All answers

The Prevailing
Answers for
Business model:
Business model, pick up to two

Should we turn on Meta's 'Acquire new customers' setting in sales campaigns, and how do we check it brings first-time buyers?

The PrevailingPublished Nov 4, 2026

Our answer

Test Acquire new customers only where first-time buyers are the job. Run it on a duplicate ad set for at least two weeks, expect a higher cost per result, and judge it on first-ever orders counted in your store.

Confidence
Medium
Strongest proof
2 Meta rules
10 practitioners, 6 opinions or claims
Sources
13 sources
18 statements

New here? Take the 1-minute tour

Why this is the answer

3 reasons and our judgment

Expect a worse cost per purchase with Acquire new customers on. Madgicx, a Meta ads automation tool maker, reads Meta's interface as warning that cost per result may increase, and Pixis gives the same warning.

Acquire new customers only works as well as Meta recognizes your buyers. Since October 2026 it excludes buyers from your purchase events automatically, 730 days by default (Jon Loomer). Madgicx, MarketplaceMax and Affect Group all advise checking what it excludes.

New audiences cost more per purchase. In one account example from Pilothouse's check of new-customer prospecting, about 92% of spend reached new audiences, at $72.63 per purchase against $38.44 for engaged audiences. Pilothouse advises checking Meta's split against your store's new-customer data.

Our judgment

  • Test Acquire new customers beside your current setup rather than switching every prospecting ad set. Meta's cost warning and a single agency example leave the gain unproven, and Madgicx, Foxwell Digital, MarketplaceMax, GoodMorning and Affect Group all compare it head to head with the setup you run.
  • A test of at least two weeks is the short end of the spans sources give. MarketplaceMax asks for at least two weeks of conversion data, and Jason Burlin for two to four weeks.
  • First-ever orders counted in your store or CRM are the yardstick for counting new customers. Madgicx says Meta's purchase count is not a count of unique first-time buyers and its breakdown proves no lift. Pilothouse says Meta reports only the customers it can identify, and Connor MacDonald finds some new customers say they already bought.
  • We keep the advice of Common Thread Collective (CTC) to turn Acquire new customers on everywhere as the dissent, not the answer. Its page discloses no dataset. Ben Heath's no-default advice becomes the trigger for running the test.

Our judgment, built from Madgicx, Pixis, Foxwell Digital, MarketplaceMax, GoodMorning, Affect Group, Pilothouse, Jason Burlin, Connor MacDonald, Common Thread Collective and Ben Heath: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.

What the sources say

18 statements from 13 sources
  • MadgicxNov 3, 2026Supports

    Madgicx, which sells Meta ad tools, reads Meta's Acquire new customers setting on screen: Meta warns cost per result may rise. It advises checking which audiences are excluded as existing customers.

    “It is a control to test against a business goal.”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MadgicxNov 3, 2026Supports

    Madgicx, which sells Meta ad tools, says Meta's new-customer breakdown shows the reported mix, not which orders ads caused, so check first-ever orders in your store system and don't count unknown as new.

    “If the report shows unknown, don't silently count that as new business.”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MadgicxNov 3, 2026Supports

    Madgicx, which sells Meta ad tools, says excluding past buyers suits established brands chasing first-time customers but works against replenishment or cross-sell campaigns. Enforce new-customer rules at checkout too.

    “New to this product and new to the business aren't the same thing”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MadgicxNov 3, 2026Supports

    Madgicx says excluding website visitors from Meta's Acquire new customers campaigns can drop likely first-time buyers from the ad set right after their first visit.

    “If you exclude website visitors, you can remove that person from this ad set right after the first visit.”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MadgicxNov 3, 2026Supports

    Madgicx, which sells Meta ad tools, warns against changing the lifecycle setting, offer, creative and budget at once when testing; isolate one variable in a controlled experiment.

    “don't change the lifecycle setting, the offer, the creative, and the budget all at once, then call the result a clean test.”

    Read it on youtube.com

  • Jon LoomerNov 3, 2026Caveat

    Jon Loomer guesses about 5% of advertisers define Meta audience segments, says segment breakdowns only work in Sales campaigns, and suggests Existing Customers could be all purchases in 730 days, not a Meta rule.

    “about 5% of advertisers define their audience segments at all”

    Read it on jonloomer.com

  • Affect GroupOct 29, 2026Supports

    Affect Group, an agency, says Meta's Acquire new customers setting is not an objective and may not exclude every past buyer; test it against manual exclusions and check results with store order data.

    “Audience exclusion is not an incrementality study.”

    Read it on affectgroup.com

  • GoodMorningOct 14, 2026Supports

    GoodMorning, which sells ad reporting tools, says to record new-customer CAC before changing Meta's lifecycle settings, change one ad set at a time, and expect blended ROAS to fall as repeat buyers leave.

    “Without the before number, the after number proves nothing.”

    Read it on goodmorningco.com

  • Jon LoomerOct 13, 2026Caveat

    Jon Loomer says Meta's "Acquire new customers" setting now automatically excludes purchasers in your conversion data from the last 730 days, and this can't be turned off. Offline buyers still need a custom audience.

    “Customers from your conversion data (730 days)”

    Read it on jonloomer.com

  • DTC Newsletter / DTC PodcastOct 13, 2026Supports

    Pilothouse, an agency, shows one prospecting campaign set to acquire new customers putting about 92% of spend ($15,542 of $16,855) on new audiences, at $72.63 per purchase versus $38.44 for engaged audiences.

    “Pilothouse recommends running this check weekly during sale periods, when the audience mix can shift quickly.”

    Read it on directtoconsumer.co

  • Common Thread CollectiveOct 11, 2026Disagrees

    CTC says for Black Friday 2026 to turn on new customers only in every prospecting ad set, after checking pixel and Conversions API coverage and uploading about two years of buyers, with a separate retention campaign.

    “Without lifecycle controls, Meta's optimization engine defaults to finding the easiest conversions.”

    Read it on commonthreadco.com

  • MarketplaceMaxOct 8, 2026Supports

    MarketplaceMax says to test Meta's new-customer setting in a duplicate ad set, audit the exclusion list Meta fills in, and judge it on blended revenue and new customer count, not in-platform ROAS.

    “Then judge the result on blended revenue and new customer count, not on in-platform ROAS.”

    Read it on marketplacemax.com

  • Ben HeathOct 7, 2026Disagrees

    Ben Heath says not to use Meta's 'Acquire new customers' setting by default, only when spend is going disproportionately to existing customers.

    Read it on youtube.com

  • MetaOct 6, 2026Caveat

    Meta's Customer Lifecycle Strategy is now open to all advertisers and lets marketers better dictate the audience for each campaign. No performance numbers were given.

    “enables marketers to better dictate the audience for each campaign”

    Read it on socialmediatoday.com

  • Jason BurlinSep 29, 2026Supports

    Jason Burlin's illustrative model, not data: at $100K a month, $30K goes to existing customers, and if 80% of their purchases would have happened anyway, about 86 are incremental. He recommends a holdout.

    Read it on jasonburlin.com

  • Connor MacDonaldSep 1, 2026Caveat

    Ridge's Connor MacDonald says splitting new from returning customer revenue in incrementality tests is blurrier than people assume, since buyers use different emails; 8-9% of surveyed customers identified as existing.

    “is new customer actually returning. And it's all much blurrier.”

    Read it on podcasters.spotify.com

  • Andrew FoxwellAug 28, 2026Supports

    Foxwell Digital, which sells training, says test Meta's Acquire New Customers option head to head against a manual audience that excludes past buyers, since the winner differs by brand.

    “The answer isn't the same for every brand, which is exactly why this needs to be a real test rather than an assumption.”

    Read it on foxwelldigital.com

  • PixisAug 4, 2026Disagrees

    Pixis, with no data, recommends Meta's Customer Lifecycle Strategy 'acquire new customers only' over manual exclusion lists, warns cost per result may rise, and says to judge on new-customer CAC and ROAS with holdouts.

    “Meta also notes the tradeoff plainly, that choosing new-customers-only can raise your cost per result, since the algorithm is working from a smaller pool.”

    Read it on pixis.ai

In the full answer

For readers who sign in
  • What to do this week3 steps
  • The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
  • Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
  • The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
  • How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer

Read next

More in Audience and customers