What should we pay an agency at our spend level, and how should the fee be structured?
Our answer
The answer depends on spend.
Once Meta spend passes about $75K to $100K a month, pay a flat or tiered retainer. Below that, 10 to 20% of spend is normal. Tie any performance fee to contribution margin or measured incremental results, never Meta-reported ROAS.
At $200K to $1M a month, budget about $15K to $50K a month for a full-service agency. Pay it as a flat or tiered retainer rather than a plain percentage of spend.
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentFour out of five agencies quote a flat retainer or a retainer plus a percentage of spend, in a Foxwell Founders survey of over 200 agencies. Brad Ploch puts ad management alone, with no creative, at about $3,000 to $5,000 a month.
The flat retainer usually wins above $75K to $100K a month, and percentage fees typically run 10 to 20% of monthly spend (Jetfuel Agency, a consumer marketing agency).
A percentage fee pays the agency more as you spend more, profitable or not, and fees on platform-reported ROAS can reward inflated numbers (Common Thread Collective). Performance-only fees can make agencies avoid needed testing (Flighted).
Our judgment
Jetfuel Agency's monthly fee ranges are its annual agency costs divided by 12. Its spend bands and its $75K to $100K line count total monthly ad spend, which we read as Meta spend where Meta is the account the agency runs. We tie any performance fee to contribution margin or measured incremental results, never Meta-reported ROAS. This combines Common Thread Collective's warnings that fees based on platform-reported ROAS can reward inflated numbers and that the metric an agency optimizes for matters more than the pricing model, its advice to ask an agency for measured incremental impact, and Flighted's warning that performance-only fees can make agencies avoid needed testing.
Our judgment, built from Jetfuel Agency, Common Thread Collective and Flighted: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 8 sourcesDrew Fallon dropped Mad Rabbit's Amazon agency, which cost roughly $60K a month, because he could hire two full-time people for two thirds of that. It is one example with no before and after results.
“he could hire two full-time people for two thirds of that”
In Andrew Foxwell's survey of 200+ agencies, four in five quote a flat retainer or retainer plus a percentage of spend. Nobody works on pure performance, and typical fees run $2,500 to $10,000 a month per client.
“four out of five agencies quote either a flat rate retainer or retainer, plus percentage [of spend]”
Brad Ploch of Scalability School says $3,000 to $5,000 a month is becoming the market rate for ad management alone, and $2,500 to $10,000 is the most common price range in the benchmark data.
“the most common price range, is that 2500 to $10,000 range”
Zach Stuck now accepts paying a media buyer a base retainer plus 1% to 5% of spend with a cap, so long as the buyer is responsible for hitting your CPA or ROAS goal. He once thought percentage fees were BS.
“I used to think percentage of spend was kind of BS, and we never ran that at homestead”
Flighted says paid media agencies commonly charge 10-20% of ad spend, with setup fees of $500 to $7,000, and performance-only fees are rare. It does not publish its own rates.
“agencies may avoid necessary testing that temporarily hurts short-term numbers.”
Flighted, an agency, calls contracts longer than three months without exit clauses a red flag. A 90-day first commitment is reasonable, and after that performance should earn the retention.
“Contracts beyond three months without exit clauses are a red flag.”
Jetfuel, an agency, says agencies typically charge 10 to 20 percent of ad spend, falling as spend rises, or flat retainers of $3K to $25K a month; a flat fee usually wins above $75K-$100K a month.
“The flat retainer usually wins above $75K-$100K/month.”
MarketerHire, which sells fractional marketers, puts consumer brand agency retainers at $6K to $25K+ a month, more with 5-15% of spend on top, and calls a 12-month minimum a warning sign. No method given.
“Anyone insisting on a 12-month minimum is selling themselves, not their work.”
MarketerHire, which sells freelance marketers, says a good DTC agency names its people and puts 30/60/90-day success metrics in writing, on a 90-day term then month-to-month. It gives no data.
“Anyone insisting on a 12-month minimum is selling themselves, not their work.”
Flighted, an agency, says the brand should own its ad account, pixel and data and keep full admin access. When moving in-house, budget for 2-3 months of weaker results while the new team ramps up.
“You own your ad account, pixel, and historical data. Full stop.”
Zach Stuck says a revenue-share agency model aligns incentives for high-potential products, claiming it took clients from tens of thousands a month to millions in under six months.
“we took them from tens of thousands a month in revenue to millions a month in like less than six months.”
A Marketing Operators guest says agency fees above $30K to $50K a month tend to draw a client's CFO to cut them, whatever the performance.
“as soon as you get a little too rich, like the CFO comes out and just shuts you down.”
CTC puts agency fees at $5K to $15K a month for $1M to $10M brands and $15K to $50K for $10M to $100M brands, and warns percent-of-spend and ROAS-based fees reward spend over profit.
“the pricing model matters less than what metric the agency optimizes for.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer