nearly 60%, without giving a base figure.
“On Target Plus, our third-party digital sales platform, we saw nearly 60% growth in first quarter GMV.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer