How should we separate brand from non-brand search traffic in reporting?
Our answer
Report brand and non-brand search as separate lines for organic and paid, never one blended number. Use Search Console's branded filter, check it against your own brand-term list and judge growth on non-brand.
- Confidence
- Medium
- Strongest proof
- 4 official rules
- 4 datasets, 4 practitioners, 3 opinions or claims
- Sources
- 11 sources
- 15 statements
- G
PSPES
New here? Take the 1-minute tour
Why this is the answer
3 reasons and our judgmentA blended number hides where growth came from. Patrick Stox, a technical SEO consultant, says it lets brand demand from PR, ads and word of mouth pass as an SEO win, and calls non-branded growth the cleaner signal.
Google's branded filter splits queries for you but can't be edited. Practical Ecommerce found it skipped branded items and counted competitor names, and Spotibo, an SEO monitoring software maker, found one project clearly misclassified.
Branded paid search flatters the account. Common Thread Collective (CTC) found a median incrementality factor of 0.27 times for branded search against 0.67 times for non-brand, so blended returns look better than they are (Bidnamic, Konvtrack).
Our judgment
- Use Google's filter for the split and keep your own brand-term list as a check. Spotibo found the filter reaches clicks a custom list cannot see, while Patrick Stox, Practical Ecommerce and Spotibo itself found it misclassifies some queries and cannot be edited.
- Check in your own property whether branded and non-branded clicks add up to the total before reporting shares. Patrick Stox says they will not, and Spotibo says the filter classifies all clicks.
- Read brand search as demand built by all your marketing rather than as SEO's result. Patrick Stox, Practical Ecommerce and PalV's DM tie branded rises to PR, ads and campaigns.
- Apply the same split to paid search. Bidnamic and Konvtrack advise keeping brand in its own campaign, and the test databases of CTC and Stella show branded search adds far less than it reports.
Our judgment, built from Spotibo, Patrick Stox, Practical Ecommerce, PalV's DM, Bidnamic, Konvtrack, Common Thread Collective and Stella: our reading of these sources, not a finding from any one of them.
What the sources say
15 statements from 11 sourcesGoogle Search Console's branded query filter splits searches that include your brand from those that do not, noting non-branded traffic can show new audience growth. Sites with few impressions lack it.
“Branded traffic often comes from users already familiar with your site, while non-branded traffic can indicate new audience growth.”
Google says Business Profile performance data covers views, searches and actions from both organic results and Google Ads, and the searches metric updates at the start of each month.
“Performance data includes views, searches, and actions from both organic search results and Google Ads.”
Google says Performance Max brand exclusions apply only to Search, Shopping and YouTube search inventory, and that brand exclusions for Search campaigns are moving into AI Max.
“For Performance Max, brand exclusions apply to only Search, Shopping, and YouTube search inventory, but you also have the option to allow your Shopping ads to appear in searches for excluded brands.”
Konvtrack, a Google Ads agency, says bid on your brand name if competitors do; otherwise prove it pays with a 4 to 6 week geo holdout on all brand conversions. It shows no test data of its own.
“A 4-6 week geographic holdout, measured on all brand conversions rather than paid ones alone, is the most honest way to decide.”
PalV's DM, which sells SEO, says to split branded from non-branded search by filtering brand terms from Search Console queries, report both, and use non-branded traffic for ROI. Share ranges are estimates.
“Excluding branded traffic from the revenue base used in an ROI calculation typically produces a smaller, more conservative, and more defensible number”
Patrick Stox, an SEO consultant, says report branded and non-branded search as separate lines, since non-branded growth is the cleaner signal, and keep your own branded term list beyond Google's filter.
“Non-branded growth is the cleaner signal.”
Bidnamic, which sells Google Ads management, says to bid on branded search but report it separately, since branded ROAS can hide weak non-brand results. Its 900% versus 2,000% and 300% ROAS figures are illustrations.
“It is important to bid on branded search, but you need to report on it separately from non-branded to see how the account is actually performing.”
CTC, which sells ad buying and measurement, says its geo holdout tests put Google branded search at a median 0.27x incremental ROAS, against 1.14x for Facebook acquisition and 0.67x for non-brand Google.
“That does not mean branded search is worthless, but it means it should not compete for budget against channels with meaningfully higher incrementality.”
Across 225 geo tests on its platform, Stella, which sells geo testing, found Google branded search lowest, at a median 0.70x incremental ROAS (typical range 0.32x to 0.89x). Its brands are mostly US Shopify stores.
“Reduce to defensive floor (prevent competitor conquest), redirect savings to higher-iROAS channels.”
Birdeye, which sells listings software, reports for large brands that 86% of Google Business Profile impressions come from category searches, and impressions per location fell 53.8% while actions fell about 5%.
“Impressions per location have declined by 53.8%, while customer actions have dropped by only about 5%”
Kevin Indig, citing Dreamdata's B2B data, says branded campaigns returned 1,299% ROAS against 68% for non-branded but mostly capture existing demand; the test is whether revenue holds when brand spend drops.
“Most brands' highest-ROAS campaigns are capturing demand that already exists.”
Ann Smarty found Search Console's new brand filter misses some branded queries and wrongly includes others. She says branded terms below position 1 or under 50% CTR may mean a competitor is outranking you.
“If your average position for a branded term isn't number 1, or if the click-through rate is lower than 50%, a competitor might be outranking you for your own name”
Search Engine Journal reports Google's John Mueller saying Search Console's branded queries filter cannot be customized with your own terms for now, and is unavailable for sub-properties or sites with few impressions.
“This filter isn't available for sub-properties (for example, https://example.com/blog/) or for sites with a low number of impressions.”
Spotibo, which sells SEO software, found across 10 of its projects that Search Console's new brand filter put average brand share at 11.9% versus 19.3% by its old regex method. It advises spot-checking.
“The direction is almost always the same: old method makes brand look bigger, non-brand look smaller.”
Google's Search Console filter splits queries into branded and non-branded using an AI-assisted system that may misclassify some. It says branded queries usually rank higher and earn higher click-through rates.
“some queries may occasionally be misidentified.”
In the full answer
For readers who sign in- What to do this week3 steps
- The numbers behind it3 figures from cited sources
- Where each source standsA chart placing each source on the question
- The strongest disagreementThe best case against the answer, from a cited source
- How sure we areWhat its confidence rests on, and what would change the answer