How should we use email to launch new products?
Our answer
Send a launch as a sequence to existing customers before ads. Give your best customers 24 to 48 hours of early access, email the engaged list on launch day, then follow up only with non-buyers.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 official rule
- 4 practitioners, 5 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 10 statements
KMLOSZD
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA sequence beats a single email. Mint and Lily (jewelry brand) ran VIP early access, a founder story and a wider launch, and got 40% more revenue than from its earlier single-email launches, by its own before and after count.
Your best customers should hear first, and buyers should drop out. Klaviyo's launch guide lets best customers buy before the regular launch, keeps texts to exclusive or time-sensitive news and leaves buyers out of reminders.
Existing customers carry a launch while the product finds new buyers. Common Thread Collective (ecommerce ad agency) advises emailing existing and VIP customers 48 hours before ads go live. In its forecasting example, a launch lifts returning-customer revenue first and reaches new customers more slowly.
Our judgment
The 24 to 48 hour window is where the windows from Mint and Lily and Common Thread Collective meet, and we shorten it for a likely sellout as Zettler Digital (Klaviyo and paid media agency) does. Email existing customers before launch ads go live and judge the launch on total sales, including returning customers. That applies Common Thread Collective's sale sequence and forecasting example to launches, is consistent with Launching a new product or offer, and tracks launches as their own campaign type, as Darkroom recommends. Send reminders only to people who showed interest but didn't buy, combining Klaviyo's exclusion of buyers with Mint and Lily's follow-up to openers and browsers.
Our judgment, built from Mint & Lily, Common Thread Collective, Zettler Digital, Darkroom and Klaviyo: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 7 sourcesKlaviyo's product launch lesson says to lead with email, keep SMS for exclusive or time-sensitive messages such as VIP early access, and after launch remind everyone who has not bought.
“Sending too many texts in a short period of time about one topic can annoy subscribers, so only send texts that are exclusive (e.g., early access for SMS subscribers) or time-sensitive.”
Ben Zettler, whose agency sells Klaviyo work, says most Black Friday early access is just a sale sent early to a big list; real early access needs real value, a genuinely small group and a short window.
“Most "early access" during BFCM is just a regular sale sent a few hours early to a bigger list, and customers can tell.”
Omnisend, which sells email software, suggests product launch emails as a series split by segment: early access for VIPs, teasers for browsers and personal picks for past customers.
“For instance, your VIPs get early access, browsers see teasers, and past customers receive personalized recommendations.”
Darkroom, an agency, says to give top RFM segments early access and loyalty perks and keep them out of blanket discounts, since they buy anyway. Guidance from client work, no data.
“excluding champions from blanket promotions is often the fastest margin win in the whole system.”
Common Thread Collective models how launches, emails and promotions move new and returning customer revenue for each brand. In its example, a launch lifts returning customer revenue fast while new customers take longer.
“Every brand has a different relationship of marketing event types”
CTC says before a sale, email existing and VIP customers early access 48 hours before ads, email and text again at 24 hours, then run ads to prospecting only for 2 days. No data.
“launching ads before you've extracted value from your existing customer base”
Darkroom, a retention agency, recommends tracking email revenue per recipient by campaign type, since welcome flows and promotional campaigns serve different purposes.
“A welcome flow email and a Tuesday promotional campaign serve fundamentally different purposes”
Mint & Lily, a jewelry brand, says a launch sequence of VIP early access, a founder story email and then a full-list launch made 40% more revenue than its single-blast launches. No control group.
“The mistake most small brands make with product launches is treating the drop as a single email.”
Sequenzy, which sells email software, says to run a launch as a sequence with VIP early access, one focused launch email and follow-ups, claiming without a source the launch email brings 30 to 40% of revenue.
“A product launch is a sequence, not a single email: build anticipation pre-launch, hit hard on launch day, and follow up after to catch the undecided.”
Klaviyo's help page lists waitlists among landing page uses, collecting an email plus one or two preferences for upcoming products.
“collect email plus 1 or 2 key preferences for upcoming products”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer