Should we use Advantage+ campaigns (sales, leads, app) or build manual campaigns?
Our answer
The answer depends on spend.
Leave Advantage+ on and control results through bids, creative and exclusions. Switch an automation off only for a specific reason.
Keep Advantage+ on, with cost controls as the default guardrail on acquisition campaigns: a cost cap or bid cap on volume and a ROAS goal on value. Run conversion lift tests as a standing program (How often to run incrementality tests).
If you also sell on Amazon or in stores, keep Advantage+ on. Judge it on total sales across site, Amazon and retail with geo holdouts, not site ROAS alone.
Leave Advantage+ on and steer it toward lead quality, not narrower audiences. Send qualified-lead stages back through the Conversions API, and bid down junk-lead ages or placements with value rules.
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAdvantage+ is no longer a separate campaign type. Meta made it a state of every Sales campaign, and most manual targeting controls are gone or only suggestions.
Meta's Incremental Attribution setting returned more in lift tests. Haus measured 1.26 times the incremental return of standard attribution in tests from July 2025 to June 2026.
Practitioners default to Advantage+. Jon Loomer restricts Advantage+ only for legal requirements or a proven performance problem. Common Thread Collective's default structure uses Advantage+ shopping or a campaign budget with broad targeting.
Our judgment
The three cases for switching an automation off come from Jon Loomer's master brief. One is legal requirements, such as age-restricted goods. Another is a proven performance problem, where he prefers a value rule first, hence a placement that value rules can't fix. The third is his one remarketing exception, an upgrade campaign on custom audiences only with Advantage+ audience off, which we extend to retention ads generally.
Our judgment, built from Jon Loomer: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
20 statements from 12 sourcesMeta's Help Center calls the setting 'Audience with Advantage+ on' and treats custom audiences, lookalikes and detailed targeting as suggestions.
CTC recommends folding manual Meta campaigns with tight interest stacks into Advantage+ Shopping campaigns with broad targeting. No test data.
“Shift campaign structure toward Advantage+ Shopping with broad targeting.”
Adweek and PPC Land report agencies pulling live ads to strip Meta AI changes, and AdCellerant says it turns off Meta's default AI automation across every campaign. No performance comparison given.
“we systematically turn off Meta's default AI automation across every campaign”
Meta has removed the existing customer budget cap from Advantage+ sales campaigns, but says you can do the same by hand with an audience exclusion or two ad sets with a spend limit.
“Existing customer budget cap, which allowed Advantage+ sales campaign advertisers to choose whether or not to spend on existing customers, is no longer available.”
Ben Heath says Incremental Attribution steers Meta spend toward sales you wouldn't otherwise get, though Meta's reported ROAS may drop.
In one test built with Meta and its agency Havas, NAR's Advantage+ Audience campaign cut cost per landing page view 29% against its usual targeting. The results are page views and stated intent, not leads.
“Compared with NAR’s standard audience-targeting approach, the Advantage+ campaign generated 432,000 landing page views while reducing the cost per landing page view by 29% and overall spending by 25%”
PPC Land reports that under Meta's Advantage+ audience, your audience entries become suggestions, with location and minimum age the practical hard limits. Some placements were removed in 2026.
“Whatever an advertiser enters becomes a suggestion. Location and minimum age remain the practical hard boundaries.”
Ad-set placement exclusions began disappearing in some Meta accounts, replaced by value rules capped at a 90% bid decrease. The rollout is partial and unconfirmed.
“some advertisers are seeing the ad placements control removed, with value rules capped at a 90% bid decrease.”
Andrew Faris says 100% of his clients run manual bids with incremental attribution.
“100% of my clients are running manual bids with incremental attribution.”
Elevarus, an agency with no data, says to settle Meta's Advantage+ gains against Haus's incrementality results by running automated and manual builds against each other in a geo split or randomized holdout.
“Run a holdout rather than a before-and-after comparison.”
Nate Schulte says Meta ads have become so automated and consolidated that the work has shifted from manual tactics to marketing fundamentals.
“Now it has become so automated. There's a lot of AI integration into the platform.”
Meta's CFO cited Underneat, an Indian online apparel brand, with a 13% incremental lift in purchases and 16% more add-to-cart conversions after moving from manual setup to Advantage+ sales campaigns.
Haus found Meta's Incremental Attribution setting delivered 1.26 times the incremental return of standard attribution from July 2025 to June 2026, up from 0.80, and 1.38 for brands selling only on their own site.
“IA iROAS is beating standard iROAS by a pooled geo-mean of 1.26x, compared to 0.80x in the July 2024-June 2025 period we originally reported on.”
Linear Design says Advantage+ suits accounts with volume and clean signal, and advises keeping a manual control group.
Andrew Faris says he is moving all Meta spend to incremental attribution, selected at the ad set level.
“We are fully embracing incremental attribution”
CTC's default Meta structure is a Sales campaign on Advantage+ shopping or a campaign budget, with an inflated budget, cost control, a minimum ROAS target and broad targeting.
Jon Loomer defaults to Advantage+: one campaign, one ad set, inputs as suggestions, restricting only for legal requirements or a proven performance problem.
Megan Winter, who runs a Meta ads agency, dislikes Advantage+ shopping campaigns, saying they chase the easiest wins and are not sustainable or scalable.
“I don't love it because it's designed to find the low hanging fruit and the easiest wins and it's not sustainable or scalable.”
Meta says legacy Advantage+ shopping and app campaigns can no longer be created through the Marketing API from v25.0, and that remaining ones would be paused at v26.0.
“Legacy Advantage+ shopping and app campaigns can no longer be created through the Marketing API”
Meta made Advantage+ a setting of a Sales campaign rather than a separate campaign type, with audience, placement and budget automation preselected; the API exposes an advantage_state flag.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer
Read next
More in Account structure- Should we test new creative in a separate testing campaign or inside the live campaign?
- Should we use a campaign budget or ad set budgets?
- How often can we edit, duplicate or relaunch campaigns before it hurts performance?
- How many Meta ad accounts should we run, and what should justify a separate one?