When should we use manual CPC or bid caps instead of fully automated bidding?
Our answer
Use automated bidding by default. Keep Manual CPC or capped Maximize clicks only while a campaign has under about 30 conversions a month or untrusted tracking. Treat Smart Bidding bid caps as loose, temporary guardrails.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 11 Google rules
- 6 practitioners, 10 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 27 statements
- GTP
MS
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBelow about 30 conversions a month, agencies start with manual or click bidding, not conversion bidding. Media Spearhead and Jetfuel Agency use Manual CPC or Maximize clicks, Store Growers Manual CPC or Maximize conversions. Kick Ads keeps manual bidding for tiny budgets or unbuilt tracking.
Caps on Smart Bidding hold it back. Google advises against Target CPA bid limits, allows bid limits only through portfolios and flags a portfolio as Limited when caps hold back spend. Store Growers, a Google Ads course seller, treats caps as training wheels.
Enhanced CPC is gone. Google retired it for Search and Display in March 2025, so campaigns never moved off it now run on plain Manual CPC.
Our judgment
- Treat about 30 conversions a month as the point to leave Manual CPC or capped Maximize clicks. Store Growers, Media Spearhead, Jetfuel Agency and Elevarus all switch near 30, which matches the launch path in Launching a new Google Ads account. Linear Design's warning against a fixed rule makes the number a guide, not a line.
- When you need click bidding, prefer Maximize clicks with a maximum CPC bid limit over Manual CPC. Use Manual CPC only when you need bids set by keyword. Google and Media Spearhead offer it as the same data gathering step with less upkeep, and Kick Ads and Linear Design say Manual CPC takes heavy labour and gets hard to run as accounts grow.
- Keep bid caps on Smart Bidding loose and temporary. Remove them when the strategy shows it is limited by bid limits. Google advises against Target CPA limits and warns limits set too low keep a strategy from its goal.
- Google's product managers calling Manual CPC a costly habit doesn't change the answer for campaigns with thin or untrusted data. Google's own setup pages still suggest Maximize clicks for limited data. A cap is the only hard ceiling a small budget has, as PPC Land reports buyers saying. Once conversions are steady, the answer already moves to conversion bidding.
- The same answer applies to local and lead businesses. Media Spearhead writes for local service businesses and gives the same switch near 30 conversions.
Our judgment, built from Store Growers, Media Spearhead, Jetfuel Agency, Elevarus, Linear Design, Google, Kick Ads and PPC Land: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
27 statements from 12 sourcesChris Shaver says switching lead gen from manual CPC to Target CPA can make Google bid for lower positions to cut acquisition cost, which lowered lead quality in his example.
“That lowering of positions of their ads brought down the lead quality.”
Boris Beceric, a consultant, shows in an illustrative scenario that a low-volume campaign can take five months to reach 30 conversions and still get only nine a month.
“In Scenario C, even after five months, you're still only generating nine conversions per month.”
Google says Manual CPC sets the most you'll pay per click and you often pay less, but the same page promotes automated bidding and gives no point at which to leave manual bidding.
“Keep in mind that Internet traffic is always changing, so it's advised to re-evaluate your CPC bids regularly.”
Google says Maximize clicks can take a maximum CPC cap to control costs, with bid adjustments applied on top, but caps set too low can miss the goal. Demand Gen does not support the cap.
“Note that if your CPC bid limits are too low, your bid strategy might not be able to help you achieve your goal.”
Google retired Enhanced CPC for Search and Display the week of March 31, 2025; campaigns not moved to another strategy now run on Manual CPC.
“Campaigns that were not proactively migrated to another bid strategy prior to deprecation are now effectively using Manual CPC.”
Google says Maximize Clicks can suit new campaigns without enough conversion data for Target CPA or ROAS, and Maximize Conversions suits spending the full budget with no set CPA. It doesn't say how much data is enough.
“can be useful for new campaigns that lack sufficient conversion data for strategies like Target CPA or Target ROAS, or if the primary goal is website traffic rather than direct conversions.”
Google says portfolio bid strategies can group several campaigns under one Smart Bidding or automated strategy, but are not available for Performance Max campaigns.
“Portfolio bid strategies are not available for Performance Max campaigns.”
Google says Target impression share bidding can suit brand campaigns, and warns that setting the max CPC limit too low can stop you reaching your impression share goal.
“Target impression share can be useful for campaigns with brand terms.”
Google suggests starting new Search campaigns, or those with little conversion data, on Maximize Clicks, moving to Maximize Conversions or Target CPA once enough data builds. Learning typically lasts 5-7 days.
“For new campaigns or those with limited conversion data, consider starting with a "Maximize Clicks" bidding strategy to gather performance data.”
Google's one-click Target ROAS experiments need a standard Shopping campaign on manual CPC with 15+ conversions in 30 days. Start the target near your past average, then change it, and test for 30 to 60 days.
“Raising your ROAS target will limit Target ROAS to entering auctions that Google believes are more likely to lead to a conversion. This means higher ROAS, but less volume.”
Google advises against bid limits on Target CPA, since they restrict its optimization. Limits exist only on portfolio strategies and apply only in Search Network auctions.
“Setting bid limits for your Target CPA bid strategy isn’t recommended, because it can restrict Google Ads’ automatic optimization of your bid.”
Google says Target ROAS portfolio strategies aren't available for Performance Max, Hotel or Travel campaigns, and a portfolio may perform better when you don't need ad group targets.
“if you don’t need to set targets for individual ad groups, a portfolio strategy may be able to offer better performance.”
Google says Target CPA can start with no conversion history, recommends a target equal to the last 30 days' average CPA, and warns that a target set too low can cost you conversions.
“For evaluation, we recommend you measure performance for the last 30 days, including at least 30 conversions.”
Surfside PPC suggests setting the max bid limit in a Google portfolio bid strategy at about half your target CPA.
“My general rule of thumb is take like half of your target CPA.”
A Google product manager says new campaigns should go straight to conversion-based bidding such as Max Conversions rather than starting on Max Clicks. Google's help pages still suggest Max Clicks.
“I would generally start in the Max conversion, Max conversion strategy, Max conversion strategy”
PPC Land explains Google portfolio bidding pools data and judges campaigns by one average: cheap brand sales let pricier generic ones fit a 50 euro target, but the average can hide the mix.
Linear Design, a PPC agency, says manual CPC suits small, closely managed campaigns, there is no universal conversion count for switching, and a starting bid should sit below conversion rate times allowable cost.
“There is no sound universal rule that says “switch at 30” or “switch at 50” conversions.”
PPC Land explains max CPC caps a click, not results, and adjustments can exceed it. It reports Google's view that starting on manual bids is costly, which small-budget buyers dispute.
“A max CPC caps a click, not an outcome.”
Scott Carruthers says a campaign switched from manual CPC to smart bidding and left unwatched spent a client's whole daily budget of over £10,000 in under an hour.
“spent an entire client's entire daily budget of over £10,000”
Chris Shaver says if you want real control over your CPCs, you have to give up conversion-based automated bidding and use manual bidding.
“If you really want to control your bids, you have to first put a lid on conversion optimization”
Jetfuel, an agency, picks Google bidding by monthly account conversions: Maximize Clicks under 30, Maximize Conversions at 30 to 80, Target ROAS from 80. It starts Target ROAS at 80% of actual ROAS.
“set your Target ROAS at 80% of your current actual ROAS when first switching to smart bidding. Give it two to three weeks to stabilize.”
Kick Ads, an ads agency, says manual CPC is now mainly for tiny budgets or accounts without conversion tracking, and target impression share is best for brand defence. No data.
“Manual bidding is now mainly for thin-data or high-control edge cases.”
Store Growers, which sells Google Ads courses, recommends Target ROAS for stores with 30+ conversions a month, and Maximize Conversions or Manual CPC below that to build baseline data.
“Use them as training wheels, not as a permanent setting”
Elevarus, an agency selling this migration work, says Shopping campaigns with 30+ conversions in 30 days can move to Maximize Conversion Value without a target; fewer stay on Maximize Clicks. No data.
“Flag any campaign with 30+ conversions in the last 30 days as a Maximize Conversion Value candidate.”
Media Spearhead, an agency for local businesses, says to start new campaigns on manual CPC or capped Maximize Clicks, then move to automated bidding after 30+ conversions in 30 days.
“Automated bidding can blow through a small budget quickly on expensive clicks.”
Chris Shaver says manual bidding beats Max Conversions in the short run, every time.
“manual bidding outperforms Max conversions, at least in the short run every time.”
Chris Shaver says only manual CPC bidding can reliably push chosen keywords to the top paid position every time.
“Only manual bids can accurately push specific keywords to the top of Google and show every single time in first paid position period.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer