Which bid strategy should we use at our spend: Maximize conversion value, target ROAS or target CPA?
Our answer
Bid for volume first. At about 50 conversions in 30 days, with 4 weeks of trusted order values, test Maximize conversion value in an experiment. Add a Target ROAS only for a return you must hit.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 Google rules
- 6 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 15 statements
- GTP
O
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle wants volume bidding and trusted values before value bidding. Its help pages say to ideally bid on your goal with Target CPA first, report values for 4 weeks, and test value bidding in an experiment with at least 50 conversions in 30 days.
Agencies switch to value bidding at set conversion volumes. Elevarus moves Shopping campaigns to Maximize conversion value at 30 conversions in 30 days. Jetfuel Agency adds a Target ROAS from 80 a month, and Adgenix stays on Maximize conversions below 100 to 150 a month.
The Target ROAS you set becomes the return a campaign delivers. One set too high limits traffic, and since August 17, 2026, a budget-limited campaign delivers closer to its stated target (Google). Without a target, Maximize conversion value spends the full budget.
Our judgment
- We side with Google, Jetfuel Agency and Adgenix on starting with volume bidding, not with Elevarus and LGG Media. Google advises bidding on Target CPA first and testing value bidding in a campaign experiment, and both agencies run ecommerce campaigns on Maximize conversions first. Neither side shows data.
- About 50 conversions in 30 days is our point to test the switch to value bidding. It is the volume Google says a value bidding experiment needs, and it sits inside the 30 to 150 conversions a month at which Elevarus, Jetfuel Agency and Adgenix switch.
- Set any Target ROAS from margin. Google's comparison table puts Target ROAS where the priority is a specific return on investment target, LGG Media sets it from margin or lifetime value, and Optmyzr, a bid software maker, advises checking a target against your margin since budget-limited campaigns deliver to their targets.
- Bid for volume first, then test value bidding, at every spend level. Google and the agencies set their thresholds in conversions, not spend, and LGG Media is the only source that names a spend level, $100K or more a month.
Our judgment, built from Google, Jetfuel Agency, Adgenix, Elevarus, LGG Media and Optmyzr: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 7 sourcesGoogle says to consider Maximize Conversions when you want as many leads or sales as possible, prioritize volume over value or have a tight budget. Maximize conversion value suits a focus on revenue and ROI.
“Choosing a bid strategy is an important part of setting up a Performance Max campaign.”
Google lists three automated bid strategies for Shopping campaigns: Maximize Clicks, Target ROAS and Maximize conversion value. Maximize conversions and Target CPA are not offered.
“Available only for Shopping campaigns”
Google says Target ROAS needs at least 15 conversions in 30 days on Search and Shopping, and values reported for 4 weeks or 1-2 conversion cycles first. A target set too high may limit traffic.
“setting a target that's too high may limit the amount of traffic your ads may get.”
Google says to use Maximize conversion value for the most value within budget and Target ROAS for a set efficiency, which needs at least 15 conversions in 30 days. Report two or more distinct values.
“Target ROAS should have at least 15 conversions in the last 30 days at the conversion tracking level.”
Google says Maximize conversion value without a target ROAS tries to fully spend your daily budget, which could raise spend significantly if you spend well below it. With a target ROAS it behaves like Target ROAS.
“Maximize conversion value strategy with a set target ROAS will behave like a Target ROAS strategy.”
Google says Target CPA can start with no conversion history, recommends a target equal to the last 30 days' average CPA, and warns that a target set too low can cost you conversions.
“For evaluation, we recommend you measure performance for the last 30 days, including at least 30 conversions.”
Google says to test value-based bidding with a 50/50 campaign experiment on campaigns with at least 50 conversions in 30 days, a 2-week ramp-up, then at least 30 days judged on conversion value and ROAS.
“Let the experiment run uninterrupted for at least 30 days.”
Chris Shafer says target ROAS bidding misfires when every lead has the same static conversion value, since the algorithm chases value differences that do not exist.
“T ROAS was chasing conversion values that were static and would never change.”
LGG Media, an agency for accounts spending $100K+ a month, ends its Google accounts on Target ROAS and uses Maximize Conversion Value only while the algorithm learns. It shows no data.
“With no target, nothing stops the strategy from buying low-return clicks to use the budget.”
Chris Shaver, who sells Google Ads management, says Maximize conversions and Target CPA push for the cheapest conversions regardless of lead quality or value.
“Target CPA, which is a system, a bidding strategy in Google, that allows the system to just push for the cheapest conversions.”
Since August 17, 2026, Google bids budget-limited campaigns on target-based strategies closer to their target, so a $10 target CPA now delivers nearer a $10 actual CPA. It won't change targets or budgets for you.
“If your campaign's Target CPA is $10 USD, but your recent actual CPA performance is $5 USD, your campaign now delivers more closely to a $10 USD actual CPA.”
Jetfuel, an agency, picks Google bidding by monthly account conversions: Maximize Clicks under 30, Maximize Conversions at 30 to 80, Target ROAS from 80. It starts Target ROAS at 80% of actual ROAS.
“set your Target ROAS at 80% of your current actual ROAS when first switching to smart bidding. Give it two to three weeks to stabilize.”
Optmyzr, which sells bid automation, says after Google's August 2026 change for budget-limited campaigns, check target CPA against what you can afford and target ROAS against your real margin.
“Take the tROAS and check it against your real gross margin”
Elevarus, an agency selling this migration work, says Shopping campaigns with 30+ conversions in 30 days can move to Maximize Conversion Value without a target; fewer stay on Maximize Clicks. No data.
“Flag any campaign with 30+ conversions in the last 30 days as a Maximize Conversion Value candidate.”
Adgenix, a one-person Google Ads service, starts accounts under 100 to 150 monthly conversions on Maximize Conversions, wants 30 conversions in 30 days before value bidding, and avoids Target ROAS.
“why I don’t use Target ROAS at all in my own accounts”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer