How should we handle comments on our ads: hide, delete or reply?
Our answer
Hide spam, scams and abusive comments quickly. Delete only harassment, dangerous links and illegal material. Reply to genuine complaints and criticism rather than hiding them, and never reply to spam.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 controlled tests
- 1 Meta rule, 2 practitioners
- Sources
- 5 sources
- 6 statements
- HB
BMAV
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentModeration lifted results in a field test. On one brand's Trustpilot ad, registrations per click rose from 1.67% to 1.94% once moderation was on (Harvard Business School, with BrandBastion). In lab tests, hiding harmful comments raised purchase intent, while replies to positive comments did not.
Hiding criticism backfired when shoppers could see it had been hidden. Purchase intent was 37.5 with moderation against 45.2 without (BrandBastion's summary of the Harvard study).
Hiding beats replying to spam. Meta keeps a hidden comment visible to its author and their friends, which Meta says helps prevent more unwanted comments. Accounts that reply to spam attract more of it (Jetfuel Agency, a consumer marketing agency).
Our judgment
Reply to genuine criticism rather than hide it. This combines Jetfuel Agency's advice to answer legitimate complaints quickly, the Harvard finding reported by BrandBastion that hiding brand criticism backfires once shoppers can see it, and BrandBastion's advice that constructive complaints stay visible. Hide rather than delete ordinary spam and abuse, because of how Meta treats a hidden comment. Jetfuel Agency deletes only content with genuine brand or legal risk, such as harassment, dangerous links and illegal material.
Our judgment, built from Jetfuel Agency, Harvard Business School, BrandBastion and Meta: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
6 statements from 5 sourcesMeta's help page says a hidden Page comment stays visible to its author and their friends but is hidden from everyone else, while a deleted comment is removed from the post.
“will still be visible to the person who wrote it and their friends.”
Antonio Ventre says replying to every comment on your ads draws more comments, which raises Meta's ad quality score and lowers CPMs. He gives no measurement.
BrandBastion, which sells moderation and ran the study with Harvard Business School, reports that adding moderation to one brand's ad lifted registrations per click from 1.67% to 1.94%. Not independent of the study.
“Study 4A shows a clean reversal: purchase intent was 37.5 with moderation on, and 45.2 with moderation off, once participants could see that criticism of the brand had been hidden.”
Harvard Business School researchers found hiding harmful ad comments helped. In a month-long matched test of one brand, the moderated arm had ROAS of 0.678 versus 0.459 and cost per purchase of $454 versus $667.
“Despite the increasing prevalence of AI-powered comment moderation solutions, little causal evidence exists on whether moderation (i.e., hiding harmful comments) improves ad effectiveness.”
In a Harvard Business School field test for one brand, hiding negative comments barely changed delivery: about $10K a side gave 545,627 impressions without moderation and 529,774 with it.
“The similar levels of impressions and reach across conditions suggest that algorithmic delivery was not meaningfully affected by the comment management intervention”
JetFuel says hiding spam comments has no negative effect on delivery and disabling comments can push CPMs up, with no measurement or Meta source. It says moderation tooling pays off above about $20K a month.
“no negative impact on ad delivery, reach, or CPM”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer