Should we spend more in the post-holiday window and other cheaper periods?
Our answer
Run a ROAS goal or cost cap with budget room, so spend rises by itself when post-holiday auctions get cheaper. Plan a bigger push only where your buyers are in market then.
- Confidence
- Low to medium
- Strongest proof
- 1 Meta rule
- 5 datasets, 6 practitioners, 4 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 14 sources
- 16 statements
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentAds got cheaper right after the holidays. In Biddyco's large US accounts, CPMs ran 24% below October from December 29 to January 4 and 17% below over January. Meta-reported cost per purchase ran 24% and 7% below.
Clicks were cheaper too. Meta cost per click fell to $1.08 in late December 2025, below October's $1.09 and the $1.62 of Black Friday and Cyber Monday (Wicked Reports, an attribution software maker, across what it calls hundreds of ecommerce accounts).
A capped campaign with spare budget can catch cheap post-holiday days. Common Thread Collective, an ecommerce ad agency, runs capped campaigns with inflated budgets and accepts daily swings so Meta can buy more when auctions are cheap.
Our judgment
- Let a capped campaign flex spend into cheap post-holiday windows. This carries Common Thread Collective's budget approach, inflated budgets with cost controls that accept daily swings, over to the post-holiday window, which CTC does not address.
- Treat Wicked Reports' December click results as unsettled. Wicked tracked them only to December 31, while its October clicks rose from 0.82 to 1.40 ROAS over the same period.
- Read Wicked Reports' advice to move acquisition budget earlier into October as a separate case. It argues for spending earlier, not against a post-holiday push (Budgets and launch timing for seasonal peaks).
- Judge a cheap window on its incremental results, not its CPM. Biddyco's and Wicked's figures are costs and attributed sales, and Haus says weeks are not interchangeable for buying incremental results.
Our judgment, built from Common Thread Collective, Wicked Reports, Haus and Biddyco: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
16 statements from 14 sourcesWorkMagic, a lift testing vendor, says judge Q4 spend on cost per incremental order, not CPM, allow for conversion lag before stop rules, and cut spend after the holidays step by step.
“A higher CPM matters only if conversion rate and order value don't rise with it; judge Q4 spend on cost per incremental order, not on CPM.”
Wicked Reports tied Meta ad clicks from Q4 2025 to purchases through December 31 across hundreds of accounts: October clicks went from 0.82 ROAS in October to 1.40 by year end. Exact account count not given.
“We tied every Meta ad click from Q4 2025 to the purchases it produced through December 31, across hundreds of eCommerce accounts.”
Aazar Ali Shad advised a kids' product brand planning about 600k over four months to avoid Black Friday's CPM spike unless discounting deeply, and to hold about 10% of stock for cheaper January.
“If you are not willing to discount deeply, and he wasn't, Black Friday is an expensive place to stand.”
Cherene Aubert says Meta CPMs spike 200-400% in November and December in reach reports, so reach new people before Black Friday and use January for a creative reset. The figure has no sample.
“If you’ve ever looked at your Rolling Reach report in Meta or any other ad platform, you’ll see CPMs get insanely expensive.”
Marketing Brew reports some agencies moving holiday budget into a late December to January window because CPMs are up and discount margins thinner. Meta's price per ad rose 12% year on year in Q1 and Q2 2026.
“Some media buyers told us that select clients are planning to purchase ads during the “Q5” period that runs from late December into January, rather than spending during the holidays.”
In Wicked Reports' Q4 2025 Meta cohorts, October clicks rose from 0.82 to 1.40 ROAS by December 31, while early December and holiday clicks never broke even (0.96 and 0.88). Later cohorts had less time to settle.
“Shift acquisition budget earlier into October, where the settle multiplier is highest.”
GeistM's own Meta data, sample undisclosed, shows 2026 CPMs month over month up 11% in March, down 18% in July and up 13% in September as the Q4 squeeze began.
“early stages of the Q4 squeeze”
Home Life Brands spends hard in September and October because those customers rebuy in November and December, and says customers won in November and December are lower quality.
Wicked Reports says Meta cost per click in Q4 2025 was $1.09 in October, $1.62 in BFCM (up 49%) and $1.08 in late December. BFCM still had the lowest first-month CAC of any Q4 window, at $179.
“up 49% over October”
Biddyco's large US Meta accounts saw consumer-brand CPMs rise 35% in the week of Nov 24 and 57% on Black Friday versus October. It says holiday ads should be live and learning by early November.
“belongs in the September or October batch”
Cody Plofker says January is the Super Bowl for health and wellness brands: new-year habits and rising intent while CPMs drop. A plan for a new sleep brand, no data.
“your Super Bowl. New year, new habits, everyone finally ready to fix their sleep, all while Q5 CPMs drop and Q1 intent spikes.”
Meta's 2026 holiday guides treat late December into the new year as its own fresh start shopping phase, after Discovery, Deal and Gifting. They give no numbers or spend advice for it.
“The fresh start phase, from late December into the new year”
Northbeam says Meta CPMs rose 10 to 20% on average from January 2026, a yearly pattern, and median CAC across all channels rose 10.34% year over year, with brands above $50M in revenue holding up better.
“CPMs increased 10%-20% on average starting January 2026, a normal trend I’ve seen several years in a row now.”
Haus, which sells a mix model, says most measurement treats every week alike; its model fits a daily efficiency factor per channel, and it says in-season holdouts can be as small as 5-10%.
“much of the industry's measurement still treats weeks as interchangeable and a dollar of media as equally effective year-round”
CTC sets Meta budgets higher than it expects to spend and uses cost controls so the bid, not the budget, paces spend, accepting daily spend swings as Meta finds cheaper moments.
“Inflated budgets with cost controls allow for fluidity of market access.”
Sam Palero, whose agency also sells a course, says spending more on historically better days of the week brings big efficiencies; his 20% gain covers days, placements and gender together.
“What we've realized is that just spending more money on better performing days of the week can lead to massive efficiencies in the overall business.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer