Should we run Standard Shopping campaigns at all now?
Our answer
Keep Standard Shopping for accounts under about 30 conversions a month and for products needing manual bids, cost caps, data collection or Shopping-only spend. Move other products only after an experiment shows a profit gain.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 controlled test
- 7 Google rules, 1 dataset, 8 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 13 sources
- 20 statements
- G
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentGoogle is still building Standard Shopping. It added AI Max for Shopping, value bidding without a ROAS target, Smart Bidding Exploration and High Value Mode. Campaign priority and one-click Target ROAS experiments work only in Shopping campaigns.
Practitioners give Standard Shopping set jobs. Store Growers, 9AM and Lionel Fenestraz start new or small stores mainly on Standard Shopping. River Stone Marketing Solutions keeps it for small budgets that need cost control and for spend that must stay on Shopping.
Stripped-down Standard Shopping led Performance Max on profit on all but six of 42 days, though not significantly, in a test Savvy Revenue designed with Google.
Our judgment
- Keep Standard Shopping for set jobs instead of dropping it. Google is still adding features and controls to it, and every practitioner source here gives it work Performance Max does less well.
- Move a product group to Performance Max only after a Google Ads experiment shows a profit gain. This matches Performance Max alone or alongside. The one test found no significant winner, and Tinuiti's advertisers see similar returns from the two.
- Settle where best sellers and new products go by experiment. Jetfuel Agency and Peak Ace keep top sellers in Standard Shopping while 9AM gives them to Performance Max, and Jetfuel Agency puts new products in Performance Max while 9AM keeps them in Standard Shopping until they convert. Jetfuel Agency and 9AM agree margin-sensitive or low-margin products belong in Standard Shopping.
- Let Standard Shopping campaigns for low-traffic, clearance or new products run below the 30 conversions a month that Splitting Shopping campaigns by margin or price sets for splitting products out. 9AM bids them on manual CPC or Maximize clicks, not on conversions. Elevarus keeps Shopping campaigns below 30 conversions on Maximize clicks because the bidder needs volume to learn.
Our judgment, built from Google, Store Growers, 9AM, River Stone Marketing Solutions, Lionel Fenestraz, Savvy Revenue, Tinuiti, Jetfuel Agency, Peak Ace and Elevarus: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
20 statements from 13 sourcesGoogle says local inventory ads serve by default in Shopping, Performance Max and Demand Gen once a local feed exists. To keep online and store budgets apart, update your inventory filters.
“If a local inventory feed is set up within the Merchant Center account, local inventory ads will serve by default in Shopping , Performance Max and Demand Gen Campaigns.”
Google says when the same product sits in several Shopping campaigns, the highest priority campaign bids even if a lower one bids more, and lower ones bid once its budget runs out.
“We recommend prioritizing only a subset of the products you want to promote, such as items featured in a special sale.”
Google said on October 22, 2026 that High Value Mode for Shopping and customer retention goals for Performance Max, Search and Shopping roll out that month; its help page did not match yet on October 25.
“Customer Retention Goals are rolling out this month for Performance Max, Search and Shopping campaigns”
Google's one-click Target ROAS experiments need a standard Shopping campaign on manual CPC with 15+ conversions in 30 days. Start the target near your past average, then change it, and test for 30 to 60 days.
“Raising your ROAS target will limit Target ROAS to entering auctions that Google believes are more likely to lead to a conversion. This means higher ROAS, but less volume.”
Google suggests a one-click A/B experiment that builds a Performance Max campaign from an existing Standard Shopping campaign, then keeping Performance Max if you like the results.
“Will Performance Max outperform your Standard Shopping campaigns? Run an experiment to be sure.”
Google's Smart Bidding Exploration lowers target ROAS by a tolerance of 5% to 30% so it can bid on high-potential queries; a 200% target at 10% becomes 180%. Campaigns should not be limited by budget.
“Campaigns using Smart Bidding Exploration shouldn't be limited by budget.”
River Stone, a Google Ads agency, leans feed-only Performance Max when the aim is conversions with little setup, but says Standard Shopping fits small budgets that need cost control or Shopping-only spend.
“If the budget is small and you need control over what you pay for, Standard Shopping is the better tool.”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads training, says start with brand search plus Standard Shopping (under about 30 conversions a month) or feed-only Performance Max, never both on the same products.
“If you’re not sure, start with Standard Shopping. Switching to Performance Max later is easy. Getting the search-term data back once you’ve lost it isn’t.”
9AM, an agency, splits a catalog by product role between Performance Max and Standard Shopping; under about 30 Shopping conversions a month it starts near 30/70, often favoring Standard.
“Split the catalog first, and let the budget follow.”
Lionel Fenestraz, a Google Ads consultant, says many stores run Standard Shopping and Performance Max together with different jobs. He suggests starting with brand Search, non-brand Search and Standard Shopping.
“Standard Shopping gives you product-level control, campaign priorities and a detailed search terms report.”
Tinuiti's Q2 2026 benchmark, relayed by Karooya, says Performance Max took 60% of spend among its clients running both PMax and Shopping, down from 67% in Q1, with ROAS similar to standard Shopping.
“PMax also generated 60% of total sales, delivering a ROAS similar to standard Shopping campaigns.”
Edwin Choi of Jetfuel tiers Shopping products into top-20% revenue Superstars, Workhorses and untested Scouts, with custom labels by margin or stock. One consumer food account's ROAS climbed after the split; no figures.
“Top 20% revenue drivers, proven converters”
CTC, an agency, relays Google's claim that AI Max for Shopping averages 5% more conversions at similar cost, and advises filling every feed attribute and testing four weeks against a control.
“Run a four-week test against a control campaign and measure conversion rate and ROAS at the campaign level before expanding.”
Jetfuel, an agency for consumer brands that sells Google Ads management, runs Performance Max alongside Standard Shopping, not instead of it, and says PMax needs 30+ conversions in 30 days.
“No. The hybrid structure is more effective than PMax alone for most accounts.”
PPC Land reports Google set Shopping campaigns to serve Local Inventory Ads by default from August 31, 2026; to keep local offers out, use the Inventory filter or an ONLINE listing scope.
“The change applies only to Shopping campaigns.”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, says to skip Performance Max under $1K a month, start with one feed-only PMax campaign at $1K to $3K, and aim for 60 to 80% of PMax spend on Shopping.
“For a healthy ecommerce pMax campaign, you want 60 to 80% of spend on Shopping.”
Elevarus, an agency selling this migration work, says Shopping campaigns with 30+ conversions in 30 days can move to Maximize Conversion Value without a target; fewer stay on Maximize Clicks. No data.
“Flag any campaign with 30+ conversions in the last 30 days as a Maximize Conversion Value candidate.”
Peak Ace, an agency, relays a rule of thumb: under 30 conversions a month run one Performance Max campaign, 30 to 100 split by category, above 100 split by margin or tier.
“Splitting campaigns too finely starves the algorithm of conversion data. Consolidation almost always wins.”
Savvy Revenue, which sells Standard Shopping management, ran one A/B test where simplified Standard Shopping led Performance Max on profit almost throughout, though not significantly at 95%.
“PMax should not be treated as an automatic, one-size-fits-all upgrade from Standard Shopping.”
Google says Shopping advertisers can upgrade to AI Max in one click and keep their product targeting and bidding controls, while Performance Max remains its pick for cross-channel performance.
“And for cross-channel performance, Performance Max remains your go-to.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer