Should we use value rules to bid more for certain locations, devices or audiences?
Our answer
Use value rules only when your own sales data shows a location, device or audience is worth a different amount per conversion, and only on value bidding. Size each multiplier from that data and restate Target ROAS.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 7 Google rules
- 5 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 15 statements
- G
IIANCMA
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA segment that simply converts better is already counted. Smart Bidding already uses location, device and audience lists (Google). A rule adds value information the account lacks.
Agencies check your own data first. Igor Ivitskiy, a Google Ads consultant, Admoon and Relevant Audience each look at CRM close rates, job size or margin before writing a rule. Ivitskiy says audits often find rules where the CRM shows no difference.
Only value bidding acts on adjusted values (Google). PPC Rebels sizes each multiplier as the segment average over the overall average, rounded down, and skips rules between 0.9 and 1.1.
Our judgment
- Treat a rule as a statement of value you can show outside Google Ads. A higher conversion rate is not enough, since bidding already accounts for segments that convert better in reporting. Relevant Audience, Igor Ivitskiy and Admoon each ask for CRM or margin data first. North Country Growth's and MB Adv Agency's view of rules as a core lever does not change this, since both fit a rule backed by outside value data.
- Choose whether your rules use location, device or audience before writing the first rule. Use them alone or as a primary and secondary pair, where your outside data shows the largest value gap. Google requires every rule to use the same condition types, and changing them means deleting all rules.
- Size each multiplier as the segment's average value over the overall average, rounded down, and skip gaps between 0.9 and 1.1, as PPC Rebels does. Admoon also starts with conservative multipliers, and Relevant Audience and Igor Ivitskiy want the size backed by data outside Google Ads.
- Restate Target ROAS by the rule's effect on average value when the rule goes live. That keeps the target's meaning, so it asks for the same return on the new values. We follow WeltPixel's same-day restatement and North Country Growth's proportional target over PPC Rebels' advice never to change value and target on the same day. Make any further target change in a later conversion cycle, since Google advises against several target changes within one cycle.
- On Target CPA, use a device bid adjustment for a device difference your data shows. Rules change only reported values there. Google says a device adjustment moves the target (+40% turns a $10 target into $14) and ignores other adjustments.
Our judgment, built from Google, Relevant Audience, Igor Ivitskiy, Admoon, WeltPixel, North Country Growth, PPC Rebels and MB Adv Agency: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 9 sourcesGoogle says conversion value rules adjust values by audience, device or location for value-based bidding, with multipliers from 0.5 to 10. Only one rule applies to each conversion.
“You can set a maximum of 2 conditions per rule.”
Google says conversion value rules adjust reported values across all campaigns, but only value-based bidding such as Target ROAS or Maximize conversion value optimizes to the new values.
“The same adjusted value that is determined at bidding time will be used for reporting.”
Google says conversion value rules adjust value by location, device or audience at auction time for Smart Bidding, but Smart Bidding already uses those signals when the difference shows in reporting.
“If a user in one of those segments converts better, and this is reflected in your reporting, Smart Bidding already accounts for that.”
Google says Smart Bidding uses active conversion value rules at auction time, and campaign-level rules do not affect other campaigns except within portfolio bid strategies.
“Conversion value rules created at the campaign level will not affect bidding performance or reported conversions for other campaigns”
Google says budget or target changes take effect at the next auction without triggering learning, but advises against several target changes in one conversion cycle and judging over 2 cycles or 2 weeks.
“Avoid making multiple target changes within a single conversion cycle unless there is a clear business need.”
Google says Target ROAS bidding ignores existing bid adjustments, with one exception: you can still set a device bid adjustment of -100%. You do not need to remove the others; they just go unused.
“There is one exception: You can still set device bid adjustments of -100%.”
Google says a Target CPA bid adjustment changes the CPA target itself, not the bid: +40% for mobile turns a $10 target into $14 on mobile. Non-device bid adjustments are ignored on Search and Display.
“If your Target CPA is $10 USD, setting a bid adjustment of +40% for mobile will increase your Target CPA to $14 USD on mobile devices.”
Igor Ivitskiy, a Google Ads consultant, says use conversion value rules only if your CRM shows lead groups paying at different rates, and only with value-based bidding. His multipliers are made up.
“If they do not, you do not need a rule.”
Relevant Audience, a Google Ads agency, says use conversion value rules only when outside data backs the adjustment and base values are right, since rules change reported ROAS and can double count.
“If the difference between mobile and desktop value is already visible in the values your tag sends, a rule double counts it.”
WeltPixel, which sells tracking apps, says when Shopify values include VAT, add one Google Ads value rule per VAT rate, such as 0.826 at 21%, and restate Target ROAS that day, so 400% becomes about 331%.
“Without it, the rule shows up as a spend drop nobody connects to a settings change.”
PPC Rebels, a Google Ads agency, says size value rules from 6 to 12 months of CRM deals, round multipliers down, skip ones between 0.9 and 1.1, and revisit quarterly. Its stacking claim conflicts with Google.
“Round down. If the maths says 1.53, use 1.4. Erring conservatively is cheaper.”
Admoon, a Google Ads agency, says to start value rules with conservative multipliers backed by CRM data, review them at least quarterly, and not treat higher reported ROAS as proof of more revenue.
“A higher reported ROAS does not necessarily prove that revenue increased.”
Jeremy Young, whose agency sells profit tracking, says sending profit per order to Google Ads as conversion value beats value rules. One unnamed client went from break-even to its best week, no figures given.
“the first one is sort of the lowest value one”
North Country Growth, a Google Ads seller, says location value rules suit multi-market advertisers, device rules rarely help e-commerce, and campaigns under 30 to 50 conversions a month lack data for them.
“Start with one or two high-impact rules and add complexity only when you have data to justify it.”
MB Adv Agency, which sells ad management, says time spent on device and location bid adjustments under Smart Bidding is wasted. It says audits, value rules and seasonality adjustments pay off. It gives no data.
“adjusting bids the algorithm ignores does not”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer