Should we run feed-only Performance Max with no creative assets?
Our answer
Run Performance Max feed-only when you lack strong images and video or want spend kept on Shopping ads. Switch off Google's generated assets and check the channel report. Add your own assets only after Google's asset experiment shows a gain.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 Google rules
- 7 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 15 statements
- G
RS9WZ
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShopping does nearly all the selling. Store Growers, River Stone Marketing Solutions, 9AM and ZenoX start a store's Performance Max feed-only. In full-asset campaigns, Shopping drove 92 to 98% of transactions while 15 to 21% of spend went elsewhere (WPMarketingRobot).
Feed-only trades reach for focus. Google lets the campaign launch but rates it Poor on Ad Strength, limits its reach and may still build video from your feed. River Stone sees some spend drift to YouTube or Display.
You can measure what assets add instead of guessing. Google's asset experiment tests adding text, images and video to a feed-only asset group.
Our judgment
- Use feed-only Performance Max as the Shopping campaign for most of the catalog when you lack strong images and video or want spend held on Shopping. Every practitioner source here starts ecommerce Performance Max that way, and Google's own guide says a feed-only group trades reach for focus.
- Wait for about 30 conversions a month with order values you trust, and run Standard Shopping until then. This keeps the answer in line with Launching a new Google Ads account and Performance Max alone or alongside.
- Use the channel report to check the share of spend outside Shopping against a share set in advance. Google can still generate video from the feed and pull images from landing pages on new campaigns.
- Add assets through Google's asset experiment or a separate campaign for best sellers, not straight into the feed-only group. Sources split on adding assets later, and the experiment measures the difference directly.
Our judgment, built from Store Growers, River Stone Marketing Solutions, 9AM, ZenoX, WP Marketing Robot and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 8 sourcesGoogle says Performance Max with a Merchant Center feed can launch with no extra creative but may get a Poor Ad Strength rating, and Google AI may auto-generate text, image and video assets if text customization is on.
“While advertisers with a Merchant Center feed don't need to supply any additional creative assets to launch a Performance Max campaign, they may notice a Poor Ad Strength rating.”
Google's developer docs say a Performance Max asset group built only from the Merchant Center feed can auto-generate assets, but reach and performance will be limited. More assets unlock more formats.
“By linking to Merchant Center, assets can be generated automatically for the campaign, but reach and performance will be limited.”
Google's Performance Max asset test splits traffic inside one campaign and serves the control with no video at all, uploaded or auto-generated, so it measures video against no video.
“Both user-uploaded and auto-generated videos are suppressed for this group”
Google recommends Performance Max video in horizontal, square and vertical formats of 10 seconds or more, and auto-generates videos if you add none. It says wait 2 to 3 weeks before replacing weak assets.
“Wait about 2-3 weeks to check on your Ad strength and Asset group status, then evaluate if you need to replace low-performing assets.”
Google turns on sourced videos by default in Performance Max, adding up to 10 videos per asset group found on social platforms, your landing page or YouTube channel. You can switch it off under Asset optimization.
“Sourced videos are enabled by default for all new campaigns.”
Google will turn on image extraction by default for new Performance Max campaigns from December 4, 2026, even if dynamic images are off for the account. Advertisers who don't want it must opt out per campaign.
“Existing Performance Max campaigns will retain their current configurations”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads training, says start with brand search plus Standard Shopping (under about 30 conversions a month) or feed-only Performance Max, never both on the same products.
“If you’re not sure, start with Standard Shopping. Switching to Performance Max later is easy. Getting the search-term data back once you’ve lost it isn’t.”
River Stone, a Google Ads agency, says feed-only Performance Max still launches without assets and is its ecommerce default, but spend is no longer guaranteed to stay in Shopping, so check channel reports.
“What has changed is that it is no longer guaranteed to spend only on Shopping, so we check where the money went.”
ZenoX, a Shopping agency for dropshippers, starts Performance Max feed-only, warning that adding even one asset shifts 10 to 20% of spend to cheap placements. Above $20K a month, it adds creative for top products.
“The moment you add assets to your asset group - even one headline or one image. It is not feed-only anymore.”
9AM, which sells Shopping management, says feed-only Performance Max serves almost entirely on Shopping and suits big catalogs with steady conversions, often paired with Standard Shopping for segments needing control.
“A common structure in our accounts is feed-only PMax for the bulk of the catalog, plus Standard Shopping campaigns for the segments that need control.”
Dennis Moons of Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, says most stores should run Performance Max feed-only for 2 to 4 weeks to build a Shopping baseline, then add images, then video.
“I recommend most stores start with feed-only. It forces your budget into Shopping, which is almost always your highest-converting channel.”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, says to skip Performance Max under $1K a month, start with one feed-only PMax campaign at $1K to $3K, and aim for 60 to 80% of PMax spend on Shopping.
“For a healthy ecommerce pMax campaign, you want 60 to 80% of spend on Shopping.”
Elevarus, an agency selling this migration work, says Shopping campaigns with 30+ conversions in 30 days can move to Maximize Conversion Value without a target; fewer stay on Maximize Clicks. No data.
“Flag any campaign with 30+ conversions in the last 30 days as a Maximize Conversion Value candidate.”
WP Marketing Robot, which sells a feed plugin, says in accounts it analysed Shopping drove 92% to 98% of Performance Max sales while 15% to 21% of spend went elsewhere, and suggests feed-only campaigns.
“Across the accounts I have analysed, Shopping consistently drives somewhere between 92% and 98% of transactions and revenue.”
smec, which sells Shopping and Performance Max tools, says AI Max text customization is only as good as the feed and PMax spends on low-margin items with easy clicks; test it on one segment first.
“If your feed is messy, your AI-generated copy will be garbage.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer