Should we collect phone numbers at checkout, and how should we ask?
Our answer
Show an optional phone field at checkout, and ask for text marketing with a separate unticked SMS box. Require the phone only where delivery, payment or reseller checks need it.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 11 official rules
- 2 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 8 sources
- 14 statements
KPDCDAGEGT
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAn optional phone field is Shopify's default. Shopify makes the shipping phone optional on new stores and recommends email as the only contact method. Postscript (SMS marketing platform) says the phone can be required, but SMS opt-in should always stay optional.
A phone number is not permission to text. Klaviyo requires separate consent for SMS, and Shopify's SMS checkbox can't be preselected.
A required phone field costs more than it gains for most products. Dash Checkout (Shopify app maker) argues the friction isn't worth it, except for limited drops with reseller abuse.
Our judgment
Keep the phone field optional by default and require it only where an order needs it, which joins Shopify's default, Postscript's setup and Dash Checkout's view with Digital Applied (marketing agency) and Growth Engines (conversion optimization agency) keeping the field for delivery updates. Ask for text marketing only through the separate unticked SMS box, and never treat a delivery number as consent to text, going by Shopify's SMS box that can't be preselected and Klaviyo's rule that a number given is not SMS permission. Send collected phone numbers with email to ad platforms' customer matching where your privacy settings allow, going by Google's Customer Match advice to upload phone numbers alongside email and TikTok's matching on email and phone.
Our judgment, built from Shopify, Postscript, Dash Checkout, Digital Applied, Growth Engines, Klaviyo, Google and TikTok: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
14 statements from 8 sourcesShopify checkout cannot require both email and phone as the contact method. To require a phone too, make the shipping address phone field required, which applies only when checkout has a shipping step.
“There's no option to require both an email address and a phone number as the contact method.”
Shopify lets stores preselect email consent at checkout by region, which makes customers opt out by hand, but says its region picks are not legal advice; SMS consent can never be preselected.
“the SMS marketing opt-in checkbox can't be preselected at checkout.”
Shopify local delivery covers up to 100 miles and 10 zones per location, works with Shop Pay but not Apple Pay or PayPal, and cannot mix shipped and delivered items on one order.
“Local delivery works with Shop Pay, but doesn't work with other accelerated checkouts such as Apple Pay, Google Pay, Amazon Pay, or PayPal.”
Shopify lets merchants set some checkout fields as required, optional or hidden. Requiring sign-in hides Apple Pay and other accelerated checkout options in the cart.
“accelerated checkout options such as Apple Pay aren't displayed in the online store cart to prevent any checkouts from bypassing the sign-in requirement”
Google says most advertisers' Customer Match rates are between 29% and 62%, and advises uploading every data type per customer and refreshing lists weekly by hand or daily by API.
“Most advertisers' match rates are between 29% and 62%.”
Klaviyo says SMS consent must be collected separately from email, can't come from bought lists or be required to make a purchase, and US carriers require double opt-in for cart abandonment flows.
“Having consent for email does not mean you have consent for SMS.”
Klaviyo can collect SMS consent on Shopify thank you and order status pages (checkout too on Shopify Plus); consent syncs even if the order isn't completed, and it strongly recommends double opt-in.
“The customer does not need to complete their order to have their consent synced to Klaviyo.”
Growth Engines, a conversion agency, says keep a phone number at checkout only for shipping notifications, and remove or make optional a separate billing phone, company name and the second address line.
“phone number (for shipping notifications only)”
Shopify now offers eligible stores recommended checkout field settings, such as email-only contact and required names. New stores use them by default; existing settings change only if applied.
“Existing store settings won’t change unless you apply the recommendations.”
Dash Checkout, which sells an order limits app, says every extra required checkout field costs conversions, so requiring a phone number isn't worth it for most products, only high-value drops with reseller abuse.
“Every additional required field costs conversions.”
Digital Applied, a conversion agency, says to cut every checkout field not needed to process and deliver the order, keep phone when carriers need it, and mark optional fields rather than required ones.
“Audit every field in your checkout form with a single question: is this field required to process and deliver the order?”
Postscript says to collect SMS subscribers at Shopify checkout, set the shipping phone field to optional so the opt-in box shows, and keep SMS opt-in optional even if the phone is required.
“While you can require the phone number, SMS opt-in should always remain optional.”
Postscript explains how to collect SMS subscribers at Shopify's one-page checkout by making email the contact method and turning on SMS under marketing options; collection happens after the order.
“Postscript will collect SMS subscribers via Shopify Checkout after the order is placed.”
TikTok recommends using manual and automatic Advanced Matching together to match hashed emails and phone numbers to site actions, but manual only in regulated fields like finance or healthcare.
“We recommend using both Manual and Automatic Advanced Matching at the same time to get better results.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it1 figure from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer