Should Reddit ads allow comments, and how should we handle them?
Our answer
Turn comments on for a Reddit ad only when someone can answer within hours. Pin a brand reply to the likeliest objection, and keep comments off or locked on ads nobody can watch.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 official rule
- 4 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 6 sources
- 7 statements
- R
TESE
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentComments are your choice ad by ad. Reddit turns them off on every new ad until you allow them. It lets you reply, pin your own comment, lock, remove and mark spam.
Agencies open comments only when someone is watching. Balistro (media and measurement agency) wants someone answering within the hour and locks comments otherwise. Tailored Edge Marketing (consumer brand marketing agency) keeps them closed when nobody can monitor. Stackmatix (paid media agency) replies within hours.
Agencies answer the thread fast and learn from it. Enrich Labs (AI marketing agent maker) advises pinning or posting a clarifying first brand comment and answering fast. Tailored Edge Marketing and ECORN (Shopify agency) feed repeated objections into the next ad.
Our judgment
Decide comments ad by ad on whether someone can answer within hours, a test that joins Reddit's default of comments off with the agencies' practice of opening them only when someone is watching. Pin one brand comment that answers the likeliest objection, taken from the objections Tailored Edge Marketing's audit lists before launch. Judge an ad with comments on by cost per purchase and conversion rate, not by how busy the thread is.
Our judgment, built from Reddit, Balistro, Tailored Edge Marketing, Stackmatix, Enrich Labs and ECORN: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
7 statements from 6 sourcesReddit's help says comments are off on new ads unless you allow them, and gives tools to lock, remove, pin or mark comments as spam. It advises answering questions and fair criticism but ignoring trolls.
“If you receive completely unmerited negative comments, don't feel obligated to respond. Don't feed the troll.”
Reddit says free-form ads suit brand stories, founder intros and how-tos, and claims more time spent in the post lowers cost per action, without giving a figure.
“The more time users spend with your ad in-post, the lower your ad’s cost per action.”
Enrich Labs, which sells an AI marketing agent, says on Reddit the comment thread is part of the ad: pin a clarifying brand comment, answer questions fast, and keep answering even on losing ads. No data.
“Ignoring comments. On Reddit the thread is the ad. Unanswered hostility trains the next viewer to skip.”
Stackmatix, which sells Reddit ad management, advises replying to comments on promoted Reddit posts within hours, taking detailed issues to private messages, and never deleting negative comments.
“Never delete negative comments (creates backlash)”
Tailored Edge Marketing, an agency, says Reddit turns off comments on new ads by default; open them only with a team to manage replies, plan answers to likely objections, and judge ads on CPA, not thread activity.
“Deleting or dodging a valid objection can create a larger credibility problem than the original comment.”
ECORN, which sells Shopify and paid channel work, says treat Reddit ad comments as qualitative data and pause ads that draw attention without site activity or expose a message mismatch.
“Pause an ad when it attracts attention without useful site activity, when comments expose a clear message mismatch, or when the landing page fails to support the promise.”
Balistro, an agency, says to turn on comments for Reddit ads only if someone can answer within the hour, including criticism, and otherwise lock them. Its claim that answered threads convert better has no data.
“If you cannot commit to that, lock comments rather than letting an unmoderated pile-on tank your campaign.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer