Should we require account creation, offer it, or skip it?
Our answer
Don't require an account before payment unless it is part of what you sell, like B2B ordering or a subscription customers manage. Keep guest checkout first, show a sign-in link for returning buyers and invite an account after the order.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 3 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 5 sources
- 10 statements
BIGCLE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentForced accounts lose orders. In Baymard Institute's survey, 19% of US adults abandoned an order rather than create an account, and Baymard advises deferring registration until after the order is confirmed.
Firms that work on checkouts agree that guest checkout should come first. Glued (Shopify CRO agency), Carty Labs (Shopify cart app maker) and EcomHint (store audit tool maker) all recommend guest checkout with the account offered after purchase.
On Shopify, requiring sign-in hides wallet buttons in the cart. Buyers sign in with an email code (Shopify).
Our judgment
You don't have to choose between guest checkout and accounts. Keep guest checkout and offer the account after the order, since Baymard, Glued, Carty Labs and EcomHint point the same way and Shopify's customer accounts already form around the order. Require sign-in only where the account is part of the service, the cases EcomHint and Carty Labs both name (B2B ordering and subscriptions). Treat their other exceptions as unproven, since neither shows data. Test any change to account settings against the current setup before switching it on, using Shopify's Rollouts, which can A/B test customer account configurations.
Our judgment, built from Baymard Institute, Glued, Cartylabs, EcomHint and Shopify: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
10 statements from 5 sourcesShopify says customer accounts let shoppers view orders, make self-serve returns and reorder. Sign-in sessions last up to 365 days, and details auto-fill at checkout.
“Sign-in sessions persist for up to 365 days”
Shopify lets merchants set some checkout fields as required, optional or hidden. Requiring sign-in hides Apple Pay and other accelerated checkout options in the cart.
“accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay aren't displayed in the online store cart to prevent any checkouts from bypassing the sign-in requirement”
EcomHint, which sells store audits, says guest checkout with an optional account after purchase suits most stores; require accounts only for B2B, subscriptions or support. Shopify's default is guest checkout.
“For most ecommerce stores, guest checkout with optional post-purchase account creation is the optimal approach.”
Baymard's research finds shoppers see account sign-in as a hurdle and that passwords are giving way to biometrics and one-time passcodes. Order tracking ranks among the most valued account features.
“During recent testing, 81% of participants reported saving credit card details in their account at sites they shop at frequently”
Shopify's blog says its customer accounts are built around guest checkout, with the account created from the email after purchase. It relays Baymard: 19% of shoppers abandon rather than create an account.
“The account forms around the completed order instead of blocking it.”
Glued, a checkout agency, says forcing account creation cuts checkout completion 20 to 35% for new visitors across its clients, and puts guest checkout first. No dataset published.
“Make guest checkout the first and most prominent option.”
Cartylabs, a checkout app seller, says dropping forced signup lifts checkout completion 4 to 9 points in stores it audited, and a post-purchase ask turns 30 to 50% of guests into accounts. No data shown.
“Forcing the rest into account creation does not turn them into repeat buyers; it loses them at checkout and produces zero additional repeats.”
Shopify's Rollouts, under Markets > Rollouts in the admin, can schedule, gradually publish and A/B test themes, checkout and customer account setups, including two entirely different themes.
“between two entirely different themes or checkout setups to find the winner”
Baymard puts average cart abandonment at 70.22%. Of US shoppers who left, 39% cited unexpected extra costs and 19% forced account creation, so it recommends guest checkout as the default.
“Prioritize guest checkout as the default path, deferring registration until after the order is confirmed.”
Shopify says legacy customer accounts are closed to new stores and get no more feature updates or support, with a final sunset date to be announced later in 2026. It recommends upgrading to the latest accounts.
“Shopify will stop providing feature updates and technical support for this older version.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer