Should we send at a fixed time or use send-time optimization?
Our answer
Send campaigns at a fixed time in subscribers' local time zones, chosen by testing send times across 3 to 5 campaigns on clicks and orders. Add send-time optimization only past 12,000 recipients in Klaviyo, and leave flows on their triggers.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 2 datasets, 1 practitioner, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 12 statements
- KM
DOATC
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentThe tools pick by opens, and opens mislead. Klaviyo's Smart Send Time needs at least 12,000 recipients and picks its hour by opens. Klaviyo's and Mailchimp's help pages both say Apple's privacy feature records opens nobody made.
The best hour for opens is not the best hour for orders. Omnisend's study of about 26 billion emails found orders strongest early in the morning, and it tests one send time across 3 to 5 campaigns.
Flows gain little from optimization. Mailchimp's and Dotdigital's optimization leave out automated and triggered emails, and Tribe (Klaviyo agency) argues that flows whose trigger sets the timing gain little from it.
Our judgment
- Default to a fixed send time in each subscriber's local time zone. Choose it by testing send time alone across 3 to 5 campaigns, judged on clicks, orders and revenue per recipient, because opens and orders peak at different hours and privacy opens distort open rates, consistent with Email metrics now that opens are unreliable.
- Turn on send-time optimization only once a list clears the tool's minimum. That is 12,000 recipients for Klaviyo. Check its pick against your fixed time on orders, since Klaviyo's and Mailchimp's tools choose by opens and the lift figure from Charle (Shopify agency) is in opens.
- Keep flows on their trigger delays. Mailchimp and Dotdigital leave automated and triggered sends out of optimization, and Tribe sees little gain where the trigger sets the timing.
- Recheck the chosen time about every 6 months and before peak season. We combined the advice to resend a focused test every 6 months or each year with the suggestion to test send times ahead of Black Friday.
Our judgment, built from Omnisend, Klaviyo, Mailchimp, Attentive, Charle, Dotdigital and Tribe: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
12 statements from 8 sourcesKlaviyo says Smart Send Time needs at least 12,000 active profiles and recipients per send, finds one best time for the audience from opens, and should be rechecked every 6 to 12 months.
“Exploratory and focused sends require at least 12,000 recipients, and your account needs at least 12,000 active email profiles to begin testing.”
Mailchimp's Send Time Optimization sends when each contact is most likely to open within 24 hours of your date. It needs enough send history, 48 hours' notice, and does not work in automated emails.
“This feature is not available in automated emails.”
Mailchimp says Apple Mail Privacy Protection marks emails as opened whether or not they were, so open rates, open-based A/B tests and open-triggered automations mislead; use clicks and purchases instead.
“Clicks and purchases are stronger signs of engagement than opens, and aren't impacted by Apple MPP.”
Top Growth Marketing says test one variable at a time in Klaviyo flows, such as subject line, send time or offer, and let winners run 2 to 4 weeks before calling results.
“Test one variable at a time (subject line, send time, offer amount)”
Klaviyo's CEO announced Personalization, in Preview, which uses models to pick audience, content, send time and channel, with built-in testing against a real customer holdout. No results given.
“Built-in testing measures lift against a real holdout of actual customers, so you never scale on faith alone.”
Klaviyo says its 2025 survey found shoppers engage most in the morning and least on weekends and late nights, though its industry table lists evening first. It advises testing send times before Black Friday.
“Set up Smart Send Time tests to find the optimal time to email your customers.”
Tribe, an agency that builds Klaviyo flows, says to turn on Smart Send Time only in flows where timing is ambiguous, not where the trigger sets the timing, such as abandoned checkout.
“Use it where it genuinely adds value rather than as a default setting.”
Charle, a Shopify agency, says AI send-time features pick a time per recipient and typically lift open rates 5 to 10%. The figure has no method, and opens are inflated by Apple's privacy feature.
“Typical lift on open rate is 5 to 10 percent with no creative work.”
Omnisend's study of about 26 billion emails sent on its platform found Tuesday best for opens and Friday for conversions, with mornings beating evenings. It says to test send times over 3 to 5 campaigns.
“The gap between the highest and lowest day is only about 1.6 percentage points, so the day you choose should usually be guided by click and conversion goals, not by opens alone.”
Dotdigital's send time optimisation picks a time for each contact from their last 90 days of engagement and sends at once to contacts with no history. Split tests and triggered campaigns are excluded.
“We analyse the historical data for each contact individually.”
Attentive, from over 25 billion messages on its platform (method not shown), says the best send times are 8am to 11am or after 7pm, and 12pm to 3pm for clicks. It suggests sending by each subscriber's time zone.
“If you’re after a really great click-through rate, you’ll want to send your emails between 12pm - 3pm.”
Klaviyo warns that Apple Mail Privacy Protection can record opens nobody read, and suggests a separate re-engagement segment for lapsed subscribers and tighter criteria if clicks fall or complaints rise.
“Apple Mail Privacy Protection (MPP) can record an open without the recipient reading your email.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer