How should we handle searches for problems our product solves?
Our answer
Bid on problem searches only where the searcher needs the fix now and you sell it, in their own campaign or ad group. Block DIY, how-to and job searches, and leave learning questions to SEO.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 Google rule
- 7 practitioners
- Sources
- 7 sources
- 8 statements
GCPLFSRS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentUrgent problem searches earn their own campaign. Clicksgeek and PushLeads give symptom searches such as AC not cooling their own campaign or ad group and budget, and block how-to, DIY, parts and job searches.
How-to questions rarely pay for a store (Lionel Fenestraz). SEOquick keeps informational queries out of search campaigns, and PushLeads warns that broad match on a repair term can show for searches on doing the repair yourself.
Match type decides which questions you buy. Exact and phrase keywords serve in AI answers only on direct commercial intent, while broad match and AI Max also match broader exploratory questions (Google).
Our judgment
- Sort problem searches by intent and bid only on fix-now ones. Clicksgeek and PushLeads build campaigns around urgent symptom searches while blocking how-to and DIY. Enrich Labs treats problem searches as mid-funnel and research questions as lower bids or content, and Lionel Fenestraz and SEOquick keep informational questions out of paid search.
- Give fix-now problem searches their own campaign or ad group, budget and ads. We apply Clicksgeek's separate emergency campaign and PushLeads' separate budgets and symptom ad groups to any business whose product fixes a problem people search for.
- Keep these keywords on phrase or exact match. Widen matching only through the tests in Turning on AI Max for Search and Match types and negative keywords, because Google's matching rules let broad match and AI Max pull in exploratory questions, and Clicksgeek keeps repair terms on phrase or exact until conversion data can steer broad match.
- We apply fix-now problem campaigns beyond local services, to consumer brands. The idea comes from local service accounts and Enrich Labs' software example, and we apply it to consumer brands whose product fixes a searched problem. Local businesses differ in urgency, so they keep problem campaigns live nights, weekends and holidays and built around calls, as Clicksgeek does.
Our judgment, built from ClicksGeek, PushLeads, Enrich Labs, Lionel Fenestraz, SEOquick and Google: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 7 sourcesGoogle says existing Search, Shopping and Performance Max campaigns can serve in AI Overviews and AI Mode automatically, with no way to target or opt out of them separately, and no extra charge.
“you can't target ads exclusively to AI Overviews or AI Mode, or opt out of showing ads in them separately from Search.”
River Stone, which sells Google Ads management, says one home services client that moved to longer, intent-specific keywords cut cost per lead from $218 to $84 and raised close rate from 14% to 31%.
“Same budget. Same market. Different keyword decisions.”
Enrich Labs, which sells an AI marketing agent, maps keywords to bid postures: problem terms as mid-funnel, research terms like "what is" or "best" with lower bids or content, and junk like free or DIY as negatives.
Enrich Labs, which sells an AI ad agent, says to set a max CPA or target ROAS before keyword research, sort keywords by intent, add negatives from day one and trust search terms over Planner.
“Keyword lists without a money goal become vanity volume.”
ClicksGeek, which sells ads to local service firms, says split HVAC emergency and planned-purchase terms into separate campaigns, build emergency ones around calls, and block DIY and job-seeker terms.
“Emergency terms and planned-purchase terms behave nothing alike, so they need separate campaigns.”
Lionel Fenestraz, who sells Google Ads services, says store Search budgets belong on category and product buying queries, not informational ones, and small stores should focus on a few high-margin products.
“Competing on generic terms against big marketplaces on a small budget usually ends in expensive clicks and too little data.”
SEOquick, which sells SEO and Google Ads services, says separate commercial queries such as buy, price and order from informational ones, which do not belong in a search campaign.
“Keywords collected and grouped by intent; informational queries excluded”
PushLeads, which sells ads to contractors, advises splitting home service campaigns by problem, such as AC not cooling, budgeting emergency work apart from maintenance, and adding negatives like DIY and how to.
“Home service ad copy has one job: convince someone who already knows they have a problem to call your company instead of your competitor.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer