Should we run creative testing in a cheaper English-speaking market than our main one, then move the winners to the main market by post ID?
Our answer
Test in a cheaper English-speaking market only if its buyers convert like your main market's. Move winners to the main market as the same post, and confirm them on cost per purchase before scaling.
- Confidence
- Low
- Strongest proof
- 3 Meta rules
- 4 datasets, 4 practitioners
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 11 statements
MMI
GG
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA cheaper market can flatter a test. Marin Istvanic moved one client's testing from the US to the UK, where conversion rates ran 30% higher. The hit rate rose from 15% to 28%. He credits a more forgiving test, not better ads.
Cheaper ads don't mean buyers behave alike. AdManage.ai's data shows US sales ads paid a median 1.76 times the UK CPM in the same accounts and drew different click-through rates. Game Growth Advisor trusts revenue reads only from a market like your real spenders.
Meta allows you to move a winner as the same post. You can duplicate an ad with its reactions, comments and shares, or run the existing post. A Facebook post on Instagram placements doesn't show the Instagram post's engagement.
Our judgment
- Choose a test market by how its buyers convert, not by its CPM. Lebesgue warns that lower ad costs don't always mean lower acquisition costs, and AdManage.ai's same-account data shows the US to UK gap in reported cost per purchase at only 1.11 times.
- Treat a cheaper market's winners as candidates and confirm them in the main market before scaling. AdManage.ai says a test must still meet purchase and margin targets, and Istvanic launches revived winners in the testing campaign at standard budget, not straight into scaling.
- Move a winner within one ad account, using the ID from the Page's posts list. Meta's copy and paste does not cross ad accounts, and Meta advises against post IDs copied from a URL, which differs from Marcus Burke's tip to copy the ID from the URL.
- Expect Instagram engagement to stay behind when a Facebook post runs in Instagram placements. Meta's rule and Marcus Burke's understanding agree on this.
Our judgment, built from Marin Istvanic, Lebesgue, Game Growth Advisor, AdManage.ai, Meta and Marcus Burke: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
11 statements from 6 sourcesMeta's help page says a duplicated ad can carry over its existing reactions, comments and shares, but only once if the creative was customized by placement. Ads cannot be copied across ad accounts.
“When you duplicate your ad you have the option to carry over its existing engagement.”
Meta's help page says you can turn existing Facebook Page posts into ads, using the post ID from the Page's ID column, not one copied from a URL. Editing the ad also changes the original post.
“Modifying details on the ad, such as adding a phone number, will also change the information on the existing post you selected.”
Meta's help page says you can make ads from published Instagram posts. If you use a Facebook post on Instagram placements, the ad will not show the Instagram post's engagement.
“If you choose to create an ad from the existing Facebook post for an Instagram placement, your total engagement metrics (such as likes) will not show engagement from the Instagram post.”
AdManage, which sells an ad launch tool, found US-targeted Meta sales ad sets paid a median 1.76x the UK CPM in the same accounts. It has no data on whether UK creative winners also win in the US.
“Median within-account US/UK CPM ratio 1.76x”
AdManage, which sells an ad launch tool, found US Meta link CTR a median 1.13x the UK's within the same accounts, but US CPMs about 76% higher and cost per link click about 53% higher.
“A stronger US CTR therefore does not prove that a US audience inherently likes an ad more.”
AdManage's Meta data on accounts selling in both markets puts the median US purchase CPA only 1.11x the UK's, against a 1.76x CPM ratio. Observational, on reported purchases, not new-customer CAC.
“reported purchase CPA is not first-time customer CAC.”
Marin Istvanic relaunches old ads that spent over $10K and did well, using the same post ID to keep their social proof, in the testing campaign. He says 6 or 7 of 10 become winners again.
“6-7 out of every 10 revivals become active winners again.”
An operator says one client's creative hit rate rose from 15% in the US to 28% after moving testing to the UK, where conversion rates were 30% higher. Winners moved to the US by post ID.
“Moved all creative testing to the UK. Hit rate jumped to 28%”
Lebesgue's 2026 Meta CPM table, with sample undisclosed, lists the US at $16.08, UK $11.81, Germany $9.05 and India $1.36. It says to judge markets on CPA and ROAS, not CPM.
“Conversion rates, purchasing power, shipping costs, and average order value all influence campaign profitability”
Marcus Burke says duplicating an ad by post ID still wipes its Instagram engagement, as he understands it. He puts test budget at about 20% of usual spend (40k a month on 200k).
“While this still wipes the Instagram engagement based on my understanding”
Game Growth Advisor, writing about mobile game launches, says retention can be read from any market but revenue only from one like your real spenders, and ad sets need about $300 to $500 a day.
“trust retention and stability from anywhere, but only trust revenue from a market that resembles your global spenders.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer