Should we use Demand Gen to retarget site visitors, and how does it compare with Meta retargeting?
Our answer
Add a small Demand Gen remarketing campaign only after Search and Shopping pay off and lists pass 100 active users, with optimized targeting off and buyers excluded, judged by holdout. On Meta, let broad campaigns reach past visitors.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 6 Google rules
- 2 datasets, 5 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 9 sources
- 15 statements
- G
TMTPWM
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentDemand Gen drifts off your remarketing lists unless you turn optimized targeting off. Google turns optimized targeting on by default and says it may stop serving your chosen segments. A remarketing ad group stays on your lists only with it off.
Google and Meta retargeting work differently. Tsvi Machluf, The Paid Search Podcast and Jetfuel Agency run Google remarketing as its own layer. On Meta, broad campaigns already spend about 20 to 25% on people who know you (Jon Loomer).
Retargeting claims more than it delivers. In one Measured holdout, remarketing kept about 39% of its claimed conversions against about 93% for prospecting. Demand Gen remarketing needs a holdout too.
Our judgment
- Build Demand Gen remarketing only after Search and Shopping pay off. Tsvi Machluf advises fixing Shopping before adding Demand Gen, and Jetfuel Agency finds Google's search remarketing catches the highest-intent visitors.
- Turn optimized targeting off in remarketing ad groups. Google turns it off in its own example aimed at past customers, and Tsvi Machluf values Demand Gen for serving only to the lists you set.
- Keep Meta retargeting inside broad campaigns, but run Google's as a separate Demand Gen campaign. On Google, Tsvi Machluf and The Paid Search Podcast's Joey Biddner choose Demand Gen over Performance Max for dedicated remarketing.
- Keep Demand Gen remarketing a small line and judge it on a holdout of total sales. Wojo Media says modelled credit still isn't a holdout, and Jetfuel Agency warns that Meta and Google both claim the same retargeted sale.
- Exclude recent buyers, watch reach and frequency, and match creative to where each visitor stopped. Demand Gen takes no manual frequency cap (Google), so Doctor Ads watches reach and average frequency instead. The exclusions follow Wojo Media and Jetfuel Agency, and the creative follows Google's advice to tailor it to people who already know you.
Our judgment, built from Tsvi Machluf, Jetfuel, Google, Jon Loomer, The Paid Search Podcast, Measured, Wojo Media and Doctor Ads: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 9 sourcesGoogle says Video campaign frequency caps are set per campaign by impressions or views per day, week or month, count shared videos across campaigns, and apply only to in-stream and bumper ads.
“When a user reaches the frequency cap, Google stops showing this campaign to the user. This only applies to in-stream and bumper ads in the auction.”
Google turns optimized targeting on for all campaigns by default; it may shift spend away from your chosen audience signals, and you can turn it off to reach only your own customers.
“If optimized targeting finds better performing traffic, it may reduce or stop serving traffic on your signals.”
Google says your data segments and customer lists need at least 100 active users in the last 30 days to serve on Display or YouTube; lists below that threshold won't show ads.
“If your list doesn't meet these thresholds, ads won't serve.”
Google's Demand Gen advice: use optimized targeting on prospecting, remarketing for first-party segments, the new customer acquisition goal for new buyers, and wait for 50 conversions before judging.
“Do not evaluate performance until the campaign has generated at least 50 conversions.”
Google's Demand Gen can target website visitors, YouTube viewers and customer lists, or exclude past customers, and Google advises separate ad groups for audiences with distinct creative.
“Advertisers with distinct targeting strategies and corresponding creatives should separate each target audience into individual ad groups.”
Google says Display Ads campaigns are moving into Demand Gen as Google Display Network. New ones can only be created there, and existing ones stay editable until migrated. Timelines may change.
“New Google Display Ads campaigns can only be created within Demand Gen.”
Joey Biddner of The Paid Search Podcast prefers Demand Gen over Performance Max for dedicated remarketing because it can target a specific audience.
“unlike performance max, you can make a demand gen campaign specifically target an audience.”
Wojo Media, which sells YouTube ads, says to separate site visitors from channel viewers, exclude buyers, start near one impression per user per week, and remember modeled credit is not a holdout.
“Data-driven attribution can provide a more balanced allocation than a simple last-click model, but modelled credit still isn't a holdout.”
Measured, drawing on 25,000+ experiments across 160+ enterprise brands, says platforms heavily over-report retargeting, while social prospecting is reported accurately or under-reported. It gives no adjustment figures.
“within a single platform, prospecting and remarketing routinely sit far apart in measured incrementality while showing near-identical platform-reported ROAS.”
Doctor Ads says remarketing always looks profitable in attribution, so test it with Conversion Lift. Google Ads has manual frequency caps for Display and Video but not Demand Gen (as of August 2026).
“always looks profitable”
In one Measured demo example, Meta prospecting and remarketing showed near-identical platform ROAS, but geo tests found remarketing only about 39% incremental vs about 93% for prospecting. Test size is not given.
“a lower funnel remarketing tactic had roughly 61% of its platform-claimed conversions exposed as non-incremental”
Relevant Audience, relaying Google, says Demand Gen view-through bidding becomes video-only, expands to the Display Network, and is on by default for new campaigns. Google gave no rollout dates.
“Separate the conversion column you report on from the one you optimise on.”
Jetfuel, a Meta and Google agency, suggests short retargeting windows on Meta, search retargeting on branded terms, excluding buyers, and 15 to 25% of paid budget for retargeting. No data.
“Running Meta and Google retargeting simultaneously creates a double-counting problem.”
Jon Loomer says broad or Advantage+ delivery already spends roughly 20% to 25% of budget on past visitors, engagers and customers, so a separate retargeting campaign reaches them twice.
“just reaches them twice”
Tsvi Machluf, a Google Ads consultant, says Demand Gen fills a mid-funnel remarketing gap between PMax and Shopping, but needs 1,000+ users and enough conversions, and doesn't pay for cheap quick buys.
“If your Shopping campaigns are not yet profitable, adding Demand Gen is spending money to build awareness you cannot convert.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer