How should we use AI to write emails, and what are the risks?
Our answer
Use AI to draft emails and test subject lines. Have a person check every price, offer, date and link before sending. Never let AI write testimonials, and disclose AI where it shaped what readers see.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 3 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 8 statements
- K
SUFL
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAI drafts still need a human check. Klaviyo's Composer never sends without your approval, and Klaviyo warns that generated content can occasionally be wrong. So check prices, product names, dates and links before anything goes out.
AI subject lines can win on clicks when the AI knows your audience. Across more than 80 client brands, sendXmail (email marketing agency) saw them win by 12 to 19%. At the sale that gap narrowed to about 1 to 2 points.
Made-up claims carry legal risk. Klaviyo's guidance says the FTC treats AI-made marketing under its deception rules and rates AI-written testimonials as the highest risk.
Our judgment
The rule that a person edits and approves every send, checking each price, discount, date, link and audience, is ours. Klaviyo builds Composer that way and holds the sender responsible, and Webtopia (ad agency) describes AI agents acting with human approval. Judging AI options on clicks or orders across several sends rather than on opens, with past sends and audience data fed to the AI, follows sendXmail's test method and results and Klaviyo's advice to A/B test a couple of generated versions. Keeping reviews real and disclosing AI where it meaningfully shaped what readers see combines the US Federal Trade Commission (FTC) rule on fake reviews with Klaviyo's disclosure guidance.
Our judgment, built from Klaviyo, Webtopia, sendXmail and US Federal Trade Commission: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
8 statements from 6 sourcesKlaviyo says its Composer AI agent drafts campaigns and segments, but users must check prices, links and audiences, add any legal disclosures, and expect weaker results on new accounts.
“Composer drafts and QAs the content, but you stay in control: you review, edit, and approve everything before it goes live.”
A podcast guest, the founder of Home Plunge, says he replaced all his Google, Meta and Klaviyo agencies with AI systems. He also plugs his own web app that packages those systems.
“I've relinquished myself from every agency from Google, to meta, to Clavio, all of it and I've replaced it with AI systems.”
sendXmail, which sells copy testing, says across 80+ brands AI subject lines beat human ones on clicks by 12 to 19% given audience data, but the gap shrank to about 1 to 2 points by paying customers.
“Pick click-through rate as your success metric from the start, not open rate.”
Litmus, which sells email tools, says inbox AI now sorts and summarizes mail in Gmail, Apple and Yahoo, so put the offer up front, use clean formatting, and set Gmail annotations yourself.
“Use clean, structured formatting so AI summarizes your email accurately.”
Webtopia, an agency with a sister retention agency, says AI lets three people do retention work that took three to five at a $10M brand, cutting flow audits to half an hour. No data.
“Flow audits drop from a three day strategist project to a half hour AI grounded review.”
Klaviyo says its Composer AI agent, now in public beta, builds complete email and text campaigns, audience and content, ready to review in minutes, and nothing goes live without approval.
“the campaign is ready to review and launch in minutes, and nothing goes live without approval.”
Klaviyo's reading, not legal advice, says the FTC may require disclosing AI-made marketing that could mislead, with AI testimonials riskiest. Its EU claim is broader than the AI Act's actual rule.
“AI-generated testimonials and endorsements carry the highest risk.”
The FTC's review rule, in force since October 2024, bans writing, creating or selling reviews or testimonials that misrepresent that the reviewer exists, used the product, or what their experience was.
“for a business to write, create, or sell a consumer review, consumer testimonial, or celebrity testimonial that materially misrepresents”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it2 figures from cited sources
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer