Should we use a campaign budget or ad set budgets?
Our answer
The answer depends on spend.
Run scaling spend on a campaign budget (CBO). Keep ad set budgets to a small share, used only where spend must be guaranteed. The exception is a consumer brand's testing campaign at $200K or more a month (Where to test new creative).
At $200K or more a month, scale on a campaign budget. Test new concepts on ad set budgets in their own campaign, one concept per ad set, and let that campaign carry whatever share of spend it earns.
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentLarge-account operators default to a campaign budget so Meta can allocate spend. Common Thread Collective, an ecommerce ad agency, uses Advantage+ or a campaign budget with an inflated budget and a minimum ROAS.
Many ad set budgets become hard to manage at scale. Skaleit Agency scales above $5,000 a day through a single-ad-set campaign budget. It says 30 to 50 ad sets on their own budgets past that point become a full-time job.
Ad set budgets still have one job: guaranteeing spend on one concept or audience. Flighted, a paid media agency, does that through a small ad set budget campaign (ABO) or a spend minimum. Dara Denney argues campaign budgets are more efficient.
Our judgment
Treat a week with no spend for new concepts in their own ad set as Meta's verdict, and answer it with more distinct ads. We follow Jon Loomer here: his Push Delivery check, an underused ad pushed from 10% to 30% for a week, usually confirms Meta had it right. Common Thread Collective adds that more creative with diversity of concept is almost always the right first answer (New ads Meta won't spend on). Our reading that large-account operators agree on a campaign budget summarizes Common Thread Collective, Flighted, Loomer, Skaleit Agency and Denney. At $200K or more a month the small-share limit on ad set budgets does not cover the testing campaign in Where to test new creative's narrower answer. In one account at about $850K a month half of all spend runs through it, and its cost per purchase is level with the scaling campaign.
Our judgment, built from Jon Loomer, Common Thread Collective, Flighted, Skaleit Agency, Dara Denney and Phil Kiel: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
36 statements from 24 sourcesCharley Tichenor says to change Meta budgets at the campaign level, not the ad set level, and to expect CPA to rise after a budget increase. No data.
“And when CPA goes up after you raise it, that's not failure. It's math.”
Phil Kiel, who runs an agency, tests in ABO at high creative volume: each new ad set starts at about 30% of target CPA a day, with no cost caps. He still uses CBO at 10 to 30 new ads a month.
“Every new ad set starts small, around 30% of target CPA a day.”
The DTC Podcast says that if you do not set Meta budgets by product, Meta will overspend on cheaper products because they sell more often.
“what's meta going to do? It's going to naturally spend against a thing that's cheaper because it has higher volume frequency.”
Marin Istvanic says ad set budgets suit tests when new ads hit often, while a campaign budget makes more sense for mixed quality, lots of content and a small budget, though new tests may get no spend. No data.
“If the hit rate of the new tests is high, you can squeeze more from ABO, although it requires more manual work”
Ben Radack's Black Friday playbook, written up by Andrew Foxwell, runs one Meta CBO campaign on highest volume bidding and excludes purchasers from the last 30 days. No data given.
“One CBO campaign optimized for highest volume, not cost or bid caps.”
Meta says Advantage+ campaign budget suits campaigns with at least 2 ad sets and may spend most of the budget on one ad set if that gets the best overall results.
“Advantage+ campaign budget is best suited for campaigns with at least 2 ad sets.”
Meta advises at most 70 ad sets per Advantage+ campaign budget campaign, sparing use of ad set spend limits, not pausing low-delivery ad sets, and ad set budgets if each needs a strict budget.
“Use ad set spend limits sparingly, or not at all.”
Meta says to use campaign budgets when ad sets are valued alike, and ad set budgets to control spend per ad set or when audiences, goals or bids differ. Budget sharing moves up to 20% between ad sets.
“lets you share up to 20% of your daily budget with other ad sets”
Meta's Nik Ketkar says Meta can't yet capture nuances like inventory skews or ad set budget limits inside one campaign. The hosts say that is why accounts end up with 15 to 20 campaigns.
“that type of nuance signal we cannot capture today as yet, but that's precisely where we're going.”
Ben Heath says most accounts should operate with a single ad set rather than using Campaign Budget Optimization.
“you should just be operating with one ad set most of the time anyway”
A buyer managing $7M a month tests creative in ABO ad sets, one concept per ad set with 3 to 5 variations, starting at $100 a day on broad audiences.
“One concept per ad set. 3-5 variations.”
In one account spending about $850k a month, moving creative testing into ABO, one ad set per concept, raised weekly spend on creative under 14 days old from 10% to 38% over eleven weeks.
“CBO makes a new ad take budget off an old one. ABO lets it earn its own.”
Involve Digital, a B2B lead generation guide, says to use campaign budget for prospecting and ad set budgets for retargeting, with a starting split of about half prospecting, 30% consideration, 20% retargeting.
“Use a campaign budget (Advantage+ campaign budget) for prospecting, where Meta can move spend between ad sets, and ad set budgets for retargeting”
Biddyco, an agency, runs one main campaign: under about $50,000 a month, test new creative in its own ad set; at high spend, add it to the winners' ad set. It warns against graduating winners.
“close to the worst thing you can do to an account”
Ricardo Powell says his team sets ad-level spend minimums so top and middle-of-funnel videos still get budget even if they lack last-click conversions.
“we use ad spend minimums on the ad level”
Skaleit says above $5K a day, run a separate test campaign plus a single-ad-set CBO scaling campaign; running 30 to 50 ABO ad sets at that spend becomes a full-time job.
Skaleit, an agency, maps structure to daily spend: under $1K a day, one campaign with one ad set; at $10K or more, a campaign-budget testing campaign plus a single-ad-set scaling campaign fed by post IDs.
“As you scale past $5K per day, an ABO structure with 30 to 50 adsets becomes a full-time job.”
A Scalability School host running a subscription app at about $20K to $25K a day now puts everything into one CBO campaign to compete, instead of testing in ABO first and moving winners.
“I just throw everything into um the one CBO campaign and just let it compete in there against everything else”
Flighted says campaign budget optimization should be the default for scaling, with a small ad set budget test or spend minimum to guarantee spend. It advises against running scale spend in rigid ad set budgets. No data.
“What you should not do is run your scale spend in rigid ABO ad sets.”
Flighted, an agency, has brands spending $5K to $100K a month run a sandbox test campaign at about 25% of spend, one ad set per concept, beside a winners campaign.
“One ad set per creative concept, grouped by theme or format”
Jetfuel, an agency, tests new ads in an ad set budget campaign and scales proven ones in a campaign budget, at any spend from 5,000 to 500,000 a month. It sizes test ad sets at Target CPA x 50 / 7 a day.
“the same shape for a brand spending 5,000 a month and one spending 500,000”
Andrew Faris describes a jewelry client running one consolidated campaign budget with 12 to 15 ad sets, each a group of products with similar order value, margin and lifetime value, with its own cost cap or bid.
“a consolidated CBO”
Andrew Faris splits ad sets by economic unit (products with similar order value, margin and LTV); one jewelry client runs 12 to 15 in one campaign.
Lucas Keeler, who runs a paid social agency, advises consolidating into CBO with Advantage+: fewer campaigns and ad sets, with more creative in each, rather than many small ABO ad sets.
“Advantage+ first, consolidate, fewer campaigns, fewer ad sets, more creative stuffed inside them.”
CTC's default Meta structure is a Sales campaign on Advantage+ shopping or a campaign budget, with an inflated budget, cost control, a minimum ROAS target and broad targeting.
CTC's Taylor Holiday uses the Sales objective in 95% of cases, value optimization with a minimum ROAS to start, and Advantage+ or CBO, and adds bid types by copying evergreen campaigns into cost and bid caps.
Zach Stuck of Motion says his team runs creative tests in ABO, or in CBO with a minimum spend per ad set, so winners have budget room to emerge.
“a CBO with a min spend per ad set”
Jon Loomer prefers Meta's creative testing tool (2 to 5 ads in the live ad set, even spend) to separate test campaigns. Launching 20 to 50 ads at once is wasteful, he says, since Meta puts budget on a few.
“More ads won't get you there. Genuinely diverse ads will.”
Flighted, an agency, runs an ad set budget testing campaign and a campaign budget scaling campaign with cost caps, keeps about 60% of budget under spend limits, and says structure barely matters below $50K a month.
“Below $50k/month, account structure is barely a lever.”
Nick Boddington runs larger accounts as one CBO campaign with many ad sets, using minimum spend limits on ad sets to control distribution.
“one campaign, many ad sets, but the campaign budget is controlling the ad sets and the creators in it.”
Jason Gan says that when ad sets target different groups, such as male and female, and you want even spend across them, set the budget at the ad set level.
“I would definitely prefer to set the budget at the ad set level.”
Jon Loomer says use Advantage+ campaign budget when possible, since fixed ad set budgets force spend into each ad set; use as few ad sets as possible and set spend limits only when optimization struggles.
“you are forcing a predetermined amount of budget to each ad set”
William Kast says to set a minimum spend of about $50 to $70 over 7 days on new ad sets inside a CBO campaign so Meta tests them all, which he says is cheaper than ABO testing.
“This prevents that the CBA looks into just one or two ad sets and doesn't spend on anything else, and it is also cheaper than testing in an ABO.”
Dara Denney says top brands mostly double down on what works. At high budgets ABO testing helps you learn from every creative while CBO is more efficient, and she warns against dogma.
Meta's ad set budget sharing lets ad sets in campaigns without a campaign budget share up to 20% of their daily budget with each other. It needs daily budgets and one bid strategy across ad sets.
“Ad set budget sharing allows you to share up to 20% of your daily budget with other ad sets to improve performance for campaigns not using a campaign budget.”
Meta made Advantage+ a setting of a Sales campaign rather than a separate campaign type, with audience, placement and budget automation preselected; the API exposes an advantage_state flag.
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer