How should we measure our share of search against competitors?
Our answer
Measure two shares against the same named competitors and read them as a trend over several months. Take brand share of search from Google Trends, and share of voice across fixed non-brand keywords from a rank tracker.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 5 official rules
- 1 dataset, 7 practitioners, 2 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 12 sources
- 15 statements
- G
TDMWOMMI
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentBrand searches track awareness and can run ahead of market share. Across 31 brands, higher awareness came with a larger share of search (Google and Tracksuit). Les Binet found it often leads market share by 6 to 12 months, as both report.
Visibility on category searches needs its own measure. Mediaworks, a UK search agency, layers share of voice across performance keywords onto brand share of search. Semrush weights each keyword in share of voice by its searches.
Google Trends is rough for small brands. It is a noisy sample that shows low-volume terms as 0 (Google). Deep Marketing, an Italian digital marketing agency, finds share of search less reliable for rarely searched products and low-volume niches.
Our judgment
Track brand share of search and keyword share of voice side by side rather than one of them. One measures demand for your brand and the other your visibility on category searches, as Semrush and Mediaworks separate them. Read share of search as a direction over several months rather than a monthly score, since Google adds noise to Trends data and Deep Marketing advises reasoning on the medium-term trend. A small or local business whose brand shows as 0 in Trends should fall back on its own Search Console branded data and a map-grid share of voice. That applies Google's note on low-volume terms and Semrush's Map Rank Tracker.
Our judgment, built from Semrush, Mediaworks, Google, Deep Marketing and Tracksuit: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 12 sourcesGoogle Trends shows a sampled, normalized 0 to 100 index, drops low-volume terms (shown as 0), duplicates and AI searches, and adds noise, so treat it as one data point among others.
“Google Trends is not a scientific poll and shouldn't be confused with polling data.”
Google Trends compares up to 8 groups of up to 50 terms each, ignores misspellings, synonyms and plural variants, and lets you add terms together with a plus sign.
“You won't get results for misspellings, spelling variations, synonyms, plural, or singular versions of your terms.”
Google Search Console's branded query filter splits searches that include your brand from those that do not, noting non-branded traffic can show new audience growth. Sites with few impressions lack it.
“Branded traffic often comes from users already familiar with your site, while non-branded traffic can indicate new audience growth.”
Ahrefs, which sells Rank Tracker, defines share of voice as your site's estimated share of clicks across all tracked keywords, the same as other tools' visibility score.
“shows the percentage of traffic that your target website gets, compared to the traffic of other websites.”
Westwood One, which sells radio ads, explains share of search: a brand's searches divided by all brand searches in its category, using Google Trends data for up to five brands over a period such as 12 months.
“Share of search divides the number of searches for a brand over all the searches for brands in a category and competitive set.”
Make Influence, an influencer platform, says Google Search Console and Google Trends can show branded search rising after a campaign for free, but only as a correlation; proving cause needs a lift study or holdout.
“neither proves the campaign caused it.”
Kevin Indig says 91% of AI search citations appear in only one of ChatGPT, Perplexity or AI Overviews, so tracking should work like polling a panel of prompts, not like Google rank tracking.
“Prompt tracking should be closer to polling and focus groups than SEO rank tracking.”
Deep Marketing, an agency, relays research that share of brand searches leads market share by 6 to 12 months, and says to compare brand names in Google Trends and read the trend, not the absolute value.
“It remains a strong correlation, not a mechanical guarantee, and should be validated on your own market.”
Search Engine Roundtable reports Google is piloting AI performance insights in Merchant Center for some US accounts, showing share of voice in AI Mode and AI Overviews for organic traffic only.
“Paid Ads traffic isn't included in this report.”
PPC Land, on Semrush's study of 1,200+ brands, says AI mentions come from brand authority and category fit while citations come from content depth. ChatGPT cited 15.4 sources per answer, Gemini 3.3.
“Mentions come from brand authority and category fit. Citations come from content depth”
Microsoft's Bing Webmaster Tools now previews reports on how a site is cited in Copilot and Bing AI answers, including citation share; it shows no competitor domains or traffic share.
“It does not expose competitor domains, represent traffic share, or assign quality scores to content.”
Google and Tracksuit, studying 31 brands in Australia and New Zealand, found higher awareness went with higher share of search; at 30% awareness each 5 points gained added 5 points of share.
“brands with higher awareness consistently commanded a larger Share of Search”
Semrush, which sells the tool, explains SEO share of voice as your share of estimated organic traffic across a keyword set, says there is no universal benchmark, and to track each location separately.
“There's no universal benchmark for a "good" share of voice percentage”
Mediaworks, a UK search agency, defines share of search as your brand's share of category brand searches; above your market share may signal growth, below it possible decline.
“If your SoS is above your market share, you may be on track for growth”
Google says its redesigned Trends Explore page uses Gemini to suggest and compare up to eight related terms, and doubles the rising queries shown, starting on desktop.
“We've also increased the number of terms you can compare, and we've doubled the amount of rising queries we show on each timeline”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer