Should we sell on Amazon outside the US, and which countries first?
Our answer
Expand only once your US Amazon business is profitable, one country at a time. Test Canada, Mexico or Brazil first through Remote Fulfillment, and enter Europe only where demand and a full margin model justify it.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 Amazon rules
- 1 dataset, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 8 statements
- AMPMSECR
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentRemote Fulfillment needs no stock abroad. Amazon's rules let you sell to Canada, Mexico and Brazil from your US FBA stock with Prime shipping. Customers clear customs and pay the duties and taxes themselves.
The US is still the strongest market, with revenue per seller more than $200,000 above the next one (Marketplace Pulse, marketplace research firm). Traffic per seller grew 40 to 57% in Brazil, Mexico, France, Poland and the Netherlands.
Europe can eat most of your margin. EU VAT, fees and fulfillment can cut a 35% net margin at home to 12 to 15%, argues Macetric (ecommerce strategy publication). It wants at least 20% net margin in the model before launch.
Our judgment
Expand only once the US business is profitable, and one country at a time. That joins SellerSprite's advice to have consistent positive margins at home and pick one market, Sean Frank's advice not to go international out of the gate and Macetric's warning on margins abroad. We treat Remote Fulfillment to Canada, Mexico or Brazil as the first, cheapest test of demand, since it needs no local stock (Amazon) and tests the demand Macetric says should pick the market. Brazil and Mexico are also among the fastest-growing stores for traffic per seller (Marketplace Pulse). For Europe we require a margin model with VAT, local fees, duties, currency costs and an EU responsible person, and stock in the UK or Germany rather than Pan-EU. That follows Macetric's margin model, SellerSprite's warning on Pan-EU VAT registrations and the EU's product safety rule (European Commission).
Our judgment, built from SellerSprite, Sean Frank, Macetric, Amazon, Marketplace Pulse and European Commission: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 6 sourcesAmazon says Remote Fulfillment with FBA lets US Professional sellers sell to Canada, Mexico and Brazil without sending inventory there, with customers paying import duties. Remote fulfillment fees replace US FBA fees.
“Customers pay any import duties, taxes, and fees as the importer of record.”
Amazon says a Europe account reaches customers in 28 countries, and with several regions the monthly fee is the lower of USD 39.99 or the summed selling plan fees. Product reviews often carry over to other stores.
“Use a Europe account to reach Amazon customers in 28 countries.”
The EU's General Product Safety Regulation, in force from 13 December 2024, requires a responsible economic operator in the EU for each product covered, such as an EU importer or authorised representative.
“It applies from 13 December 2024.”
Amazon says only 30% of its sellers list in more than one country, and those who do earn 70% more revenue on average. Amazon grades its own sellers; this does not show expanding causes the gain.
“Sellers active in more than one country earn 70% more revenue on average than those selling in just one.”
SellerSprite, which sells Amazon research tools, advises positive margins at home before expanding abroad, launching one market at a time, and starting with Canada or the UK for most US sellers.
“Pick one market, launch properly, prove the model, then replicate.”
Ridge's CEO advises keeping it simple at first (Shopify, Amazon, one wholesale account, one or two 3PL warehouses) and not going international at the start; Ridge itself did too much early.
Marketplace Pulse found traffic per Amazon seller grew 40% to 57% in Brazil, Mexico, France, Poland and the Netherlands, versus 19% in the US. The US still has revenue per seller over $200,000 above the next market.
“U.S. sellers saw traffic per seller rise 19%”
Macetric, an unsigned ecommerce publication, says a 35% net margin at home can fall to 12 to 15% in Europe from VAT and fulfillment costs. It advises a UK and Germany start and a 20% minimum net margin. No data.
“Geographic convenience is not a demand signal.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer