Should we sell on eBay or other resale channels?
Our answer
Treat eBay and other resale channels as outlets for returned and refurbished stock rather than a growth channel. Add eBay for new goods only after Amazon and Walmart run profitably.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 Amazon rules
- 1 dataset, 4 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 11 statements
- ECCAVAFSCMP
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmenteBay's growth is led by collectibles, car parts, luxury and pre-owned fashion. Its focus categories, consumer selling and recommerce make up more than 70% of its marketplace sales (Value Added Resource, a marketplace seller news site).
Marketplace advisers put Amazon ahead of eBay for new goods. Cart.com rates eBay best for collectibles, refurbished, unique and vintage goods, and ranks Amazon first and Walmart second for most brands. FlowLister, a reseller crosslisting software maker, says Amazon dominates new, commodity goods.
Returns have a ready outlet inside Amazon. Grade and Resell relists customer returns as Used, now including shoes and apparel (Amazon). SPS Commerce, a retail supply chain software firm, says to compare its recovery with liquidation and removal for each product.
Our judgment
We read eBay as an outlet, not a growth channel, for a brand's new goods, because eBay's growth is led by collectibles, car parts, luxury and pre-owned fashion, Cart.com puts Amazon first and Walmart second for most brands, and FlowLister says Amazon dominates new goods. We start resale with Amazon's Grade and Resell for FBA returns, compared product by product with liquidation and removal. If you list on eBay, Amazon's free multichannel tools can bring its listings and orders into Seller Central as they reach your account. Weigh that against the deeper dependence on Amazon that Marketplace Pulse warns of.
Our judgment, built from eBay, Value Added Resource, Cart.com, FlowLister, Amazon, SPS Commerce and Marketplace Pulse: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 7 sourceseBay charges most sellers 250 free listings a month then $0.35 each, plus a 13.6% final value fee on sales up to $7,500 and a $0.30 or $0.40 per order fee. Some categories differ.
“13.6% on total amount of the sale up to $7,500 calculated per item”
eBay's Refurbished program requires sellers to qualify, offer at least a 30-day return window and free shipping, and includes a one or two year warranty; items that don't qualify list as Used.
“In order to sell refurbished items on eBay, sellers must qualify and meet a list of condition requirements and have a minimum 30-day return window plus free shipping.”
Amazon says more than 95% of independent sellers in its store sell across multiple channels, and Seller Central now links eBay, Shopify, TikTok and Walmart accounts, rolling out gradually to US sellers at no extra cost.
“More than 95% of independent sellers in Amazon’s store sell across multiple channels.”
Amazon's new tools pull Shopify and Walmart orders into Seller Central. Marketplace Pulse's 2026 survey finds 71% of Amazon-first sellers on other marketplaces still earn three quarters or more of that revenue on Amazon.
“selling on several channels rarely means being diversified”
SPS Commerce says Amazon Grade and Resell recovers part of an item's value instead of disposal but excludes many consumables, and liquidation or removal can pay better, so compare per product.
“Compare recovery values against liquidation, removal orders, and reimbursements to determine the best outcome for each product.”
Value Added Resource reports eBay's Q2 2026 focus categories grew 26% to over 40% of sales volume, led by trading cards, and nearly half of its 2.6 billion listings were promoted.
“Promoted listings comprise nearly 1.3 billion of the 2.6 billion total listings on eBay with 5.7 million sellers using at least one advertising product during the quarter.”
eBay reported Q2 2026 GMV of $22.4 billion, up 15%, with 136 million active buyers. It closed its Depop purchase and extended Authenticity Guarantee to over 100 fashion brands to grow resale.
“strengthening eBay's leadership in circular fashion and recommerce.”
FlowLister, which sells crosslisting software for resellers, says eBay leads for used, discontinued and vintage items, with final value fees of 13.25% to 15% including shipping.
“Final value fees typically run between 13.25% and 15% of the total sale amount, and that total includes the shipping charge the buyer pays.”
Cart.com, which sells marketplace management, estimates US monthly active shoppers at 200M+ on Amazon, 135M on eBay and 120M+ on Walmart, and rates eBay best for collectibles, refurbished and vintage goods.
“Collectibles, refurb, unique/vintage”
Cart.com, which sells marketplace management, says pick two or three marketplaces: Amazon first, Walmart second, then a third such as TikTok Shop once operations are stable.
“Amazon first, Walmart second, is the right order for most brands.”
Amazon's FBA Grade and Resell now covers watches, jewelry, luggage, shoes and apparel, resells returns as Used with prices tied to New, and lets sellers pick up to 2,000 ASINs or the whole catalog.
“Used item prices now update automatically to match New item pricing and discount percentages.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer