How should we cut fraud and chargebacks without blocking good orders?
Our answer
Act on your platform's fraud recommendation rather than single warning signs, and verify or cancel high-risk orders before they ship. Check what your rules turn away, and keep your 90-day chargeback rate below 1%.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 8 official rules
- 1 dataset, 2 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 14 statements
VRCSSDCCI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentShipping risky orders has a real cost. Shopify warns that fulfilling high-risk orders raises chargebacks and can cost you Shopify Payments. It also says one indicator does not show an order's risk level.
Turning away good orders costs money too. The average false decline rate is 1.51% of sales (Datos Insights, reported by Signifyd). Signifyd (fraud screening software maker) found 27% of loyal customers turned away never return. A cancelled order is not a proven saved chargeback (Chargeflow).
The chargeback rate thresholds for penalties are close together. Shopify can put stores at a 90-day rate of 1.5% or more into automatic refunds with a 10% reserve. Visa cut its merchant threshold to 1.5% on April 1, 2026.
Our judgment
- Act on the platform's overall recommendation and verify rather than cancel orders whose recommendation falls between fulfill and cancel. Shopify says single indicators don't show an order's risk, and ShieldLabs and Signifyd say single signals such as an address mismatch or a VPN often belong to real customers.
- Check a sample of declined and cancelled orders before adding blocking rules. That applies Signifyd's advice to review declines (its example is everything over $500) and Chargeflow's advice to count good orders lost beside chargebacks.
- Keep the 90-day chargeback rate on Shopify Payments below 1% and check it at least monthly. That is the line Shopify uses for leaving its dispute program and for further action after a reserve, and Redo also names it as Shopify's threshold. Visa's 1.5% level applies only once a store logs 1,500 fraud reports and disputes in a month, so below that count Shopify's line is the one that binds. Shopify says Visa and Mastercard evaluate activity monthly, and Redo works out a monthly Visa figure beside Shopify's 90-day rate.
- Treat disputes that are not stolen cards as part of the same work. Shopify gives separate fixes for unrecognized charges, missing deliveries, unacceptable products, unprocessed credits and canceled subscriptions. Chargeflow says screening before shipping cannot stop disputes caused by poor service, unclear descriptors or a refund never processed.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, ShieldLabs, Signifyd, Chargeflow, Redo and Visa: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 8 sourcesShopify says fulfilling high-risk orders can bring chargebacks and loss of Shopify Payments. Judge by the overall fraud recommendation, not single indicators, and use manual capture to buy time.
“Review the fraud recommendation instead of deciding whether to fulfill an order from one indicator or the number of indicators.”
Shopify's fraud guide covers Shopify Protect, 3DS, address checks and card testing, and warns that every chargeback counts toward your rate whether you win or lose the dispute.
“Each chargeback counts toward your chargeback rate regardless of whether you win or lose the dispute.”
Shopify says to check suspicious orders before shipping, show your store name on card statements, and for US, UK or Canada orders consider shipping only those that pass an AVS check.
“You should use your store's name or domain name, so that the customer can recognize it on their credit card bill.”
Shopify says a chargeback takes the disputed amount plus a fee at once, merchants usually get 7 to 21 days to respond, and a won dispute still counts toward the rate that governs account standing.
“Winning a dispute doesn't remove it from your chargeback rate.”
Shopify can auto-enroll stores with a 90-day chargeback rate of 1.5% or more in a program that refunds disputes without contest and holds a 10% payout reserve. Exit needs under 1.00% for 30 days.
“Merchants with an NDRP-inclusive chargeback rate of 1.5% or higher over the last 90 days can be automatically enrolled in an NDRP.”
Shopify summarizes card network limits: outside CEMEA, Visa flags 1,500 disputes plus fraud reports and a 1.5% ratio; Mastercard starts at 100 disputes and 1.5%. Monthly fines can follow.
“If disputes or fraud exceed card network thresholds, then you might be placed in a monitoring program and incur monthly fines or additional fees.”
Visa's monitoring program flags merchants whose fraud plus disputes reach 220 basis points (2.2%) of settled transactions with 1,500 or more a month, lowered to 150 basis points in several regions from April 2026.
“Excessive Merchant threshold reduced to >=150bps in AP, Canada, EU, and U.S. regions on 1 April 2026.”
Chargeflow, which sells chargeback software, says pre-shipment fraud rules should weigh evidence and order economics, and warns that a cancelled order is not a confirmed saved chargeback.
“A low-margin $40 order and a scarce $2,000 item should not share the same intervention rule.”
Chargeback.io, which sells chargeback tools, says Shopify Payments is the best default gateway for most stores, adding no third-party fee; high-risk, EU-first or global stores may add or switch gateways.
“Shopify Payments is the best default gateway for most stores. It adds no third-party fee on top of card processing.”
Redo, which sells chargeback tools, says Shopify's line is a 1.00% dispute rate over 90 days, but clearing it does not make a store safe with Visa, and refund filters can hide a rising rate.
“Shopify's 1.00% is Shopify's line. It is not a card network line, and clearing it is not the same as being safe with Visa or with your acquirer.”
Signifyd, which sells fraud screening, relays a 1.51% average false decline rate and says loyal customers falsely declined then place 65% fewer orders, and 27% never return. Sample not stated.
“every notch tighter swaps a fraud loss you can see for a false decline you can’t, and the false decline usually costs more.”
ShieldLabs, which sells fraud detection, says the most common promo abuse is one shopper making new accounts to keep claiming a first-order discount, which code rules and IP blocks miss.
“No single row is proof. A real customer can shop over a VPN, and two people in one household can share a network and a delivery address.”
A survey by Chargebacks911, which sells chargeback services, found 74.4% of retailers call friendly fraud a significant concern and 26.7% use AI fraud tools. Sample size not given.
“In its 2026 Chargeback Field Report, it found that 74.4% of retailers describe friendly fraud as a significant concern.”
Since January 28, 2026, Shopify's chargeback rate counts all disputes, including those resolved through Visa's Rapid Dispute Resolution. A filter shows the old view, and risk evaluation is unchanged.
“The updated chargeback rate metric now includes all disputes, including those resolved through programs like Visa's Rapid Dispute Resolution (RDR).”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer