Should we target by subreddit, interest or keyword?
Our answer
Target Reddit by subreddit first, with 3 to 5 closely related communities per ad group. Layer high-intent problem keywords onto a cluster that works. Add interests only to scale a message that already converts.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 3 official rules
- 9 practitioners, 1 opinion or claim
- Sources
- 10 sources
- 13 statements
- RAA
DES
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAgencies start with small groups of related subreddits. Elevarus picks three to five per ad group, and DropCommerce, a dropshipping app maker, tests 3 to 5 at a time. AI Advantage Agency finds interest-only targeting too broad for most ecommerce conversion campaigns.
Keywords are a layer on communities, not a starting point. AI Advantage Agency adds 10 to 20 problem-statement keywords per ad group on top of subreddit targeting, and ECORN, a Shopify agency, also layers them. Enrich Labs warns against bidding on rant language.
Community targeting reaches people who engage with a subreddit wherever they browse on Reddit (PPC Land). Reddit's guide seeds automated targeting with 1 to 5 communities and 1 to 3 keywords.
Our judgment
Six of the agencies and vendors that advise stores on Reddit start with communities, and the one that starts with interests does so to test messaging, so we start there, with a few per ad group. We add keywords only on a community ad group that already works, limited to high-intent problem phrases and checked against search terms weekly. The agencies that use keywords layer them onto communities, and Enrich Labs adds them when it needs scale. We keep Reddit's automated targeting or Max as a separate test cell, because its results are Reddit's own figures.
Our judgment, built from Elevarus, DropCommerce, AI Advantage Agency, Enrich Labs, ECORN, Sagum, Stackmatix and Reddit: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
13 statements from 10 sourcesReddit says its ads can target by interest, by community across over 100K active communities, by keyword, or by automated targeting that reads ad creative, landing page and user behavior.
“Go niche or go broad spanning Reddit users in over 100K active communities”
Reddit claims its automated Max campaigns cut CPA 17% and raised results 27% in 2025 split tests against standard campaigns over 21 days. This is Reddit's own claim; it also offers audience suggestions and controls.
“Max decreased CPA by 17% and increased results by 27%.”
PPC Land says Reddit community targeting has never meant placement inside one subreddit; it reaches users who engage with a community across their feeds. Reddit's new planner adds conversation summaries.
“Community targeting on the platform has never meant placement inside a single subreddit.”
Enrich Labs, which sells an AI marketing agent, advises starting Reddit ads with 5-15 communities, clustered into separate ad groups, and pausing communities with spend but no qualified events. No data.
“Start with 5-15 communities, not 200.”
Sagum, an agency running Reddit campaigns, advises excluding communities hostile to your category and building ad groups by subreddit, not one big campaign. It says the first 30 days are for signal, not scale.
“The goal in the first 30 days isn't scale. It's signal.”
Stackmatix, which sells paid media management, calls community targeting Reddit's most powerful feature, and advises starting with one method like interests, then layering in keywords or subreddits as you scale. No data.
“Community targeting, or subreddit targeting, is Reddit's most powerful and distinctive feature.”
ECORN, a Shopify agency, advises grouping closely related subreddits into separate Reddit ad groups instead of one broad audience, so community quality and creative response can be compared.
“The safest structure is to group closely related subreddits instead of combining every potentially relevant audience into one broad ad group.”
Reddit advises a store without a catalog to launch a Conversion campaign with Reddit Max, using automated targeting seeded with 1 to 3 keywords and 1 to 5 communities. Reddit sells the ads.
“Use automated targeting with 1-3 keywords and 1-5 communities.”
Adwave, an ad platform that buys Reddit, suggests small businesses start at $5 to $20 a day on a few relevant communities for a couple of weeks, then scale what works.
“The goal of the initial budget is learning, not immediate scale.”
Elevarus, an agency selling Reddit ad work, says Reddit product ads suit research-driven buys in active subreddit categories, and to plan for 60 to 90 conversions and a 30-day learning window.
“Plan for 60 to 90 conversions before you judge ROAS against Meta.”
AI Advantage Agency, which sells Reddit campaign work, suggests each ad group pair one large subreddit with two to four smaller ones and add 10 to 20 keywords. It gives no data behind the mix.
“Never target Tier 1 only.”
AI Advantage Agency, which sells Reddit ads management, says interest-only targeting is too broad for ecommerce conversion, and communities discussing a pain point convert better than product category ones.
“The communities where buyers discuss their pain points convert better than the communities where they discuss product categories.”
DropCommerce says to start Reddit ads with subreddit targeting rather than interests, building 20 to 40 subreddits and testing 3 to 5 at a time. Its claim that niche subreddits convert better has no data.
“Always start with subreddit targeting. Interest targeting pulls from Reddit's inferred data and tends to produce broader, lower-intent audiences.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer